paull wrote:
And AC has been caught out quoting a statement from a paper of which he is co author and yet he now says he did not agree with that statement - nice one TrevI certainly don't think that Tim expressed things perfectly. But, I don't believe that Trev's interpretation of events is correct, either.
More globally: what many people don't seem to realize is that just because you are the co-author of a publication, it doesn't necessarily mean that you agree with everything single word/phrase/sentence written by others. That isn't true even in the case of formal scientific publications.
paull wrote:
I see that many of the respected physiologists do not take AC seriously, since he exited physiology academia many years ago.Pardon my French, but WTF are you talking about? I am currently PI, co-PI, or co-I on four grants totaling ~$1.2M, have published 14 papers in the last 3 y, have two more in preparation, have a review article under consideration at ESSR, and just won an award for my research efforts from my school. Indeed, I have never been busier with real work (which is why I have stepped away from my hobbies, e.g., am no longer contributing to WKO4).
Last edited by:
Andrew Coggan: May 20, 18 14:38