Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Prev Next
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [SDG] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
SDG wrote:
Why is that? What has changed between then ( guns everywhere) and now ( guns everywhere) that makes psychotic animals want to shoot up schools? Surely it is multi-factorial but we need to study this as much as anything. I suggest kids these days are largely seeing a darker world then we ( 80's kids) grew up in. Although we had the cold war, we also had optimism about growing up, getting a job, getting married, having a family and living the american dream. The American dream was a wife, kids, boat on the weekend and vacation at the beach each summer. Maybe golf each sunday afternoon with the boys

Kids currently only see fear porn all over the internet and social media about the word coming to an end because of climate change, race relations, discrimination, and all sorts of other things.

This is a fascinating take.

Are today's young people troubled because:

1) of actual fear of things actually getting worse for today's young people?

Or

2) because of fear of things that appear to be getting worse (from fear porn, etc.), but actually in reality things are just dandy?




I ask this because I had a very politically conservative graduating HS senior boy neighbor (whose parents are also both far right conservatives) tell me last year that he thought that the world had 10 decent years left, and after that things were gonna go to hell because of global warming.

When I heard him say that, my jaw nearly hit the ground ...

Advanced Aero TopTube Storage for Road, Gravel, & Tri...ZeroSlip & Direct-mount, made in the USA.
DarkSpeedWorks.com.....Reviews.....Insta.....Facebook

--
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [Greg66] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Greg66 wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
You wouldn’t need to defend indefinitely, you’d just need to defend for 18-20 “child-deaths” worth of time (based on recent massacres) until LEO arrives on scene.

Gunfire defectors, auto locking doors, panic buttons, cameras, defense in depth with redundant and bulletproof entry points and internal segregation points, comms for teachers in mutually supporting classrooms, procedures for sweeping up straggler kids in hallways. Most of these resources are already on site just not arranged in the right spatial or sequential arrangement.

E


It’s un fucking believable that anyone would think this is the right solution - for schools, FFS - to shootings.

It's unbelievable that anyone would think doing the same thing we've been doing is the right solution.

It's not the guns, it's the interests pushing the guns, and the interests radicalizing people. Attack them, defend the children. Both of these are achieve by "effective accountable executive branch government" which is my solution for the moment to this problem. Legislative branch government is completely broken.

E

Eric Reid AeroFit | Instagram Portfolio
Aerodynamic Retul Bike Fitting

“You are experiencing the criminal coverup of a foreign backed fascist hostile takeover of a mafia shakedown of an authoritarian religious slow motion coup. Persuade people to vote for Democracy.”
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [SDG] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
SDG wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
SWEDE63 wrote:
On this we can agree, neither side wants to let it seem like the other side won. Being from Kansas I was never a Bob Dole fan, however back when he was in office there was at least some civility within our government.


Please understand when I say “harden” …

a) I don’t mean with concrete and rebar I mean make it harder or more costly or more time consuming to hit the target

b) the target is the kids not the school.

c) the threat to our children is now endemic and Societal and cultural and memetic.

All in all, hire a police force that will respond sooner then the current “one full classroom of massacred kids” standard unit of measure, and hire administrators that can extend the threat surface space-time out to where the police response begins.

E


I can't tell if you are being serious with your over the top suggestions or just trying to make a point by being so over the top.

You have schools becoming akin to SEAL TEAM SIX locking down a safe house in Kandahar. While I agree we need to increase cops on site, lock doors, have bullet proof glass put in and a few other things, not sure we can do all you require.

I am being completely serious. The problem is that you have malware installed on your operating system that conflates competence with military porn. They are not the same.

Pretend we're talking about football play diagrams.

E

Eric Reid AeroFit | Instagram Portfolio
Aerodynamic Retul Bike Fitting

“You are experiencing the criminal coverup of a foreign backed fascist hostile takeover of a mafia shakedown of an authoritarian religious slow motion coup. Persuade people to vote for Democracy.”
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [SDG] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
SDG wrote:
FishyJoe wrote:
SDG wrote:
This is something else I don't understand about this shooting but will wait for the facts to come out. I know in my kids schools, the doors are locked all day long....no exception. If you want in, there is one way in and its through the office and you have to be buzzed in. There is no way this could have happened at my kids schools unless

1) he shot his way in through the glass or

2) the office accicentally buzzed him in.


All the other doors are locked, made of steel etc.

I suppose someone could shoot their way in through the window and there we are, but there is no way a person is just walking into my kids school with a gun. Not possible.

Add an armed secutiry guard ( one of my kids schools has an armed cop there all day everyday) and I feel pretty good about it. ( Not sure every district in Texas has an armed cop there all day)


Sounds like your kids go to school in a prison.

All the schools I went to growing up were open campuses. Big windows. When you step outside you feel the sun in your face. I rode my bike to school by myself. Then I think about what kids have today and wonder if they really know what freedom is.



No actually it's quite nice. It's a neighborhood school and many are taken by their parents in golf carts, walk on the sidewalks or ride their bikes. They leave their bikes at the front of the school and no one uses a bike lock, just lays their bike down. Skateboards, scooters everywhere and nothing locked up. Teachers are all great, energetic and the class size is small and well funded. Each kid has a ipad. They have recess twice a day and parents often come eat in the cafeteria and bring kids lunch. My kid loves the chick fil a I bring him all the time and time we eat up there.


You can have all of this and have the school locked down during the day with each door outside locked. My kids probably don't even know the doors are locked. Each class has a large window to the outside and they can daydream watching the squirrels all they want.

So what's to stop someone waiting for recess or school getting out and doing the shoot em up? I don't want to see it happen, but you seem to be under the illusion that locked doors are an impediment. If there are windows, then there will always be a line of sight with a shooter.

I don't want to see any of it happen, but in reality most security measures are theater.
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [307trout] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
307trout wrote:
I think Eric speaks in a semi different language but from what I can piece together, it's sort of like taking mostly the same lego blocks you currently have, but arranging them differently in order to have a much better final product.

Yes. This is both strategy (decision to use the same things) and tactics (arrangement of resources in space and time).

Also could be framed as ways and means.

What to do and how to do it.

Etc.

E

Eric Reid AeroFit | Instagram Portfolio
Aerodynamic Retul Bike Fitting

“You are experiencing the criminal coverup of a foreign backed fascist hostile takeover of a mafia shakedown of an authoritarian religious slow motion coup. Persuade people to vote for Democracy.”
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [drn92] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
drn92 wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
LorenzoP wrote:
As long as we can buy an AR-15 and body armor there are no practical deterrents to keep people safe. We can build 1000+ bed mental health facilities on every street corner, it won't make any difference.


This is absolute horseshit. Defending a hardened building instead of security theater would solve this problem.

No guns or off-duty rent seeking cops required.

E


I’m sorry, but I would rather imagine a future where our kids do not have to go to school in an armed encampment.

drn92

I'm really questioning everybody's motivations and reading comprehension. I'm advocating for using time and space instead of guns and ammo to keep our kids safe. Literally a gun-free zone.

E

Eric Reid AeroFit | Instagram Portfolio
Aerodynamic Retul Bike Fitting

“You are experiencing the criminal coverup of a foreign backed fascist hostile takeover of a mafia shakedown of an authoritarian religious slow motion coup. Persuade people to vote for Democracy.”
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [SDG] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
SDG wrote:
Doru wrote:
SDG wrote:


No actually it's quite nice. It's a neighborhood school and many are taken by their parents in golf carts, walk on the sidewalks or ride their bikes. They leave their bikes at the front of the school and no one uses a bike lock, just lays their bike down. Skateboards, scooters everywhere and nothing locked up. Teachers are all great, energetic and the class size is small and well funded. Each kid has a ipad. They have recess twice a day and parents often come eat in the cafeteria and bring kids lunch. My kid loves the chick fil a I bring him all the time and time we eat up there.


You can have all of this and have the school locked down during the day with each door outside locked. My kids probably don't even know the doors are locked. Each class has a large window to the outside and they can daydream watching the squirrels all they want.


I live in Canada and the schools in my neighborhood have basketball courts / running tracks / soccer fields that are not fenced. How do you defend these?
Do you have a big fence around sport fields?


We have all of those as well. No problems so far and kids play outside everyday. I don't recall ever seeing the situation where any of these cases happened outdoors at the school. I guess if they ever had that, the kids would run into the school as fast as they could.

Then you will need multiple security guards to protect open sport fields, which would be very expensive and impractical.
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [FishyJoe] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
FishyJoe wrote:


I don't want to see any of it happen, but in reality most security measures are theater.

This is the crux of the problem. We live in the real world, and the real world is unforgiving. This is why we have kids play games at school... ritualized combat that are unforgiving like the real world. Ironically we adults are living in a fake social/emotional world where we thing forgiveness is baked in and mistakes don't count or something, and security theater soothes our feelings. That is the only thing I can think of to explain our lack of creativity or sense of urgency.

E

Eric Reid AeroFit | Instagram Portfolio
Aerodynamic Retul Bike Fitting

“You are experiencing the criminal coverup of a foreign backed fascist hostile takeover of a mafia shakedown of an authoritarian religious slow motion coup. Persuade people to vote for Democracy.”
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [Doru] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Doru wrote:
SDG wrote:


No actually it's quite nice. It's a neighborhood school and many are taken by their parents in golf carts, walk on the sidewalks or ride their bikes. They leave their bikes at the front of the school and no one uses a bike lock, just lays their bike down. Skateboards, scooters everywhere and nothing locked up. Teachers are all great, energetic and the class size is small and well funded. Each kid has a ipad. They have recess twice a day and parents often come eat in the cafeteria and bring kids lunch. My kid loves the chick fil a I bring him all the time and time we eat up there.


You can have all of this and have the school locked down during the day with each door outside locked. My kids probably don't even know the doors are locked. Each class has a large window to the outside and they can daydream watching the squirrels all they want.


I live in Canada and the schools in my neighborhood have basketball courts / running tracks / soccer fields that are not fenced. How do you defend these?
Do you have a big fence around sport fields?

I would argue that the target is "kids in classrooms" because these are radicalized terrorists not murderers or criminals, and we are losing 1 unit of "kids in classroom" per massacre, because that's what is fetishized and sexualized and that's what's reinforced by the economy or market in that police have a one classroom massacred response time... nobody fantasizes about being a proficient marksman from a distance engaging kids in a field and people might notice a sniper setting up. They'd all run and scatter. These monsters want to hear the screams and see things up close.

Which sounds horrible but is helpful to us in that we can defend against that, defend the 1 classroom getting massacred, but we can't defend sports fields unless we're doing an area defense which we can't do without background checks, waiting periods, red flags, and a will to monitor and investigate threats.

E

Eric Reid AeroFit | Instagram Portfolio
Aerodynamic Retul Bike Fitting

“You are experiencing the criminal coverup of a foreign backed fascist hostile takeover of a mafia shakedown of an authoritarian religious slow motion coup. Persuade people to vote for Democracy.”
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [Kay Serrar] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What about concealed carry?


How exactly does one concealed carry a rifle?
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [Kay Serrar] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Kay Serrar wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
SWEDE63 wrote:
On this we can agree, neither side wants to let it seem like the other side won. Being from Kansas I was never a Bob Dole fan, however back when he was in office there was at least some civility within our government.


Please understand when I say “harden” …

a) I don’t mean with concrete and rebar I mean make it harder or more costly or more time consuming to hit the target

b) the target is the kids not the school.

c) the threat to our children is now endemic and Societal and cultural and memetic.

All in all, hire a police force that will respond sooner then the current “one full classroom of massacred kids” standard unit of measure, and hire administrators that can extend the threat surface space-time out to where the police response begins.

E


How about you stop talking in riddles and stop proposing unworkable (from a cost perspective) solutions to the problem.

And making schools a bit more “hardened” as targets, or getting cops to arrive a few seconds sooner, are not going to solve the problem. The problem is the quantity of guns in our society and the ease with which anyone can buy one. This is not rocket science.


I feel like I'm asking an 1800s surgeon to wash his hands before surgery... you're absolutely baffled as to why you'd do that.

Yes, you're right the number of guns in our society is WAY too high but it's not THE problem. THE problem is the interests that push guns and radicalize people. They are doing what they do with zero pushback or even recognition. Because of that, there are too many guns and too many radicalized people in America, which now seems to be propagating memetically, or by itself, which could lead to a really horrific society and culture.

My reaction, for the moment, is to control what I can control and perhaps channel resiliency and preparedness and just lock the doors at our schools and make it more difficult to massacre and slaughter our babies. Removing guns from our society is a supra-national extra-political problem that's not achievable by a local school board and won't come to pass for 100 years at this rate. My solution is to do something we can do now, for free, based on the realities at play.

Realize what's the target, realize who the actors are, lock the fucking doors, reduce the police response time, save the 1 classroom that is getting slaughtered by reducing the N to 0.

E

Eric Reid AeroFit | Instagram Portfolio
Aerodynamic Retul Bike Fitting

“You are experiencing the criminal coverup of a foreign backed fascist hostile takeover of a mafia shakedown of an authoritarian religious slow motion coup. Persuade people to vote for Democracy.”
Last edited by: ericMPro: May 25, 22 15:59
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [ericMPro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ericMPro wrote:
LorenzoP wrote:
As long as we can buy an AR-15 and body armor there are no practical deterrents to keep people safe. We can build 1000+ bed mental health facilities on every street corner, it won't make any difference.


This is absolute horseshit. Defending a hardened building instead of security theater would solve this problem.

No guns or off-duty rent seeking cops required.

E

Cruz mentioned this today during his rant on Fox, one entrance/exit. So guess we will just let the kids burn if there is a fire or be sitting ducks if the shooter(s) get past the guard. Jez...................
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [ruby1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ruby1 wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
LorenzoP wrote:
As long as we can buy an AR-15 and body armor there are no practical deterrents to keep people safe. We can build 1000+ bed mental health facilities on every street corner, it won't make any difference.


This is absolute horseshit. Defending a hardened building instead of security theater would solve this problem.

No guns or off-duty rent seeking cops required.

E

Cruz mentioned this today during his rant on Fox, one entrance/exit. So guess we will just let the kids burn if there is a fire or be sitting ducks if the shooter(s) get past the guard. Jez...................

I can't tell if you're actually serious.
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [307trout] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
307trout wrote:
ruby1 wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
LorenzoP wrote:
As long as we can buy an AR-15 and body armor there are no practical deterrents to keep people safe. We can build 1000+ bed mental health facilities on every street corner, it won't make any difference.


This is absolute horseshit. Defending a hardened building instead of security theater would solve this problem.

No guns or off-duty rent seeking cops required.

E

Cruz mentioned this today during his rant on Fox, one entrance/exit. So guess we will just let the kids burn if there is a fire or be sitting ducks if the shooter(s) get past the guard. Jez...................

I can't tell if you're actually serious.

Why do you question this comment and not the suggestion that we "harden" schools? Single entrance schools are a terrible idea for a number of reasons. Not only safety (fire, stampede, etc) but for logistical reasons as well. Schools are busy places and one entrance would be a nightmare to deal with.
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [ruby1] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ruby1 wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
LorenzoP wrote:
As long as we can buy an AR-15 and body armor there are no practical deterrents to keep people safe. We can build 1000+ bed mental health facilities on every street corner, it won't make any difference.


This is absolute horseshit. Defending a hardened building instead of security theater would solve this problem.

No guns or off-duty rent seeking cops required.

E

Cruz mentioned this today during his rant on Fox, one entrance/exit. So guess we will just let the kids burn if there is a fire or be sitting ducks if the shooter(s) get past the guard. Jez...................

Crus is an idiot, and so is one entrance.

The idea is to shrink the threat surface such that the schools resources link up with the police’s.

This is not a commentary about politics or gun control, just closing things that close, locking things that lock.

E

Eric Reid AeroFit | Instagram Portfolio
Aerodynamic Retul Bike Fitting

“You are experiencing the criminal coverup of a foreign backed fascist hostile takeover of a mafia shakedown of an authoritarian religious slow motion coup. Persuade people to vote for Democracy.”
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [southpaw] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
southpaw wrote:
307trout wrote:
ruby1 wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
LorenzoP wrote:
As long as we can buy an AR-15 and body armor there are no practical deterrents to keep people safe. We can build 1000+ bed mental health facilities on every street corner, it won't make any difference.


This is absolute horseshit. Defending a hardened building instead of security theater would solve this problem.

No guns or off-duty rent seeking cops required.

E


Cruz mentioned this today during his rant on Fox, one entrance/exit. So guess we will just let the kids burn if there is a fire or be sitting ducks if the shooter(s) get past the guard. Jez...................


I can't tell if you're actually serious.


Why do you question this comment and not the suggestion that we "harden" schools? Single entrance schools are a terrible idea for a number of reasons. Not only safety (fire, stampede, etc) but for logistical reasons as well. Schools are busy places and one entrance would be a nightmare to deal with.

They figured out emergency exits for secured doors a long time ago. You may have even seen an alarmed crash door as an emergency exit.
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [zed707] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
zed707 wrote:
southpaw wrote:
307trout wrote:
ruby1 wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
LorenzoP wrote:
As long as we can buy an AR-15 and body armor there are no practical deterrents to keep people safe. We can build 1000+ bed mental health facilities on every street corner, it won't make any difference.


This is absolute horseshit. Defending a hardened building instead of security theater would solve this problem.

No guns or off-duty rent seeking cops required.

E


Cruz mentioned this today during his rant on Fox, one entrance/exit. So guess we will just let the kids burn if there is a fire or be sitting ducks if the shooter(s) get past the guard. Jez...................


I can't tell if you're actually serious.


Why do you question this comment and not the suggestion that we "harden" schools? Single entrance schools are a terrible idea for a number of reasons. Not only safety (fire, stampede, etc) but for logistical reasons as well. Schools are busy places and one entrance would be a nightmare to deal with.

They figured out emergency exits for secured doors a long time ago. You may have even seen an alarmed crash door as an emergency exit.

Holy hell, you solved the riddle!!!

Our schools have functioned this way for as long as I can remember.
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [307trout] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
307trout wrote:
zed707 wrote:
southpaw wrote:
307trout wrote:
ruby1 wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
LorenzoP wrote:
As long as we can buy an AR-15 and body armor there are no practical deterrents to keep people safe. We can build 1000+ bed mental health facilities on every street corner, it won't make any difference.


This is absolute horseshit. Defending a hardened building instead of security theater would solve this problem.

No guns or off-duty rent seeking cops required.

E


Cruz mentioned this today during his rant on Fox, one entrance/exit. So guess we will just let the kids burn if there is a fire or be sitting ducks if the shooter(s) get past the guard. Jez...................


I can't tell if you're actually serious.


Why do you question this comment and not the suggestion that we "harden" schools? Single entrance schools are a terrible idea for a number of reasons. Not only safety (fire, stampede, etc) but for logistical reasons as well. Schools are busy places and one entrance would be a nightmare to deal with.

They figured out emergency exits for secured doors a long time ago. You may have even seen an alarmed crash door as an emergency exit.

Holy hell, you solved the riddle!!!

Our schools have functioned this way for as long as I can remember.

It still makes no sense to me to design schools to accommodate murderers. But whatever man, you can have your fantasy.
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [FishyJoe] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
FishyJoe wrote:
SDG wrote:
FishyJoe wrote:
SDG wrote:
This is something else I don't understand about this shooting but will wait for the facts to come out. I know in my kids schools, the doors are locked all day long....no exception. If you want in, there is one way in and its through the office and you have to be buzzed in. There is no way this could have happened at my kids schools unless

1) he shot his way in through the glass or

2) the office accicentally buzzed him in.


All the other doors are locked, made of steel etc.

I suppose someone could shoot their way in through the window and there we are, but there is no way a person is just walking into my kids school with a gun. Not possible.

Add an armed secutiry guard ( one of my kids schools has an armed cop there all day everyday) and I feel pretty good about it. ( Not sure every district in Texas has an armed cop there all day)


Sounds like your kids go to school in a prison.

All the schools I went to growing up were open campuses. Big windows. When you step outside you feel the sun in your face. I rode my bike to school by myself. Then I think about what kids have today and wonder if they really know what freedom is.



No actually it's quite nice. It's a neighborhood school and many are taken by their parents in golf carts, walk on the sidewalks or ride their bikes. They leave their bikes at the front of the school and no one uses a bike lock, just lays their bike down. Skateboards, scooters everywhere and nothing locked up. Teachers are all great, energetic and the class size is small and well funded. Each kid has a ipad. They have recess twice a day and parents often come eat in the cafeteria and bring kids lunch. My kid loves the chick fil a I bring him all the time and time we eat up there.


You can have all of this and have the school locked down during the day with each door outside locked. My kids probably don't even know the doors are locked. Each class has a large window to the outside and they can daydream watching the squirrels all they want.


So what's to stop someone waiting for recess or school getting out and doing the shoot em up? I don't want to see it happen, but you seem to be under the illusion that locked doors are an impediment. If there are windows, then there will always be a line of sight with a shooter.

I don't want to see any of it happen, but in reality most security measures are theater.


The NRA did come up with a solution here of how to build schools. The answer, and this may shock you, was basically a prison. No windows, no trees or bushes (if you had to have bushes make them thorny), fences that demonstrate "territorial ownership", no parking lots, etc.

I am sure kids would love going to school in a prison.

But on the plus side the NRA was generously providing this advice for free. So that is nice.
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [southpaw] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
southpaw wrote:
307trout wrote:
ruby1 wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
LorenzoP wrote:
As long as we can buy an AR-15 and body armor there are no practical deterrents to keep people safe. We can build 1000+ bed mental health facilities on every street corner, it won't make any difference.


This is absolute horseshit. Defending a hardened building instead of security theater would solve this problem.

No guns or off-duty rent seeking cops required.

E


Cruz mentioned this today during his rant on Fox, one entrance/exit. So guess we will just let the kids burn if there is a fire or be sitting ducks if the shooter(s) get past the guard. Jez...................


I can't tell if you're actually serious.


Why do you question this comment and not the suggestion that we "harden" schools? Single entrance schools are a terrible idea for a number of reasons. Not only safety (fire, stampede, etc) but for logistical reasons as well. Schools are busy places and one entrance would be a nightmare to deal with.

Maybe we can rename them triangle shirtwaist elementary?
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [chaparral] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Replying to last.

I have 2 kids in public school, and a third that’ll go. We couldn’t afford ventilators in a global airborne pandemic, can’t afford enough teachers, can’t afford basic supplies. The idea that we’ll find funds to hire highly effective security guards and “harden” our schools (subtly, you understand, not like a prison), is laughable. It will never happen. Even if it did, 2 or 3 LEOs engaged this shooter and couldn’t stop him accessing the school. As many other instances have show, even if there is a good (and very brave, you often don’t get both) guy with a gun he’s often ineffective. Passing gun control legislation is highly unlikely, having a surfeit of funds in public education budgets is even less likely.

But this is my bigger point. I don’t want hardened schools. I don’t want bullet proof glass even if it’s indistinguishable from regular glass. I don’t want armed guards even if the kids don’t see them. I flat don’t want to live in a society where defending myself and my children from potential acts of mass murder becomes a rational thing to think about and invest resources in, beyond the sort of precautions I take to avoid getting hit by lightning.



"Are you sure we're going fast enough?" - Emil Zatopek
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [Bretom] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Bretom wrote:
Replying to last.

I have 2 kids in public school, and a third that’ll go. We couldn’t afford ventilators in a global airborne pandemic, can’t afford enough teachers, can’t afford basic supplies. The idea that we’ll find funds to hire highly effective security guards and “harden” our schools (subtly, you understand, not like a prison), is laughable. It will never happen. Even if it did, 2 or 3 LEOs engaged this shooter and couldn’t stop him accessing the school. As many other instances have show, even if there is a good (and very brave, you often don’t get both) guy with a gun he’s often ineffective. Passing gun control legislation is highly unlikely, having a surfeit of funds in public education budgets is even less likely.

But this is my bigger point. I don’t want hardened schools. I don’t want bullet proof glass even if it’s indistinguishable from regular glass. I don’t want armed guards even if the kids don’t see them. I flat don’t want to live in a society where defending myself and my children from potential acts of mass murder becomes a rational thing to think about and invest resources in, beyond the sort of precautions I take to avoid getting hit by lightning.

Each of those things you listed is a direct reduction in freedoms to each and every American that not only attends school, but also goes to grocery stores, churches, festivals, concerts, etc. Making accomodations in our infrastructure for murderers when we won't pass very basic and effective gun control measures makes us less free. Living without constant threat of deadly violence makes us more free.
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [ericMPro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ericMPro wrote:
Kay Serrar wrote:
ericMPro wrote:
SWEDE63 wrote:
On this we can agree, neither side wants to let it seem like the other side won. Being from Kansas I was never a Bob Dole fan, however back when he was in office there was at least some civility within our government.


Please understand when I say “harden” …

a) I don’t mean with concrete and rebar I mean make it harder or more costly or more time consuming to hit the target

b) the target is the kids not the school.

c) the threat to our children is now endemic and Societal and cultural and memetic.

All in all, hire a police force that will respond sooner then the current “one full classroom of massacred kids” standard unit of measure, and hire administrators that can extend the threat surface space-time out to where the police response begins.

E


How about you stop talking in riddles and stop proposing unworkable (from a cost perspective) solutions to the problem.

And making schools a bit more “hardened” as targets, or getting cops to arrive a few seconds sooner, are not going to solve the problem. The problem is the quantity of guns in our society and the ease with which anyone can buy one. This is not rocket science.


I feel like I'm asking an 1800s surgeon to wash his hands before surgery... you're absolutely baffled as to why you'd do that.

Yes, you're right the number of guns in our society is WAY too high but it's not THE problem. THE problem is the interests that push guns and radicalize people. They are doing what they do with zero pushback or even recognition. Because of that, there are too many guns and too many radicalized people in America, which now seems to be propagating memetically, or by itself, which could lead to a really horrific society and culture.

My reaction, for the moment, is to control what I can control and perhaps channel resiliency and preparedness and just lock the doors at our schools and make it more difficult to massacre and slaughter our babies. Removing guns from our society is a supra-national extra-political problem that's not achievable by a local school board and won't come to pass for 100 years at this rate. My solution is to do something we can do now, for free, based on the realities at play.

Realize what's the target, realize who the actors are, lock the fucking doors, reduce the police response time, save the 1 classroom that is getting slaughtered by reducing the N to 0.

E

Look, I know you have a bit of a hard on for this magical solution, but the reality is that an 18 year old kid with a hidden gun and an intent to kill is still going to find his way into a school, and sometimes they are actually students doing the shooting. What you propose would be prohibitively costly and barely make a difference, if at all. It might also not meet fire safety codes.
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [southpaw] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
southpaw wrote:
Bretom wrote:
Replying to last.

I have 2 kids in public school, and a third that’ll go. We couldn’t afford ventilators in a global airborne pandemic, can’t afford enough teachers, can’t afford basic supplies. The idea that we’ll find funds to hire highly effective security guards and “harden” our schools (subtly, you understand, not like a prison), is laughable. It will never happen. Even if it did, 2 or 3 LEOs engaged this shooter and couldn’t stop him accessing the school. As many other instances have show, even if there is a good (and very brave, you often don’t get both) guy with a gun he’s often ineffective. Passing gun control legislation is highly unlikely, having a surfeit of funds in public education budgets is even less likely.

But this is my bigger point. I don’t want hardened schools. I don’t want bullet proof glass even if it’s indistinguishable from regular glass. I don’t want armed guards even if the kids don’t see them. I flat don’t want to live in a society where defending myself and my children from potential acts of mass murder becomes a rational thing to think about and invest resources in, beyond the sort of precautions I take to avoid getting hit by lightning.

Each of those things you listed is a direct reduction in freedoms to each and every American that not only attends school, but also goes to grocery stores, churches, festivals, concerts, etc. Making accomodations in our infrastructure for murderers when we won't pass very basic and effective gun control measures makes us less free. Living without constant threat of deadly violence makes us more free.

Thank you, that was well put and I couldnt agree more.



"Are you sure we're going fast enough?" - Emil Zatopek
Quote Reply
Re: Shootings - Imagine what it'd be like [Bretom] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
A lot of schools, maybe even most schools were designed decades if not centuries ago. The last thing on their mind was security, some might not even have had locks if you go back far enough.

The high school I went to was designed in the 1950's. It would be almost impossible to turn into a prison. The campus is laid out like a college campus, with many one story buildings spread out over acres of land. There are gigantic windows right next to the doors. You can look right in.

It would probably cost tens of millions to secure all the schools in my hometown district like some have suggested. It's just not reality.
Quote Reply

Prev Next