tilburs wrote:
What vernacular would you use to clearly state what a person is that has been convicted by USADA of a doping infraction then?
Part of the problem is that "convicted" to many of us (including Oxford...) carries the weight of the legal system. Not the WADA/ USADA system of voluntary rules to participate in the events which adhere to those rules, but the court of laws of the country. She's not "convicted" because she was never declared guilty of a criminal offense by a judge or jury. It's one of the words that really shouldn't be used in a vernacular sense, because even if that wasn't your intention (I'll believe you that it wasn't) it brings connotations to people of a person in handcuffs in a courtroom and charged with a criminal offense. This casts the whole thing in a different and much more serious light, and makes some people think you're deliberately attempting to make it look worse. It would be like saying "my friend convicted me of bailing on our plans" or "the referee convicted the football player of pass interference". You can also observe this by noting when a reporter will use the word "convicted": it's always in a court of law. Never by a non-legal organization. Even when Goodell punishes a player under the personal conduct policy, it is never referred to as a "conviction" for precisely this reason. Apparently a race allowed her to compete, which isn't so much a loophole as "well I got let go from one job so I went and found another". If an organization doesn't adhere to WADA, or the ban hasn't started yet, it doesn't apply.
Sometimes it seems like people on this forum want all infractions to be responded to with ritual suicide. There are rules, and there are penalties (sometimes with latitude) for infractions of those rules. There's no reason to expect that someone will self-penalize in excess of those penalties, any more than you or I would voluntarily not drive for six months after a minor speeding ticket.
This all coming from THC makes the whole situation even more ridiculous.
The point is, ladies and gentleman, that speed, for lack of a better word, is good. Speed is right, Speed works. Speed clarifies, cuts through, and captures the essence of the evolutionary spirit.