I'm not Jim, but I have been fit by Jim and also independently pre-Jim worked out the benefits of reach and aerobar tilt so I'll comment a little.
It's more than just the sum of parts a+b+c. it's a synergy of a few things that when done right is a very fast and comfortable setup. If you understand the "Cobb Slam" then imagine this as a aerobar corollary to that.
first of all, extended reach forces you to shrug to get there, if you don't move the seat forward. Shrugging is fast aerodynamically as well know. But with a flat aerobar pad and straight extensions, it didn't feel comfortable *to me* to have that position with the bars slammed, and it was hard to get "low". So it was either raise bars, go slow, or come up with something else.
I quickly discovered that ski bend extensions and tilted aerobar pads gave me a "backboard" or "foundation" for my shrugged and turtled upper body to lean into. This had the ancillary benefit of wanting to move my butt *back*, engaging glutes a little better, while relaxing back and relaxing arms. I also discovered that it "locked" my shrug and turtle in, so I could then just relax even more and still have that position. Finally, I found that this new configuration made it very easy to actually *reach* the previously "extra" reach I had thrown in, so even more relaxation resulted which is also fast.
That said, Jim helped me discover that by going even lower, and tilting even more, I could get lower and tilt more if that makes sense. By now I was at well below "recommended" pad stack and it still felt comfortable. No adjustments to crank length or weird saddle tilt necessary. He of course also validated my position, and with his great aerodynamic memory helped me to be sure that it was fast even though we didn't test.
For me, on my P5, I tilted the pads with washers under the front of the pads and got the biggest ski bends from USE/Tula on Wiggle or PBK or something. I really lock the heels of my palms into the "hook" of the shifter cluster as it exits the extension.
I also used diagonal Zipp Vuka Wing extenders to get extra reach on the P5. This was a work-around to the no longer existing Aduro Extra Low which would have been perfect for Jim's model of fitting.
Jim let me know if this PDF is your IP and I'll remove.
Eric
DFW_Tri wrote:
Let me clarify my question... there are probably 3 (maybe more?) ways to angle arms upward....(1) tilting the entire base bar; (2) just tilting the extensions independently of the base bar; (3) keeping base bar and extensions at the same angle of each other but using an extension type that necessarily angles the forearms upward (i.e., ski bend). My understanding is that Jim's article focused on number 2 and I was asking for a comparison of numbers 2 and 3. This sorta seemed to answered in the thread earlier but not exactly. I believe Jim answered a question about s v. Ski bends combined with independent extension pads tilts. I am simply looking at the aero benefit of achieving an upward angle through S or ski bends
Eric Reid
AeroFit |
Instagram Portfolio Aerodynamic Retul Bike Fitting
“You are experiencing the criminal coverup of a foreign backed fascist hostile takeover of a mafia shakedown of an authoritarian religious slow motion coup. Persuade people to vote for Democracy.â€