Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Prev Next
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
afrizzledfry wrote:
fulla wrote:
Has there ever been a race where so many contenders and race leaders have crashed due to the danger of the course?


I disagree with this mindset. That course was as dangerous as the riders chose to make it. That's decending, and bike racing in general. Abbott elected to go at her own pace downhill. It kept her safe and she almost took it all. I thought the course was great. Have to believe that tactical decisions caused most of those wrecks ("I'm gonna bomb this decent for an advantage")- though I can't say that definitively as it seems many of them were off camera.


Well I disagree with your mindset. Racing means trying to go as fast as possible and yes, that includes risk management and racing on the edge just like they do in short track speed skating, downhill skiing, cross country skiing (the descents and some really gnarly ones). But if you err slightly on the wrong side of the risk balance, does not mean that the course should not be design to the point that an athlete has to chose between racing fast and death/near death. If something goes wrong the course should be designed to minimize the injuries of the athlete that has lot control. Heck in short track speed skating they have pads all the way around the turns so if an athlete looses it at 50-60 kph then don't slam head first into the boards.

I think we want fast racing and a show and we want athletes to take risks where the outcome is win or lose, not win or being incapacitated/career ending/death. Right now Sergio Henao has a broken pelvis. Who knows if he bounces back. He is one of the top climbers around

i agree completely. it is debateable what is an acceptable level of technicality and crash potential. it is not debatable that measures should be taken to minimise consequences to athletes where there is a significant crash risk. hell, even DH mtb have pads on trees and thats a sport that is all about technicality and crash potential!

some pads on a few spots of that descent would not have been hard to achieve
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
Archibald wrote:
Same here. That was really bad. Hope she will be fine.

What a finish and gold for the Dutch...but please send us the news from the sound of the mountain.

I am glad that Lizzie Armisted did not medal after skipping her dope tests.

https://www.thesun.co.uk/...-victoria-pendleton/
I'm disgusted LA was even allowed to start, who the &%@! Misses 3 consecutive doping tests and is still racing?

res, non verba
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [pk1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pk1 wrote:

i agree completely. it is debateable what is an acceptable level of technicality and crash potential. it is not debatable that measures should be taken to minimise consequences to athletes where there is a significant crash risk. hell, even DH mtb have pads on trees and thats a sport that is all about technicality and crash potential!

some pads on a few spots of that descent would not have been hard to achieve

bingo.

that's nearing the level of negligence on the part of the organizers.
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [echappist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i'm surprised no one has brought this up yet.. so i will:

abbot was doing a pretty darn good job holding them off. she had about 8k where she really had to have a solid solo effort.

a few things i thought (and i would love some ST engineering/mathematics here):

if she had:
- longer sleeves on her arm (hers were extremely short compared to the other girls)
- more aero helmet (was hers the most aero?)
- had di2 (vs the cables in the front of her mechanical set)
- more aero frame
- ditched the water bottle (she didn't drink from it once the final 8k)
- rode aero position vs in drop bars

would that have given her the extra few seconds she needed?

i know 8k is not a lot of pavement, but every little bit counts, right? is it possible?
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [RoYe] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
RoYe wrote:
devashish_paul wrote:
Archibald wrote:
Same here. That was really bad. Hope she will be fine.


What a finish and gold for the Dutch...but please send us the news from the sound of the mountain.

I am glad that Lizzie Armisted did not medal after skipping her dope tests.


https://www.thesun.co.uk/...-victoria-pendleton/
I'm disgusted LA was even allowed to start, who the &%@! Misses 3 consecutive doping tests and is still racing?

Firstly it is very clear that Lizzie Armitstead made some huge errors over the last year, which have should lead to some very large questions being asked and answered. Both of herself and of her governing body. However your statement above is a long way from true.

As I understand:

Test 1: She was where she told the testers she would be, however the hotel she was in refused to allow the tester access to her room. The tester then made minimal efforts to try and find her. She was then tested the following day. That doesn't excuse her completely, but it does appear as though she was not trying to miss a test.
Test 2: There was no attempt by the testing agency to test her, so she didn't miss her test. However, there are several forms that must be completed for every day stating the athlete's whereabouts and two of those forms gave conflicting information on her whereabouts. As a result the agency were unsure as to which of two places she was in and declared this a missed test. Again, it doesn't suggest that she was deliberately trying to miss the test.
Test 3: She has just cited personal family reasons for missing this test so that doesn't really cut it for me.

I also believe that she was tested extensively over that period as well, so to claim that she missed 3 consecutive doping tests is untrue. A more correct statement would be that out of many tests (more than 20?) a hotel blocked access to her for one, an admin error meant that two testers would have been required to definitely test her and it was therefore easier to just put it down as missed (as per the rules) and therefore she actually only 'missed' one test.

However, her initials are LA, and he never tested positive, so I'm not for one minute saying that she is definitely clean. She certainly won't be gaining any marks for intelligence this year and, guilty or innocent, will likely be tainted as a drugs cheat forever more. Maybe I just want to believe that she isn't taking drugs and am being naive, but once I looked into the circumstances surrounding the 'missed tests' I changed my initial "guilty - burn at stake" verdict to "undecided".
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [mag900] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mag900 wrote:
ThisIsIt wrote:
snaaijert wrote:
Abbott, Johansson, Longoborghini all ride for Wiggle High5. So in that light they basically enacted an Etixx vs. Stannard scenario ;) Purely trade teams you don't ride of course, unless you have a female Sagan coming up from behind. I agree you have to be willing to lose in order to win but getting on the podium counts a little bit more in the Olympics than at any other race, you do get to bring home some kind of hardware (look at the men's race yesterday, all three medallists were happy). And the other saying is, you have to be at the front in order to win the race ;)


Well they were going to catch Abbott if they just kept working and you'd have to figure she'd have nothing for a sprint. I guess I just don't get why she put her head down and buried herself without even trying to get the others to work especially if it was her team mate up the road? So aren't you saying that the riders that got 2,3 and 4th ride for the same team? And the one rider that wasn't on their team got gold? You couldn't fuck it up any worse than that if you tried :)

Johansson and Longoborhini should have been pulling the trade team card and forced that Dutch rider to work or let their trade team member win. Abbott should be super pissed one way or another.


yeah, that was so obvious being that it took them until 150m to go to catch her. had they been just a little less organized, then never would have caught her. if she sat up and "made" them work (as you incorrectly assume she would have been able to), that time soft pedaling could have been the difference between catching her and not catching her.

your expert background in cycling also COMPLETELY misses the fact that the 2nd chase pack closed to within 10 seconds of them so any jerking around trying to force the other 2 to work most definitely would have brought the 2 groups together and she would have been sprinting with 6 (or 7) and she's not a sprinter. she did what she had to do to maximize her performance (a bronze with a shot at gold) while you continue posting irrational posts on a message board.


this.

Guess what happened in the closing kms of the 2014 championships on ponferrada? Vos, Armitstead, Johansson, and guess who, Longo Borghini established a sizeable gap into the run-in. Guess what happened in that race?

it's funny that thisisit claims to watch a lot of cycling when s/he misses the connection to almost the exact same scenario two years ago
Last edited by: echappist: Aug 7, 16 20:43
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [Timtek] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Timtek wrote:
I wonder if any of that course is used in the tri bike course?

Yes. The first circuit which featured cobbles is used in the time trial. However, pavement has been laid down covering half the road and the pavement part will be used for the TT.

________
It doesn't really matter what Phil is saying, the music of his voice is the appropriate soundtrack for a bicycle race. HTupolev
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [ThisIsIt] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ThisIsIt wrote:
mag900 wrote:
because he thinks she was better off coming in at best 4th (likely worse with the 2nd chase group catching them) than driving the train to catch abbott and get at worst 4th (likely at worst 3rd as abbott was going to be dead once she was caught).


Well I think when she went to the front and just drove it on her own for most of the last km, there wasn't much if any chance of that chasing group catching them. I guess who knows if they would have started playing cat and mouse. She basically traded 3rd at best for 4th at worst in my mind, not to mention she got used by the other two riders who took gold and silver. No self respecting professional male rider would allow that to happen. I think the saying is, you have to be willing to lose in order to win.

There could be trade team relationships I'm unaware of though, but she basically rode as if she was a team mate of one of the other two riders.

The group cooperated beautifully until the last 800m or so, so it's not like she wasn't working her ass off. Emma, Mara and Elisa all ride for the same trade-team, it's the winner AvdB that's the odd one out - so trade team allegiance isn't the case here.

The part in bold works both ways. Too many world championships were determined by a hesitant chase - if you don't put everything into the chase you won't get to sprint for the medals to begin with... Pauline Ferrand-Prevot's 2014 Worlds win was exactly a case of nobody in a 10-strong chase group willing to do the work.

And if you want an example of "self-respecting male professionals" screwing that up, just look at Valverde in Worlds 2013, letting trade teammate Costa go and screw over national teammate Purito. Or, look at Valverde and Eddie B failing to cooperate at Worlds 2012 to catch Phil Gilbert.

The chasing trio worked perfectly until the catch was certain. After that, you don't always get to choose where you position yourself when there's another chase group behind.

ZONE3 - We Last Longer
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [snaaijert] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
[quote snaaijertHonest question. Seems like most women riders are much more allround (probably partially out of necessity) than the male riders. I guess in a flat flat stage someone like a Kirsten Wild or Bronzini? might be the fastest, but in any other scenario there just seems like a whole host of fast-ish women.[/quote]
Most of the women's races don't have extreme amounts of climbing in them, but are more similar to "classics-type" courses: short sharp hills, technical sectors. Except for the Giro Rosa, I can't think of a World Cup/Tour course that would really suit a climbing specialist.

Naturally, this lends itself to more of the stand-out female pros being more "Classics Specialist" type all-arounders with a decent sprint. There are a few exceptions - Abbott, Katie Hall and Ashley Moolman-Pasio are examples - but most of the field is on the Classics spectrum, from somewhat-better-climbers like Longo Borghini to the better-sprinters like Armitstead and Vos - and of course the pure sprinters like Shelley Olds, Wild and Riviera.

ZONE3 - We Last Longer
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [rmt] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
rmt wrote:
However, her initials are LA.

Her initials are EA.
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [knighty76] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
True!! Being a bit dumb there!!!
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [ahhchon] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ahhchon wrote:

<snip>

- rode aero position vs in drop bars

would that have given her the extra few seconds she needed?

I was thinking this too, and this seemed to be the biggest thing: not a very good 'aero' position on the road bike to do a solo effort like that, and constantly getting up out of the saddle. Compare to the form of the 3 chasers. She basically needed to do an 8k TT -- so ride it like a TT. Get low, get on the rivet, get narrow, head low and just hold it.
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [BrianB] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I missed the men's race. Does anyone know where I can buy/watch the full race? Ideally I'd like to download because high resolution and no buffer would be amazing.
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [SBRYYC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
SBRYYC wrote:
I missed the men's race. Does anyone know where I can buy/watch the full race? Ideally I'd like to download because high resolution and no buffer would be amazing.

If you have cable, and it includes the NBC sports network, you should be able to watch the event replay. I did that with the women's race last night, via the Roku app.
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [ahhchon] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ahhchon wrote:
if she had:
- longer sleeves on her arm (hers were extremely short compared to the other girls)
- more aero helmet (was hers the most aero?)
- had di2 (vs the cables in the front of her mechanical set)
- more aero frame
- ditched the water bottle (she didn't drink from it once the final 8k)
- rode aero position vs in drop bars

would that have given her the extra few seconds she needed?
Deeper wheels? Little hard to see, but looked like she was on 35s, only Longo Borghini was on deeper wheels.
An Evade might have been the next best upgrade.

Brian

Gonna buy a fast car, put on my lead boots, take a long, long drive
I may end up spending all my money, but I'll still be alive
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [sto] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
sto wrote:
There is no WAY Coryn would have made it over the climb in the top group. Hell, Evie and Megan got dropped, and they are way better climbers. Abbott is the best climber in the world, and she blew all but one rider off her wheel. Coryn, sadly would have had ZERO chance on this course.

Edit: I'm also quite shocked at how early Megan got dropped on the climb. Evie hung in for awhile and I thought she had a chance to bridge. Funny how the two who were "didn't deserve to be on the team" were the biggest players for the USA in the race.

This surprised me too. I think Mega would have had a better chance in holding off the three if she'd been the one off the front (but I am more than biased). And agree - Coryn wouldn't have been in the mix at all.

clm
Nashville, TN
https://twitter.com/ironclm | http://ironclm.typepad.com
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [SBRYYC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
SBRYYC wrote:
I missed the men's race. Does anyone know where I can buy/watch the full race? Ideally I'd like to download because high resolution and no buffer would be amazing.

BBC iplayer
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [ergopower] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ergopower wrote:
ahhchon wrote:
if she had:
- longer sleeves on her arm (hers were extremely short compared to the other girls)
- more aero helmet (was hers the most aero?)
- had di2 (vs the cables in the front of her mechanical set)
- more aero frame
- ditched the water bottle (she didn't drink from it once the final 8k)
- rode aero position vs in drop bars

would that have given her the extra few seconds she needed?

Deeper wheels? Little hard to see, but looked like she was on 35s, only Longo Borghini was on deeper wheels.
An Evade might have been the next best upgrade.

oops.. yeah, not deeper wheels. i was just on a roll. ha ha.

but she was caught 150 meters out.. that's not very far at all. i don't know her exact speed, but she couldn't have been going any less than 25mph.

but even at that.. 25mph is about 11.176m/s.

let say the chasers were going 27mph, which is about 12.07m/s

so about 1 meter per second faster. she would have needed a little over 10 seconds to hold them off? i guess she probably wasn't going to gain 10 seconds over the 8k stretch, even with the best aero equipment....

right?
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [ergopower] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ergopower wrote:
An Evade might have been the next best upgrade.


You realize these are not weekend warrior MOP triathletes that can just willy nilly slap on any helmet they want, right?

Besides, no Spesh rider (that was in the final at least) was wearing the Evade, not the women, not the men. Probably because it was hot as hell. Good job being aero when your brain is being fried. Only Johansson had the full POC aerolid, but she's Swedish so then it works ;)
Last edited by: snaaijert: Aug 8, 16 16:00
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [ahhchon] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It's a decent list. Looks like Abbott cut her sleeves and shorts shorter than the standard issue, to save weight I guess? If she would have traded some of that weight weeny-ism for aeroweeny-ism it might have gained her a couple of seconds, sure.

But the time gained is rather academic. She might have gained 10s but she was being chased, so they might have chased harder to bridge that gap. This is bike racing, not a time trial. You ride hard you get chased harder. Majka and Abbott should have a little crushed dreams reunion on Ipanema this week ;) at least Majka got a bronze.
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [ahhchon] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ahhchon wrote:
i'm surprised no one has brought this up yet.. so i will:

abbot was doing a pretty darn good job holding them off. she had about 8k where she really had to have a solid solo effort.

a few things i thought (and i would love some ST engineering/mathematics here):

if she had:
- longer sleeves on her arm (hers were extremely short compared to the other girls)
- more aero helmet (was hers the most aero?)
- had di2 (vs the cables in the front of her mechanical set)
- more aero frame
- ditched the water bottle (she didn't drink from it once the final 8k)
- rode aero position vs in drop bars

would that have given her the extra few seconds she needed?

i know 8k is not a lot of pavement, but every little bit counts, right? is it possible?


Besides the fact that the poster above me mentions (she can't just choose anything she wants as a sponsored trade team/national athlete)...she had electronic shifting on her bike.
Last edited by: James Haycraft: Aug 8, 16 15:57
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [James Haycraft] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
are you suuuuuure about di2? i swear i saw tons of cables on multiple occasions. then again. it was late, i had a few beers and i was really sleepy.
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [ahhchon] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yes, I am sure she had electronic shifting. One thing you didn't mention would be the helmet chin strap.


Last edited by: James Haycraft: Aug 8, 16 16:26
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [ThisIsIt] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ThisIsIt wrote:
Brooks Doughtie wrote:
A) In case you missed it, she actually did have a chance to sprint for GOLD at the finish.

B) If they all refused to work, my A point would never had happened. They caught her and sprinted 11s from the finish.

ETA: I just completely disagree with your point that she rode poorly. The finish allowed her to finish on podium and *atleast* attempt to go for gold versus cat fighting over sprinting for silver at best. To bring up all that after that bike race, yawn.


A) Effectively she didn't.

B) She never even tried to force them to work. She could have at least tried.

She in reality did not attempt to go for gold, she gave it to one of the other two riders. You can't even argue she thought she had an awesome sprint even when spent and the other 2 didn't have any legs left, because she was happy with the result, not disappointed she got it wrong by effectively being a leadout for the other 2. She gave the race away.

Is nobody her clued into the fact that some people are good sprinters and others aren't? That for some people, no matter how much you make the other work, you're basically still going to get smoked? For sprinters it's like their fast twitch muscles are in a separate compartment and have been on vacation until it's time to sprint. If they are still there, they can still sprint. Perhaps Longo Bourgini is one of those non-sprinters and she knew that no matter what she was going to get 3rd in that group. If she is one of those riders, then she absolutely did the right thing.

Hey, guess what, she's not a sprinter.
http://www.cyclingnews.com/...dal-in-rio-olympics/

From that article:
"...but of course I had to wait for them for the sprint, because I am not a sprinter," Longo Borghini said."

"Instead of a bunch sprint, the race came down to a small group of nine riders and Lizzie Armitstead won the world title for Great Britain. Longo Borghini was in that small group but she could only manage a fourth place behind silver medallist Anna Van der Breggen (Netherlands) and bronze medallist Megan Guarnier (USA). It was a result that she expressed disappointment over while speaking with Cyclingnews at the finish line.

"I think we rode really well, I'm just really sad that until 20 metres to go I was third position but I couldn't really finish off the good teamwork with a medal. I feel really sorry for my national team. It's a hard fourth place for me," she said."

Shocking that a professional cyclist would know more about his or her strengths as a rider than the internet peanut gallery...

Kevin

http://kevinmetcalfe.dreamhosters.com
My Strava
Quote Reply
Re: Olympic Road cycling thread [nslckevin] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I already addressed that when she was excited for finishing 3rd and not pissed or banging her bars. That proved to me she wasn't a sprinter and rode the ending exactly how she did. Look up a few pages up I think.
ETA: My response to her being "happy" for 3rd at end of race:

Then that was exactly why she worked to ensure she could sprint for at worse bronze. If she knew she couldnt sprint, it makes complete sense in my mind to gurantee a top 3 versus waiting and then only finishing 4th. So your reasoning proves to me atleast, exactly why she worked the finish like she did.

If you know you can't outsprint the other 2, and you know this, and there is still one person up the road, I'd say she rode exactly how she wanted to get a medal.

Brooks Doughtie, M.S.
Exercise Physiology
-USAT Level II
Last edited by: Brooks Doughtie: Aug 8, 16 16:31
Quote Reply

Prev Next