Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War
Quote | Reply
You knew this was coming, so here it is. Some spoilers for earlier films included below:

Avengers: Infinity War is a spectacle, hitting all the notes you've come to expect from any film in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). There is a ton of action, some good bits of humor, and all your favorite heroes (well, most of them). The movie serves as the beginning of the end for the existing MCU as it's currently known, and wraps up a bunch of the story lines surrounding the search for the Infinity Stones that began as far back as the first Captain America film.

Thanos has finally stepped to the forefront, and has taken on the job of collecting the Infinity Stones with his close group of dedicated baddies. As we saw at the end of Thor: Ragnarok, Thanos starts his search with the remaining Asgardians fleeing from their destroyed world. After Thanos deals with Thor and Loki in short order, Bruce Banner is cast back to Earth to warn the Avengers of the coming danger. Our heroes are scattered around the world, some unlocated, some in hiding, some still managing the government bureaucracy established in the aftermath of the Civil War film. With the threat of Thanos looming heavily, all of the strength of Earth's mightiest heroes (not to mention the Guardians of the Galaxy) must come together if there is any chance to stop the death and destruction Thanos plans to unleash upon the entire universe. Can the heroes stop the mad Titan from finding and using the stones? Can they work together to protect Earth and the entire universe? What will they have to sacrifice to survive a fight with a being with the power of multiple Infinity Stones?

Infinity War is big, loud, fast, fun-filled action from start to finish. There's a lot to see here, but the directors did a really good job of balancing a number of story lines that allow virtually the entire cast of Marvel heroes to play roles in the spectacle. All the major characters are on display to some extent or another, with the exceptions of Hawkeye and Ant-Man, who are explained away with some nonsense about protecting their families. There is even a cameo from a character many people thought was long gone. Some of the minor characters are either missing or wrapped up pretty quickly, but they're not really missed. It was good to see some of the familiar characters put together in new combinations to see different interactions. The action is very good, and the movie really shows how overmatched our heroes are when facing Thanos. The plot, humor, acting, effects, etc are all exactly what you'd expect from a Marvel film. There were one or two scenes that had individual effects that looked odd to me, but I was also watching on a Navy base theater screen, so not really the best quality. Thanos is a good villain, with more to his story and motivation than just being a really bad guy. While the film definitely is set up as a bit of a cliffhanger, it does a good job of putting a bow on the MCU, and the quality of the Thanos character plays a big role in making that work.

Infinity War is rated PG-13, which matches the rest of the MCU movies, although there were a couple of scenes that might have pushed into the R area. There were a lot of little kids at the theater when I went, and there were some scenes that I thought might be too much for them. There's no sex or nudity or foul language, but a lot of violence, including torture.

This movie is going to do big box office numbers. Overall I highly recommend it, especially to anyone who's been a fan of the MCU movies over the past decade.

Slowguy

(insert pithy phrase here...)
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Agreed with the review above. Just a roller coaster ride of a film. 2 hours, 40 minutes felt much less than that. I've never been in a theater where everyone cheered like 10 times during the movie.

Saw it Thursday night with my family, and my daughter saw it again with her high school friends. As I picked them up after the movie, they looked like they had been in a car wreck. It's that intense.

Now time to over-analyze everything that happened (or didn't), said (or wasn't), going into next May. :-)
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
slowguy wrote:
There's no ... foul language,

There's a couple "douchebags," an "asshole" and a "nut-sack" that I recall

Samuel L Jackson disappears before he can actually finish "motherfucker" but we know what it was

"What's your claim?" - Ben Gravy
"Your best work is the work you're excited about" - Rick Rubin
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [MikeH in MD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
MikeH in MD wrote:
As I picked them up after the movie, they looked like they had been in a car wreck. It's that intense.

D'Kid's synopsis "What the absolute fuck???!!! All that destruction and killing just so he could sit on hill by himself? What a dick!!!"

Then she cried

"What's your claim?" - Ben Gravy
"Your best work is the work you're excited about" - Rick Rubin
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks for the review, I was hoping you would post one soon. I don't trust the media promoted reviewers, but I trust yours as you seem to enjoy the MCU movies like I do.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have to say they did a great job with Thanos. I *almost* sympathized with him and I think that’s exactly what the writers and producers were going for. This wasn’t meant to be a feel good movie and I think it was excellent as a result.

The scene with Thanos a Gamora (sp?) at the end was... perfect. I can’t describe it any other way.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Agreed, great film, if you have been following MCU. No movie spoilers from me, but Marvel is putting some other franchises (DC, Star Wars) to shame.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [oldandslow] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
oldandslow wrote:
Agreed, great film, if you have been following MCU. No movie spoilers from me, but Marvel is putting some other franchises (DC, Star Wars) to shame.

That is a huge understatement. I haven't watched any of the recent Star Wars or DC movies with exception of Wonder Woman because my daughter had the movie. The last SW movie I watched was #7 - I watched it once and decided I wasn't interested in watching any others.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
When the Guardians + Ironman + Strange had Thanos pretty much subdued on Titan, why did they waste efforts try to get the glove off? Just chop off his fucking arm, TOTALLY!!!

Thor had the magic axe and went for the kill, why didn't he chop off the fucking arm FIRST? Or, like Thanos said, "Should've gone for the head"

"What's your claim?" - Ben Gravy
"Your best work is the work you're excited about" - Rick Rubin
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I enjoyed it.
Though I also loved "The Last Jedi" (especially the sick, sick 3D....best 3D by far I have ever seen). IMO, Infinity War didn't put Last Jedi to shame. I enjoyed both equally, but in different ways.

I see a big hole in Thanos' plan, but I deleted it not to give too much away.
Last edited by: Sshoreli: Apr 30, 18 10:23
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [MikeH in MD] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
There were one or two scenes that had individual effects that looked odd to me, but I was also watching on a Navy base theater screen, so not really the best quality.


POSSIBLE SPOILER ALERT BELOW








Near the end, when Bruce Banner was in the ironman hulk suit, he had the helmet off so you could see Bruce Banner. That effect looked really bad to me, it just didn't look polished at all, very sloppy CGI to me.
Last edited by: damn lucky: Apr 30, 18 15:30
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Quote:
. There is even a cameo from a character many people thought was long gone. Some of the minor characters are either missing or wrapped up pretty

That was the biggest surprise for me. It was fun seeing my sons reaction to it; draw dropped and wide eyed.

who's smarter than you're? i'm!
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [damn lucky] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
damn lucky wrote:
There were one or two scenes that had individual effects that looked odd to me, but I was also watching on a Navy base theater screen, so not really the best quality.


POSSIBLE SPOILER ALERT BELOW








Near the end, when Bruce Banner was in the ironman hulk suit, he had the helmet off so you could see Bruce Banner. That effect looked really bad to me, it just didn't look polished at all, very sloppy CGI to me.

That’s exactly the scene I had in mind.

Slowguy

(insert pithy phrase here...)
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [veganerd] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
veganerd wrote:
Quote:
There is even a cameo from a character many people thought was long gone. Some of the minor characters are either missing or wrapped up pretty


That was the biggest surprise for me. It was fun seeing my sons reaction to it; draw dropped and wide eyed.

You mean Stan Lee? He's old & broke, but not gone yet

https://www.forbes.com/...anager/#5ab832e6fef0

"What's your claim?" - Ben Gravy
"Your best work is the work you're excited about" - Rick Rubin
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [RandMart] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
RandMart wrote:
veganerd wrote:
Quote:
There is even a cameo from a character many people thought was long gone. Some of the minor characters are either missing or wrapped up pretty


That was the biggest surprise for me. It was fun seeing my sons reaction to it; draw dropped and wide eyed.


You mean Stan Lee? He's old & broke, but not gone yet

https://www.forbes.com/...anager/#5ab832e6fef0

No, not Stan Lee. He has a cameo in every marvel movie. Talking about who we meet on Vormir where Thanos goes after the Soul Stone.

A false humanity is used to impose its opposite, by people whose cruelty is equalled only by their arrogance
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [RandMart] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Quote:
You mean Stan Lee? He's old & broke, but not gone yet

You don't know that. 50/50 chance that he is gone at the end of the movie. Was there a crashing school bus in the last scene?
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Just saw it. My reviews are not near as eloquent as slowguy's. All I can say is holy f-in crap. If it hadn't ended the way that it did, knowing the comics and knowing there is a part 2, I would have been really disappointed.


SPOILER:















I just wish Thanos's one-shot of Cap was the same as in the comics too.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [bluemonkeytri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Can you explain more, I didn't read the comic?
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BRING ME THANOOOOOSS!
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [damn lucky] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Spoilers possible






As I recall, after Thanos has snapped his fingers, killed half of all,life in the universe, and defeated the Avengers, only Cap remains standing. He walks up to Thanos and says something like as long as one of us is still standing you haven't won, and Thanos kills him with one punch.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [oldandslow] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Okay, on reflection, this may be the best popcorn epic of all time (not best movie). As one critic siad, this is "the Empire Strikes Back" of this generation.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [rick_pcfl] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
rick_pcfl wrote:
That is a huge understatement. I haven't watched any of the recent Star Wars or DC movies with exception of Wonder Woman because my daughter had the movie. The last SW movie I watched was #7 - I watched it once and decided I wasn't interested in watching any others.
Same here, but I did watch borrow someone's copy of Justice League. I see almost every Marvel movie in the theater.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Why did they ditch the eye patch and give Thor a prosthetic eye?
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [Perseus] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I watched Justice League on demand, and came away with not a single scene making an impression on me. Watched it partially again the next day and still can't tell you anything about it. What a waste.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I went into this knowing nothing (other than having seen most of the other movies) about the plot, nor any future projects.


When the last scene went dark, I sighed out loud and said, audibly, "Aww, that's messed up." I sat there through the credits holding back my tears and reflected on how much I came to love all the characters. When the lights came on I turned to my wife and said, "Fuck, that was worse than Star Trek 2." (meaning the negative feels of the ending).


I absolutely plan to see this in the theater, again. I thought it was an unbelievably good movie.

-----------------------------Baron Von Speedypants
-----------------------------RunTraining articles here:
http://forum.slowtwitch.com/...runtraining;#1612485
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [BarryP] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I was there with my two boys, 9 and 5 (because I'm a terrible parent), and pretty much had the same response at the end. Really dark, and sad. I had no idea how this one would play out, but both boys had thoroughly enjoyed the previous MCU films and were really looking forward to this one. The older boy loved it, the younger probably didn't really get what was happening, but definitely picked up on the mood.

It's an impressive film. Thanos was beyond sympathetic in my viewing experience. He's only crazy by normative standards, and beings like him should exist and operate outside of those constraints.

Or maybe I'm just a sociopath. Who knows.

The devil made me do it the first time, second time I done it on my own - W
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [sphere] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
sphere wrote:
I was there with my two boys, 9 and 5 (because I'm a terrible parent), and pretty much had the same response at the end. Really dark, and sad. I had no idea how this one would play out, but both boys had thoroughly enjoyed the previous MCU films and were really looking forward to this one. The older boy loved it, the younger probably didn't really get what was happening, but definitely picked up on the mood.

It's an impressive film. Thanos was beyond sympathetic in my viewing experience. He's only crazy by normative standards, and beings like him should exist and operate outside of those constraints.

Or maybe I'm just a sociopath. Who knows.

Yeah, my pet peeve in this world is bad ideas that don't get challenged because interests aren't aligned to do so. Nobody in the MCU can argue against a Malthusian? Pathetic.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [SH] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Quote:
Yeah, my pet peeve in this world is bad ideas that don't get challenged because interests aren't aligned to do so. Nobody in the MCU can argue against a Malthusian? Pathetic.

What's the point? Do you argue with Hitler in 1944 over the virtues of Nazism?

(Does Godwin's Law apply to comic book threads?).
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [oldandslow] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
oldandslow wrote:
Quote:

Yeah, my pet peeve in this world is bad ideas that don't get challenged because interests aren't aligned to do so. Nobody in the MCU can argue against a Malthusian? Pathetic.


What's the point? Do you argue with Hitler in 1944 over the virtues of Nazism?

(Does Godwin's Law apply to comic book threads?).


Sometimes you crack me up.

Show me any modern movie about Nazis that doesn't challenge the precepts of Nazism. Besides, everyone is ready for the Nazis. Their ideas are constantly challenged, if not presented in a way as to make them patently ridiculous. Imagine Sphere making his comment about a WWII movie: Hilter was beyond sympathetic in my viewing experience. He's only crazy by normative standards, and beings like him should exist and operate outside of those constraints. Ha!

No, no, and no.

The point. The point is it's 2018 here on planet earth, infinity war is the biggest movie in history, the world revolves around ideas, and no one can argue the logic of the guy that wants to kill half the universe.
Last edited by: SH: May 7, 18 12:27
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [SH] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Quote:

The point. The point is it's 2018 here on planet earth, infinity war is the biggest movie in history, the world revolves around ideas, and no one can argue the logic of the guy that wants to kill half the universe.



Okay, I'm really not sure what you are pointing out. One can certainly argue for/against Malthusian doctrine, lots of folks have. Just did a production of "Urinetown" and they all sardonically cry "Hail, Malthus" at the end (one of the weirder moments). The world/universe may or may not revolve around ideas, comic book movies revolve around biceps, aliens and explosions. Are you saying that there should have been more support for Thanos' ideology, or that it is so wrong that it undercuts his motivation? I really don't know what you are getting at.

Okay, rereading your post, it seems that you wanted to have a long argument about how wrong Thanos is, preferably directed by Ingmar Bergman. It is presented a priori as wrong, and a different variation of evil motivation (he is called "the mad Titan" for a reason, and his slaughters and henchman are portrayed as evil). People don't waste time philosophically challenging Nazism in movies, they are always the "bad guys". This is probably a step up from a Sith Lord, who simply follows an amorphous "Dark Side" (you get a black cape and ominous music, that goes with the territory). It might be difficult to address this issue in a comic book epic.
Last edited by: oldandslow: May 7, 18 18:33
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [SH] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Quote:
The point is it's 2018 here on planet earth, infinity war is the biggest movie in history, the world revolves around ideas, and no one can argue the logic of the guy that wants to kill half the universe.

Maybe you should consider that this is a comic book movie. It's not that "nobody can argue" with Thanos' motivation. It's that the point is big action spectacle, not philosophical debate. If that's what you wanted, you need to find different movies to watch.

Slowguy

(insert pithy phrase here...)
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [slowguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Finally saw this over the weekend.

One question. Instead of killing half the universe due to scarce resources, why didn't Thanos just double the resources?

I'm beginning to think that we are much more fucked than I thought.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [j p o] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Because the Avengers have to fight him. :) Seriously though, in the comics he killed half the universe to impress the physical embodiment of Death in the hopes he could marry her. I guess that motive wouldn't translate well to the movies. My thought is that the sacrifice would cause all civilizations to take the stewardship of their resources seriously in the future to avoid this from happening again.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [j p o] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Probably much easier to destroy than create. If you think of the reality stone, it mostly transmuted objects. D you imagine creating twice as many inhabitable planets? C'mon, get real!
Last edited by: oldandslow: May 14, 18 13:44
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [j p o] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
j p o wrote:
Finally saw this over the weekend.

One question. Instead of killing half the universe due to scarce resources, why didn't Thanos just double the resources?

Yeah, the shown scale of civiliation in the MCU makes this "resource" storyline a total joke. Double the resources or halve the resources, who would notice? The Earth receives only 1/3 of one one billionth of the Sun's energy. Hell, all of the remaining Asgardians fit on a ship about as long as a football field. Thanos and his entire entourage emanate out of one ship only a few hundred times larger than the Asgardian ship? I guess most people are just ignorant to the scale of the vast treasure of the universe that science might unlock.

What "resources" can these galactic travelers possibly lack?
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [SH] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Finally saw it this weekend as well. My biggest quesrion was why didn't they just cut off Thanos' arm instead of trying to pull the glove off?

--------------------------
The secret of a long life is you try not to shorten it.
-Nobody
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [mck414] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mck414 wrote:
Finally saw it this weekend as well. My biggest quesrion was why didn't they just cut off Thanos' arm instead of trying to pull the glove off?

That would be gross. And what kind of character would Thanos be without an arm?
Quote Reply
Post deleted by Calamityjane88 [ In reply to ]
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [Calamityjane88] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Quote:
Did Dr. Strange really see 1 possible outcome out of the 14 billion scenarios where they could win or was he just trying to keep up morale?

14,000,605. 1 in 14M isn't much of a morale booster....
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [oldandslow] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
oldandslow wrote:
Quote:

Did Dr. Strange really see 1 possible outcome out of the 14 billion scenarios where they could win or was he just trying to keep up morale?


14,000,605. 1 in 14M isn't much of a morale booster....

[Spoilers Below.]

I dunno.

When he said that, Strange still had the time stone, and maybe could steer events towards that one improbable victorious outcome. I thought that might have been why he gave the stone to Thanos, and when asked why by Stark replied, "we're in the end game now".

Maybe in a sequel, giving the stone to Thanos to spare Stark will be pivotal in ultimately defeating Thanos due to that 1 in 14M outcome. (Or, maybe Strange just realized that defeat was inevitable when he gave up the stone....)


"100% of the people who confuse correlation and causation end up dying."
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [j p o] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
"One question. Instead of killing half the universe due to scarce resources, why didn't Thanos just double the resources?"

Because he can't, and even if he could it would never work.

Now that that's out of the way, wow, what an awesome movie! Ask another plot hole question and get punched in the face!!!

-----------------------------Baron Von Speedypants
-----------------------------RunTraining articles here:
http://forum.slowtwitch.com/...runtraining;#1612485
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [MOP_Mike] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
MOP_Mike wrote:
oldandslow wrote:
Quote:

Did Dr. Strange really see 1 possible outcome out of the 14 billion scenarios where they could win or was he just trying to keep up morale?


14,000,605. 1 in 14M isn't much of a morale booster....


[Spoilers Below.]

I dunno.

When he said that, Strange still had the time stone, and maybe could steer events towards that one improbable victorious outcome. I thought that might have been why he gave the stone to Thanos, and when asked why by Stark replied, "we're in the end game now".

Maybe in a sequel, giving the stone to Thanos to spare Stark will be pivotal in ultimately defeating Thanos due to that 1 in 14M outcome. (Or, maybe Strange just realized that defeat was inevitable when he gave up the stone....)

That was my take. In the one future he saw where they won, Stark played a key role. So if Thanos kills Stark there's no hope left, hence it made sense to give up the Time stone to save Stark. Maybe he saw himself giving up the Time stone in that future as well.

I'm guessing in the next movie there's going to be some time travel, with at least some of the heroes going back in time to get the stones before Thanos can. Maybe via Antman going subatomic. With them already having announced Spiderman and Guardians sequels it certainly seems that Spidey and at least some of the Guardians are going to get brought back (think Rocket is the only Guardian left alive right now?).
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have no doubt that they’ll be bringing a number of characters ‘Back from the dead.’ In addition to the ones you mentioned, I think they already have Black Panther prequels planned as well.

I was disappointed that Black Widow survived. In personally think Scarlet Johansen is a terrible actor and would rather see almost anyone else have her screen time in the sequel.

Matt
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [Pun_Times] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Pun_Times wrote:
I personally think Scarlet Johansen is a terrible actor and would rather see almost anyone else have her screen time in the sequel.

Take whatever role she's in and replace her with Katheryn Winnick from Vikings, and I'm all in.



The devil made me do it the first time, second time I done it on my own - W
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [oldandslow] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
oldandslow wrote:
Probably much easier to destroy than create. If you think of the reality stone, it mostly transmuted objects. D you imagine creating twice as many inhabitable planets? C'mon, get real!

Plus, if we assume Thanos is right and the universe is overstretched on resources, would just creating more resources really solve the problem? Would it really wake life up to,the fact that resources are limited and must be respected? Thanos was Marvels Ozymandias.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [BarryP] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
So I saw today that James Gunn told a fan what Groot's last line was in Infinity War. As he is disintegrating, he looks as Rocket and says "Dad". And you thought Spider-man's exit was a tear-jerker.....
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [bluemonkeytri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Missed that line, might have to go watch it again!

Can we all agree October 5, 2018 will be a day to spend in the theater?


--------------------------
The secret of a long life is you try not to shorten it.
-Nobody
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [mck414] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Well, he says "I am Groot" but means dad.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [bluemonkeytri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
bluemonkeytri wrote:
So I saw today that James Gunn told a fan what Groot's last line was in Infinity War. As he is disintegrating, he looks as Rocket and says "Dad". And you thought Spider-man's exit was a tear-jerker.....

When no deaths are permanent, none of them are sad. We all assume that someone will use the gauntlet and/or some of the stones to reset things and some/most/all of the characters will come back to life.

Later we might find out that someone is completely dead and not just mostly dead. But that won't sting near as much as seeing Groot evaporate and knowing he is dead dead.

It really makes any sacrifice or death meaningless and takes away from the movies.

And I say this as someone who has seen all of the movies and enjoys them.

I'm beginning to think that we are much more fucked than I thought.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [j p o] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
MY wife is pretty certain when Strange was using the Time Stone to find a way to beat Thanos, he simply created an alternate universe where all those disintegrated went to. However, that doesn't account for Loki and Gamora who died by means other than Thanos' finger snap.

--------------------------
The secret of a long life is you try not to shorten it.
-Nobody
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [mck414] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mck414 wrote:
MY wife is pretty certain when Strange was using the Time Stone to find a way to beat Thanos, he simply created an alternate universe where all those disintegrated went to. However, that doesn't account for Loki and Gamora who died by means other than Thanos' finger snap.

I’m with your wife. I don’t think this is the first time Thanos has done this. Hence the scene with toddler Gamora asking him was it worth it. I think it has happened when she was actually that young at some point in an alternate universe.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [TimeIsUp] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TimeIsUp wrote:
mck414 wrote:
MY wife is pretty certain when Strange was using the Time Stone to find a way to beat Thanos, he simply created an alternate universe where all those disintegrated went to. However, that doesn't account for Loki and Gamora who died by means other than Thanos' finger snap.


I’m with your wife. I don’t think this is the first time Thanos has done this. Hence the scene with toddler Gamora asking him was it worth it. I think it has happened when she was actually that young at some point in an alternate universe.

That scene with Thanos and toddler Gamora actually took place in the Soul Stone (http://www.digitalspy.com/...ne-theory-confirmed/), which has the ability to create pocket universes. So yes, I think instead of dying, those that disappeared went to another universe.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [bluemonkeytri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
bluemonkeytri wrote:
TimeIsUp wrote:
mck414 wrote:
MY wife is pretty certain when Strange was using the Time Stone to find a way to beat Thanos, he simply created an alternate universe where all those disintegrated went to. However, that doesn't account for Loki and Gamora who died by means other than Thanos' finger snap.


I’m with your wife. I don’t think this is the first time Thanos has done this. Hence the scene with toddler Gamora asking him was it worth it. I think it has happened when she was actually that young at some point in an alternate universe.


That scene with Thanos and toddler Gamora actually took place in the Soul Stone (http://www.digitalspy.com/...ne-theory-confirmed/), which has the ability to create pocket universes. So yes, I think instead of dying, those that disappeared went to another universe.

Well, it can either contain pocket universes, or it can contain the soul of the person sacrificed for its possession (Gamora).
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [SH] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
SH wrote:
bluemonkeytri wrote:
TimeIsUp wrote:
mck414 wrote:
MY wife is pretty certain when Strange was using the Time Stone to find a way to beat Thanos, he simply created an alternate universe where all those disintegrated went to. However, that doesn't account for Loki and Gamora who died by means other than Thanos' finger snap.


I’m with your wife. I don’t think this is the first time Thanos has done this. Hence the scene with toddler Gamora asking him was it worth it. I think it has happened when she was actually that young at some point in an alternate universe.


That scene with Thanos and toddler Gamora actually took place in the Soul Stone (http://www.digitalspy.com/...ne-theory-confirmed/), which has the ability to create pocket universes. So yes, I think instead of dying, those that disappeared went to another universe.


Well, it can either contain pocket universes, or it can contain the soul of the person sacrificed for its possession (Gamora).

Or both.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [bluemonkeytri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply

Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [bluemonkeytri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Finally got to see this over Memorial Day weekend. That was everything I hoped Infinity War would be. Love my wife's reaction at the end: WTH, not cool. Me: There's a Part 2. Her: You should have told me that before the movie started.

One area better than the comics: The almost sympathetic feelings you get for Thanos. I had thought with the introduction of Hela in Raganrok they were going to introduce the Lady Death part of the storyline, but this was just as good if not better.

One area that could have been more like the comics: More of the Avengers killed like in the comics. The Infinity Gauntlet had so many cool deaths, Cloak, Cap., Wolverine(not fully dead), War Machine, IronMan etc.





Spoiler:





If they are going to bring everyone back, i hope they let the person who did it in the comics, do it in a similar fashion in the movie.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [ubdawg] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
OK, so how many original Avengers survived? All of them. How many are there? 6. How many may have their contracts up? Depending on what you read, maybe all of them are done. How many Infinity Stones are there? 6. Coincidence? Maybe, maybe not. It took all of the Guardians (sans Groot) to wield the Power Stone. Maybe all 6 original Avengers together can wield the Gauntlet. Together they sacrifice themselves to restore the universe and then destroy (or take and hide) the Stones.

But I am with you, I hope the character in the comics has a major say in the outcome. I hope they don't use Carol Danvers instead.
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [bluemonkeytri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I remember the Russo Brothers saying that they didn't want to retell a story that's already been told, so I guess the second film will depart from the comic story line significantly.

I also wondered whether Hela would fill the role of Lady Death, and whether Loki would cover the role that Mephisto played in the comics. Different story though...
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [RandMart] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
RandMart wrote:
When the Guardians + Ironman + Strange had Thanos pretty much subdued on Titan, why did they waste efforts try to get the glove off? Just chop off his fucking arm, TOTALLY!!!

Thor had the magic axe and went for the kill, why didn't he chop off the fucking arm FIRST? Or, like Thanos said, "Should've gone for the head"

Finally saw it. Having read most of this thread I knew what Thanos was going to win and what he was going to do. Ruined it for me. By the end I was on the side of Thanos because he was the only competent character who did not do stupid things. I was pissed off at the end that any of the idiot avengers got to survive.

Tony Stark was supposed to be a smart guy? He takes one of the infinity stones to Thanos. Idiot. Hate that he survived.

Vision: Half the population in the world is going to be vaporized. Nobody can stop Thanos so he is going to pull that damn stone out of your head. Don't ask Scarlett Witch to kill you. She won't do it till it is too late. Pull it out of your head and let her vaporize it. You two are in love, so I'll give both of you a pass.

Gamora: Your lie didn't work, so you just go ahead and just lead Thanos to the stone. You asked the idiot boy friend to kill you, but you can't lead Thanos on a wild goose chase and just kill yourself at some point?

Quill, your plan to subdue Thanos has almost worked. Passing on the easy opportunity to cut off his arm, the gauntlet is almost removed and now you are going to slap some sense into Thanos and wake him up. Nice. Well you were always stupid, so I'll give you a pass.

Well, good thing we had some humor on the way to half of population of the universe being exterminated. Now we see what was Joseph Goebbels' failing: genocide needs some humor along the way.

Three stones needed by the bad guy are in possession/control of the good guys. Good guys take bad guy to one stone and take another to the bad guy. The last stone is taken to valiant people who are exterminated trying to protect good guys who are too weak to do what needs to be done to save half humanity.

I can root for a bumbling hero, e.g. Inspector Clouseau, if the hero wins. Avengers were fun entertainment when they won. Now they are playing the role of James Bond villains, making it easy for the other side. Thanos is only sympathetic because he has some admirable characteristics unlike the idiot avengers.

Goes to show that decent action, effects, a few good characters (Thor, Black Panther, Spider Boy), and a serious sad ending can cover up for a stupid story that makes a mass killer seem a sympathetic character.

________
It doesn't really matter what Phil is saying, the music of his voice is the appropriate soundtrack for a bicycle race. HTupolev
Quote Reply
Re: Movie Review: Avengers - Infinity War [H-] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Quote:
Goes to show that decent action, effects, a few good characters (Thor, Black Panther, Spider Boy), and a serious sad ending can cover up for a stupid story that makes a mass killer seem a sympathetic character.

You do remember this is basically just a big screen comic book, right? Of course the story is stupid.

Slowguy

(insert pithy phrase here...)
Quote Reply