I used upstep.com for a set of orthotics that I wear in my everyday shoes. The orthotics are fairly tall, so your shoe is going to fit more snug, but I really like the product. I've used the everyday orthotics everyday for over a year now and they still have their same shape. I expect to get at least 5 years out of these. I use to have a set of orthotics from the podiatrist, and they were 2 pieces. A hard molded shell with a cushion on top. The molded shell was good for 15 years, I'd just need to get the cushion replaced every year. I got those for $400, but that was also 20 years ago.

I think the upstep product works great and I would have no issues recommending them.