Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Prev Next
Re: Lionel's encore?! [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
thinking lionel belongs in the same bracket as literal multiple Kona / 70.3 WC winners over the last decade, because he got a 2nd place there once and won a soft field arizona race..... and i'm apparently the one living in a fantasy world.

fanboys gonna fanboy.

equating the arizona race to Frankfurt in prestige, strength and depth of field over the last decade, and longer, is a great encapsulation of what one finds on ST as well.

Feel the Speed
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [BigBoyND] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
BigBoyND wrote:
Really curious how it plays out. Lionel seemed to have figured out that with an even pace, he can easily get sub-8. But that strategy probably won't get him on a podium at this race. On the other hand, Cam's bike pace is probably not sustainable, either.

My guesses for the future prediction thread:
- Lionel will push harder on the bike this race but still let Cam go. Gradually works his way up during the bike and run to 3rd or 4th depending on Iden bonking or not
- Iden comes off the bike in 3rd behind Jan and Cam, passes Cam on the run but doesn't reduce the gap to Jan by more than a minute. Comes in 2nd or bonks
- Cam catches Iden on the bike, who stays with him for a while before he also let's him go. Cam get's close to Jan before T2 but get caught by Iden on the run. 2nd or 3rd place depending on Iden bonking or not
- Jan leads wire-to-wire in another master class

But will this count as a record with a downriver swim?
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [FtStri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
FtStri wrote:
thinking lionel belongs in the same bracket as literal multiple Kona / 70.3 WC winners over the last decade, because he got a 2nd place there once and won a soft field arizona race..... and i'm apparently the one living in a fantasy world.

fanboys gonna fanboy.

equating the arizona race to Frankfurt in prestige, strength and depth of field over the last decade, and longer, is a great encapsulation of what one finds on ST as well.

Your opinion that Frankfort should mean something is pretty meaningless to me. It tends to have "better" fields. But it's meaningless for prestige for me. There's basically two races that have "prestige" and mythology. Those are Roth and Kona. That's it.

But the fields at Frankfort are OMFG the best on earth ever like you're attempting to state. But you guys are funny. I say look at his resume, but you decide to move the line to say he chose to race weak competition. No, that's not the case. He raced within his means as a younger triathlete. Now that he's got major sponsorship he can afford to go do things that he has been afforded. At the end of the day, his peers and race organizers like the PTO see Lionel as a CONTENDER. That's it. So why you want to keep dragging him down I don't know...but keep moving the line so you feel better.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
BigBoyND wrote:
Really curious how it plays out. Lionel seemed to have figured out that with an even pace, he can easily get sub-8. But that strategy probably won't get him on a podium at this race. On the other hand, Cam's bike pace is probably not sustainable, either.

My guesses for the future prediction thread:
- Lionel will push harder on the bike this race but still let Cam go. Gradually works his way up during the bike and run to 3rd or 4th depending on Iden bonking or not
- Iden comes off the bike in 3rd behind Jan and Cam, passes Cam on the run but doesn't reduce the gap to Jan by more than a minute. Comes in 2nd or bonks
- Cam catches Iden on the bike, who stays with him for a while before he also let's him go. Cam get's close to Jan before T2 but get caught by Iden on the run. 2nd or 3rd place depending on Iden bonking or not
- Jan leads wire-to-wire in another master class

But will this count as a record with a downriver swim?

A record is a record provided the course isn't short. I think a record will be set at this race.
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
the original response was to add balance and reality to some fanboy nonsense claiming lionel has one of the greatest resumes of the last decade, rather than dragging him down.

it's grossly disrespectful to what the other athletes have worked to achieve, to put lionel in that same bracket for a handful of wins against weak fields and a second place in Kona - work that lionel has steadfastly refused to do to get to that level, as he's always thought he knows best, and every year we get a similar post Kona/ end of season video from him.

those who actually belong in that bracket have even multiple Kona / 70.3 WC wins over that period and on top of that, many wins in the biggest races in the sport outside of Kona and the 70.3 WC's, e.g. Frankfurt and Roth, which have always had some of the most competitive fields, whether they mean anything to you or not is irrelevant, along with last years Daytona race - which lionel did not win either.

lionel has a great resume that many would love, but it's far far off 'one of the greatest resumes over the last decade' - and despite that being obvious, even from a quick scan of results, the fanboys still cry about him getting a 2nd in Kona or 4th in Daytona and claiming he's up there with those who actually win these events - and multiple times. there are many European athletes who have achieved very similar results to lionel, who you wouldn't dream of putting in this 'one of the greatest' brackets. difference is, lionel has this cult fanboy club.


as for the dodging races - he's consistently dodged the 70.3 WC's, not just this year, which has historically even been his strongest distance.

this year, very obviously Tulsa had the stronger field over CdA and yet he chose CdA. he then chose the very obviously weaker field in Copenhagen, where even Wurf wasn't due to race until the last moment, over racing Frankfurt. and instead of simply staying in Europe after the Tri Battle, he chose to fly back and forth to the US. many European athletes perfectly well stay in the US for multiple races across months in order to manage their travel and training, but just another thing that lionel wasn't able to handle.

his reasons for choosing the weaker fields are perfectly understandable, but he can't then come out on youtube yelling about how he seeks out racing the best, as he has done many times, while his fanboys pedal this 'he's one of the greatest' nonsense. reality hurts for this group.

Feel the Speed
Last edited by: FtStri: Oct 15, 21 7:17
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [FtStri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This is the guy who ridiculed Iden for showing up in Nice on a road bike. Read what he writes in a few threads and put him on your red list as many have done before you.
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [AS88] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
thanks - multiple red clown flags in each of his posts

Feel the Speed
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [AS88] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
AS88 wrote:
This is the guy who ridiculed Iden for showing up in Nice on a road bike. Read what he writes in a few threads and put him on your red list as many have done before you.

Ok guy, on this board there were tons of people who did the same thing. And then we all found out why he didn't ride a tri bike, he wasn't sponsored. Just like the dozens of people on this board that were critical of Knibb for not having a tri bike...but as I pointed out in multiple threads and people kept forgetting or just didn't care to read and or listen to her interviews...she didn't own one. The only clown here is the guy who keeps moving the goal posts on what someone's resume means.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [FtStri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
FtStri wrote:
thinking lionel belongs in the same bracket as literal multiple Kona / 70.3 WC winners over the last decade, because he got a 2nd place there once and won a soft field arizona race..... and i'm apparently the one living in a fantasy world.

fanboys gonna fanboy.

equating the arizona race to Frankfurt in prestige, strength and depth of field over the last decade, and longer, is a great encapsulation of what one finds on ST as well.


I think many if not most people who are fans of LS are not fans because of his resume, but because he's interesting.
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [SBRcanuck] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
SBRcanuck wrote:

I think many if not most people who are fans of LS are not fans because of his resume, but because he's interesting.

^ This.
He might probably not be as entertaining if he was as strong as Jan.
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [devashish_paul] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
devashish_paul wrote:
ThailandUltras wrote:
TheStroBro wrote:
ThailandUltras wrote:
TheStroBro wrote:

Doubling down and being wrong is hilarious. The way this sport worked, before this year, outside of Kona every field was weak. (just race for points and not wins) And then the one year where it went to a win or get second qualification system we went straight into a pandemic. But hey, live in your fantasy world that Frankfort was somehow better than Arizona.

.
.
Lionel hasn't won an Ironman in four years but if you were to arrive at the sport as a newbie the constant hype would have you believe that he has won everything.Yes he has performed well in a bunch of races but he hasn't dominated anything except YouTube whereas all the other guys who have won multiple Ironman's in the last few years,in fast times, including regional championships are totally ignored. It is hilarious.
.
You love to throw the term "hater" around but that is just a cheap Kafka Trap to try and move the discussion away from the point at hand and that is, people are allowed to both, appreciate and follow Lionel's exploits as an elite triathlete while at the same time shake our collective heads at the rabid,one-eyed fans who feel the need defend some perceived personal attack on Lionel himself.For the millionth time,we are not talking about Lionel per se, but the fans who don't accept that Lionel himself says the same things about his place in the sport that we do.
.
If any other Kona podium guy had failed to win any Ironman, anywhere, in the four years since that podium performance,he would be written off as a has-been as far as Kona goes. Lionel is an exceptional talent but I fear he will go down in history as the greatest to never have won any of the majors, but that is sport.
.
.


One thing that frustrates me about your posts is all the useless periods you input!

On the topic, how many guys can ever be second at Kona? Only one per season. Podium guys at Kona that have failed to win races in the last four years...well you've got Lange, TO, Hoff, all in that conversation.

.
Yes,and none of those guys are even remotely given the adulation that is piled on Lionel and one of them is a multiple Ironman World Champion who is treated with distain here. They are all largely ignored by everyone,especially here on ST.
.
Lionel is a 70.3 specialist who himself said before the 70.3 worlds that he wasn't in the shape to take on the Norwegians so he was going to bypass (his specialty distance) to focus on Ironman only to say,the week after the St George 70.3 Worlds that he would have done well against the field that showed up. WTF! The dude is all over the place which is highly entertaining.
.
The "Lionel Tribe" is fascinating to me and as much as I'd love to see Lionel actually pull off a win against a stacked field,part of me wants to see how many years the blind faith fans will continue to treat him with such reverence for continuing the second place streak in Ironman races.


Jurgen Zack is getting pissed off right now that you're giving all of ths credit to Lionel for finishing second at Kona 2017 and winning no other Ironmans. Jurgen was second at kona 1997 after going sub 8 the same year at Roth (and also not winning) and to my recollecton winning no other Ironmans after that 2nd

Lionel actually backed up his Kona 2017 2nd wiith an 7:54 win in his very next race at Arizona!!!

Here is the link to Lionel's finisher certificate (remember those) :

https://feathersprod.blob.core.windows.net/...932-23E6705B4BDE.pdf


Juergen Zaeck also got a 2 year suspension for I believe of a metabolite called Etiocholanolone?
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [pwai] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
pwai wrote:
SBRcanuck wrote:


I think many if not most people who are fans of LS are not fans because of his resume, but because he's interesting.


^ This.
He might probably not be as entertaining if he was as strong as Jan.

More relatable, entertaining AF, and a great story teller. Same reason golf fans love John Daly.
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [Sof'ingmoney] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sof'ingmoney wrote:
pwai wrote:
SBRcanuck wrote:


I think many if not most people who are fans of LS are not fans because of his resume, but because he's interesting.


^ This.
He might probably not be as entertaining if he was as strong as Jan.

More relatable, entertaining AF, and a great story teller. Same reason golf fans love John Daly.

Bingo. I don’t understand why some can’t grasp this. The best and the most popular don’t always coincide. The more bizarre result to me would be for all of us to only love in the “best”.
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [Sof'ingmoney] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'll bet anyone on this thread, that Lionel can eat 50 eggs, in a hour.

http://www.fitspeek.com the Fraser Valley's fitness, wellness, and endurance sports podcast
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [Hydrosloth] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
No he can’t.

"FTP is a bit 2015, don't you think?" - Gustav Iden
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [Hydrosloth] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hydrosloth wrote:
I'll bet anyone on this thread, that Lionel can eat 50 eggs, in a hour.

Isn't he vegan ?
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [FtStri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
FtStri wrote:
the original response was to add balance and reality to some fanboy nonsense claiming lionel has one of the greatest resumes of the last decade, rather than dragging him down.

it's grossly disrespectful to what the other athletes have worked to achieve

How is it disrespectful? Do you get angry at work when a colleague gets a compliment? Lifting one person up is not putting another down. Slowman didn't say Lionel is the best, but one of the best. If winning 140.6 WC or 70.3 WC is your only criteria then he doesn't fit, but that's ignoring what is otherwise a great resume. And as someone else mentioned, just because you define "one of the greatest" as top 0.1 percentile of the pro field while another person draws the line at top 1 percentile, doesn't mean either of you is wrong. Your arguments are just explaining why he doesn't cross your threshold, which has nothing to do with Slowman's threshold.

Btw, if you use the term "fanboy", then that just makes you sound like a "hater." It really doesn't do your argument any favors.
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [FtStri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
FtStri wrote:
the original response was to add balance and reality to some fanboy nonsense claiming lionel has one of the greatest resumes of the last decade, rather than dragging him down.

it's grossly disrespectful to what the other athletes have worked to achieve, to put lionel in that same bracket for a handful of wins against weak fields and a second place in Kona - work that lionel has steadfastly refused to do to get to that level, as he's always thought he knows best, and every year we get a similar post Kona/ end of season video from him.

those who actually belong in that bracket have even multiple Kona / 70.3 WC wins over that period and on top of that, many wins in the biggest races in the sport outside of Kona and the 70.3 WC's, e.g. Frankfurt and Roth, which have always had some of the most competitive fields, whether they mean anything to you or not is irrelevant, along with last years Daytona race - which lionel did not win either.

lionel has a great resume that many would love, but it's far far off 'one of the greatest resumes over the last decade' - and despite that being obvious, even from a quick scan of results, the fanboys still cry about him getting a 2nd in Kona or 4th in Daytona and claiming he's up there with those who actually win these events - and multiple times. there are many European athletes who have achieved very similar results to lionel, who you wouldn't dream of putting in this 'one of the greatest' brackets. difference is, lionel has this cult fanboy club.


as for the dodging races - he's consistently dodged the 70.3 WC's, not just this year, which has historically even been his strongest distance.

this year, very obviously Tulsa had the stronger field over CdA and yet he chose CdA. he then chose the very obviously weaker field in Copenhagen, where even Wurf wasn't due to race until the last moment, over racing Frankfurt. and instead of simply staying in Europe after the Tri Battle, he chose to fly back and forth to the US. many European athletes perfectly well stay in the US for multiple races across months in order to manage their travel and training, but just another thing that lionel wasn't able to handle.

his reasons for choosing the weaker fields are perfectly understandable, but he can't then come out on youtube yelling about how he seeks out racing the best, as he has done many times, while his fanboys pedal this 'he's one of the greatest' nonsense. reality hurts for this group.

Imagine caring this much that someone is getting more credit than you deem they deserve
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TheStroBro wrote:
AS88 wrote:
The only clown here is the guy who keeps moving the goal posts on what someone's resume means.

which clown is doing that?

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
If you look at my back and fourth with FtStri he's just trying to drag down Lionel's accomplishments and say he's ducked people and not chosen to go to "prestigious" races. There is no way of knowing whether or not Lionel has chosen to duck people and second guessing his decisions based on the blow ups we've seen when we know what the goal is: Get to Kona.

I've been racing Tri for 5 years and following it for 4 and I don't know how Frankfort is meant to be prestigious at all. If it is, great I guess. But it doesn't carry mythology for me considering I'm a "new" fan of triathlon and that the races for me that hold any mythology are Kona and Roth to some extent.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Slowman wrote:
TheStroBro wrote:
AS88 wrote:
The only clown here is the guy who keeps moving the goal posts on what someone's resume means.


which clown is doing that?

minimally Lionel has been consistent in saying that Jan, Lange, Iden and Blum are pretty great. It seems to be the one thing he is consistent on...and perhaps racing almost every weekend (well minus St. George, so maybe not that consistent). The guy even created his own race of one person where there was no racing and went 51.3 km in an hour on a velodrome!!! How many guys tried that ???
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TheStroBro wrote:
If you look at my back and fourth with FtStri he's just trying to drag down Lionel's accomplishments and say he's ducked people and not chosen to go to "prestigious" races. There is no way of knowing whether or not Lionel has chosen to duck people and second guessing his decisions based on the blow ups we've seen when we know what the goal is: Get to Kona.

I've been racing Tri for 5 years and following it for 4 and I don't know how Frankfort is meant to be prestigious at all. If it is, great I guess. But it doesn't carry mythology for me considering I'm a "new" fan of triathlon and that the races for me that hold any mythology are Kona and Roth to some extent.

Frankfurt is a huge race in Europe and has been for a long time. It is the European IM Championship and not scheduled for right after Kona like AZ or FL, for example. It isn't a big deal that you didn't know of its status but I'd advise against railing against being corrected on this. It just isn't a great look.

I agree that there are some people who are just jealous and are now stuck in the "Lionel sucks" category. I see no problem with him choosing Copenhagen over Frankfurt. He needed the KQ. I personally get frustrated with the chopping and changing and thus likely never approaching his potential.
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [TheStroBro] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TheStroBro wrote:
If you look at my back and fourth with FtStri he's just trying to drag down Lionel's accomplishments and say he's ducked people and not chosen to go to "prestigious" races. There is no way of knowing whether or not Lionel has chosen to duck people and second guessing his decisions based on the blow ups we've seen when we know what the goal is: Get to Kona.

I've been racing Tri for 5 years and following it for 4 and I don't know how Frankfort is meant to be prestigious at all. If it is, great I guess. But it doesn't carry mythology for me considering I'm a "new" fan of triathlon and that the races for me that hold any mythology are Kona and Roth to some extent.


frankfurt is more prestigious if you're european, especially if you're from germany. especially if you're a young german based racer, and you haven't been around long enough to have seen the arc in the sport. germany does have the truly prestigious race, but it's not frankfurt. IM lost the most prized race outside of Kona, which was IM germany (in roth). that race became challenge roth. IM placed a race in frankfurt because it needed a german race, but you could throw as much prize money as you want at that race and it will never be roth. now...

as resumes go, lionel is undeniably among the top half dozen men since he's been racing (the last 7 years), at the half and full distance. just look at the resume. only jan, sebi, patrick have won the big one (kona, not frankfurt) since lionel has been racing. it's fair to say these 3 have better resumes. i don't see how he ducks anybody. he does the opposite. he seeks out top athletes to race. he's raced those 3 top-level germans a bunch of times, and does okay. if memory serves in both of lionel's challenge championship wins (2017 and 2018) he beat great fields (kienle got 2nd both times). like him or don't like him, but facts are facts.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Last edited by: Slowman: Oct 15, 21 17:21
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [mkq] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mkq wrote:
TheStroBro wrote:
If you look at my back and fourth with FtStri he's just trying to drag down Lionel's accomplishments and say he's ducked people and not chosen to go to "prestigious" races. There is no way of knowing whether or not Lionel has chosen to duck people and second guessing his decisions based on the blow ups we've seen when we know what the goal is: Get to Kona.

I've been racing Tri for 5 years and following it for 4 and I don't know how Frankfort is meant to be prestigious at all. If it is, great I guess. But it doesn't carry mythology for me considering I'm a "new" fan of triathlon and that the races for me that hold any mythology are Kona and Roth to some extent.

Frankfurt is a huge race in Europe and has been for a long time. It is the European IM Championship and not scheduled for right after Kona like AZ or FL, for example. It isn't a big deal that you didn't know of its status but I'd advise against railing against being corrected on this. It just isn't a great look.

I agree that there are some people who are just jealous and are now stuck in the "Lionel sucks" category. I see no problem with him choosing Copenhagen over Frankfurt. He needed the KQ. I personally get frustrated with the chopping and changing and thus likely never approaching his potential.

Never heard of Frankfort triathlon until your post

But I am a newbie

Only been racing triathlons for 38 years
Quote Reply
Re: Lionel's encore?! [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Slowman wrote:
frankfurt is more prestigious if you're european, especially if you're from germany. especially if you're a young german based racer, and you haven't been around long enough to have seen the arc in the sport. germany does have the truly prestigious race, but it's not frankfurt. IM lost the most prized race outside of Kona, which was IM germany (in roth). that race became challenge roth. IM placed a race in frankfurt because it needed a german race, but you could throw as much prize money as you want at that race and it will never be roth.


There used to be two major races in long distance racing: Hawaii and ... I wish the old Nice (4k/130k/30k) classic would make a comeback. Now it's only a regular Ironman with no particular gravitas (and I'm not talking about Zofingen, as Duathlon has all but just about died as a high performance sport at least).
Quote Reply

Prev Next