cgrubb wrote:
These threads are always full of the people who have had bad luck with the specific tyre being debated in the thread - those who have none or very few problems tend to stay silent. So very easy for the redaer to take away the message that Corsa Speeds are a nightmare and everybody punctures. Not the case.
I have a set of Corsa speeds that I use for TT's along with latex tubes - definitely not for training though, there is no point using such an expensive and relatively fragile tyre for training! - so far so good and after approx 250km (touch-wood) on the first set I have had no problems - they actually still look like new - but I am aware they are fragile and will not last forever, so I am not going to push my luck and so I am about to switch them before my next race to a new set just to be on the safe side.
If you look at the data the speed gain is very worthwhile - but it is a gamble - you will of course puncture more than you would on a more bullet proof set of tyres - I think it all depends on how ready you are to sacrifice the occasional result (lets say 1 race in 10 you get a puncture) - whilst knowing in 90% of the races you likely won't puncture and you can be sure you will be materially faster.
Sorry I disagree with your first point. There have been way more complaints on this forum about Corsa Speed and flats than any other tyre. But then these tyres are not designed for triathlon. Perhaps people don't get what the Corsa Speed is designed for. It's designed for short TTs on perfect roads. Like you said it's fragile and not suited to triathlon. Some people have used them in long course with no problem, but that doesn't mean they're not fragile and not puncture prone. Vittoria even admit they have little puncture protection and are only good for time trials. People get sucked in when they hear how fast they are. It's probably worth running them in certain situations i.e if you're not gunning for a Kona spot. Training hard for 3 months for an IM, you'd be gutted if you flatted and doubly gutted if you flatted on something you knew was puncture prone.
I guess the TDF tyre selection says it all, they only use the Corsa Speed for the TT, the majority of the teams run Conti Comp, 30% heavier than the Corsa with decent puncture protection.