[reply]I have always wondered why I haven't gotten the mileage out of my shoes that I should(I still don't know why I don't)? As far as myself, I am 5'9", 155-160 & right now I am in Mizuno Waves I wish I could get another another 150-200 miles out of a pair! I would love to have my gait analyzed but places that do this are hard to come by.[/reply]
DO NOT attempt to get more miles out of your Mizuno Waves. I am 5'11" 155lb and I would definitely not recommend anything more than about 250 miles on a pair, maybe less. I ended up hurting my right hip pretty significantly by running too long on wornout shoes.
Regarding the original post, the best way I found to tell is to wear your shoes to a store that carries them, get a pair in your size...run 20 or 30 yards in your pair and put on the new pair and do the same. When your shoes are worn you will be able to tell an immediate difference. Any reputable running store will let you run a short distance in them to make sure they feel right, most will watch you and tell you if they see you running strangely.
AJ, I find that a training log is my most valuable partner. I keep split times on all my runs, so I can see if I am dropping off near the end of a run or keeping it up. I have Excel automatically give me a "run pace" and "run pace with water stops" for my water fountain breaks. I have a column on the far right of the page for notes, where I note when I buy a new pair of shoes, how my legs felt, any unusual circumstances (dog repeats, etc) and any pain or tightness. I can then look back over years of training and see trends and problems. Once I made the log, I can't imagine training without it...an indispensible reference for me.