In Reply To:
The whole situation is quite simple. Your legs do not float. Even the feeblest kick will create some lift. The band drill shows you how important a kick is to your balance and speed. If you are an accomplished swimmer you will be able to generate enough speed to keep your legs on the surface with the band but you must point your toes while doing it.
Kick a length of the pool with a kickboard as you normally do. Now kick another length. At the halfway mark instead of pointing your toes like a ballet dancer (plantar flexion) point them the other way (dorsi flexion) notice what happens instantly.
Your kick is very important in maintaining balance and speed. A poor kick can kill you in the water and it is a matter of ankle flexibility. If you spend as much time kicking as you do complaining about kicking you will develop strong legs for swimming.
Hard work will get you to the finish line. Smart work will get you there first. Choose your parents well.
doug Stern
My masters coach says it's my kick that is killing me -- exactly as you suggest. Not because of failing to point my toes, but rather because I bicycle kick at times, especially when I breathe and get tired. Nothing good can come from that! So far, I haven't been able to fix the kick problem.
**************
Too f@ckin depressed from various injuries to care about having a signature line.
Sponsored by Blue Shield PPO.