david wrote:
That rainy day came and I finally listened.
CAVEAT - I am not much of a podcast person. I can read MUCH faster, and I think most podcasts have too much drivel and waste my time. I also think many/most podcasts could deliver the message much more efficiently and entertainingly. I would include these in this category. I really like both of you guys so I really don't want to be overly critical, but I think this could be greatly improved. Just rambling is not very interesting to me. I know these are hard to do, but under the ST brank these have to be better than the others and I don't think these are/were. These were not my cup of tea.
I listened to both episodes.
Ryan said something in the first, something like "we have a very large rolodex we can call on". I think this is the thing they need to leverage. There are definitely areas where Ryan and Eric's experience is interesting, but their own opinions are not enough to fill up an interesting podcast. I think they needed to set the table in episode one. I think they did this quite well.
I think they need to bring in experts in the various fields they plan to explore. A great formula would be : pick a topic, bring an expert and possibly fire up a specific Forum thread to discuss. Or fire up a thread, announce a guest, take questions, do the podcast and follow up discussion in a specific thread. This would be very unique. Nobody has the mechanism to do this like ST does.
For episode 2, and maybe I am just sensitive here, but I heard a strong bias towards IM and a negativity towards the PTO. That sensitivity may come from other actions and comments, and/or having a personal bias myself. But I believe it dilutes the "fiercely independent" mantra. For me, Joe nobody in the triathlon world is ok, for ST, not so much. Very much an opinion there, others may have heard it differently.
Having a forum is a pretty unique situation. You can do things nobody else can. But you also have a forum for criticism which you probably have to be pretty think skinned to handle. I hope the above comments were not just perceived as criticism.