Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

New FTP via Zwift race, how valid?
Quote | Reply
I did a 55 minute race last week and wanted to get a good threshold workout so I rode like an utter moron and just kept drilling it every time someone slacked at the front. When the race was over, Zwift handed me a 12 watt increase in FTP. My effort wasn't very well paced at all, so I'm wondering how Zwift makes this call, is it my best 20 minutes? Not a big deal, but mostly curious.
Quote Reply
Re: New FTP via Zwift race, how valid? [jroden] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
If yiu didn't ride a steady effort, I wouldn't take it.
Quote Reply
Re: New FTP via Zwift race, how valid? [Tom_hampton] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
You were highly motivated to ride harder than you normally would, that’s the challenge within a FTP test. I’d take NP for that ride as being pretty close to FTP.
Quote Reply
Re: New FTP via Zwift race, how valid? [turningscrews] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jeepers, that's even higher. Riding less, but harder seems to be helping my fitness. I've been busier with life and just ride an hour a day, mostly inside after cross season and I'm at 320 Watts at age 58, have not seen that in a while
Thanks Zwift.
Quote Reply
Re: New FTP via Zwift race, how valid? [jroden] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jroden wrote:
I did a 55 minute race last week and wanted to get a good threshold workout so I rode like an utter moron and just kept drilling it every time someone slacked at the front. When the race was over, Zwift handed me a 12 watt increase in FTP. My effort wasn't very well paced at all, so I'm wondering how Zwift makes this call, is it my best 20 minutes? Not a big deal, but mostly curious.

I think the biggest question is if that's straight from an actual, dual-sided power meter.
Quote Reply
Re: New FTP via Zwift race, how valid? [aravilare] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
aravilare wrote:
jroden wrote:
I did a 55 minute race last week and wanted to get a good threshold workout so I rode like an utter moron and just kept drilling it every time someone slacked at the front. When the race was over, Zwift handed me a 12 watt increase in FTP. My effort wasn't very well paced at all, so I'm wondering how Zwift makes this call, is it my best 20 minutes? Not a big deal, but mostly curious.

I think the biggest question is if that's straight from an actual, dual-sided power meter.

A powertap on rollers
Quote Reply
Re: New FTP via Zwift race, how valid? [jroden] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jroden wrote:
I did a 55 minute race last week and wanted to get a good threshold workout so I rode like an utter moron and just kept drilling it every time someone slacked at the front. When the race was over, Zwift handed me a 12 watt increase in FTP. My effort wasn't very well paced at all, so I'm wondering how Zwift makes this call, is it my best 20 minutes? Not a big deal, but mostly curious.

I've had some pretty flattering stats after a Zwift race, at first it was great, but now I'm a little skeptical. I did a 40km race this week and I averaged close to my FTP, I've been living on beer and mince pies for the last 2 weeks, so the result was inaccurate unless someone laced my mince pies with EPO. If I ride solo or on a TT bike, average power is accurate, in a group, then it's always unrealistically higher.
Quote Reply
Re: New FTP via Zwift race, how valid? [jroden] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I’d guess it’s valid.

Try reverse engineering it: do a max 20’ at 1.05 x that power.

#######
My Blog
Quote Reply
Re: New FTP via Zwift race, how valid? [jroden] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I have noticed that too. If I ride harder and skip a day or two, on repeat, I get stronger quicker. If I want more endurance then I have to ride more often but less power. I would recommend you try some intervals at your new FTP and see how it feels. You might be physically ready but not mentally ready for that number. Or the opposite. Or you might nail it and then you should accept it.

http://www.sfuelsgolonger.com
Quote Reply
Re: New FTP via Zwift race, how valid? [jroden] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
May or may not be accurate. Zwift just takes 95% of your best 20 minute power. So if that was your first 20 minutes, I would not think that would be accurate. The proper 20 minute test needs a hard couple minutes before the test.

On the other hand, Zwift can really motivate you and maybe you are stronger than you thought, just needed the motivation. I would look at the NP for the entire ride, how close was that to the FTP? What was the average power of the race?

I agree with the other posters that have said you should try some intervals using a higher FTP and see how they go.
Quote Reply
Re: New FTP via Zwift race, how valid? [jroden] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
jroden wrote:
Jeepers, that's even higher. Riding less, but harder seems to be helping my fitness. I've been busier with life and just ride an hour a day, mostly inside after cross season and I'm at 320 Watts at age 58, have not seen that in a while
Thanks Zwift.

Fitness is a tricky term.

FTP and VO2 Max? I'm positive your methods can improve them and that's really useful.

But for the longer stuff like Ironmans you also have to focus on endurance and look at things like sustainable percent of FTP, which for me are more indicative of my goal fitness simply because those races are my goals.

One is no better than the other, but highest FTP doesn't always win the long race. Short one probably though, all else aero-equal.

Too old to go pro but doing it anyway
http://instagram.com/tgarvey4
Quote Reply
Re: New FTP via Zwift race, how valid? [jroden] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I would say to do the Zwift ramp test to validate those numbers but I don't think you can do that on rollers.
Quote Reply
Re: New FTP via Zwift race, how valid? [ksb] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I used the 20 minute protocol in the past, it seed to work fine. I have a tugboat power curve and score worse on the to tests
Quote Reply
Re: New FTP via Zwift race, how valid? [jroden] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What do you mean by valid? Do you mean, does it represent MLSS? I think unfortunately that’s a maybe yes, maybe no.

But what do you want to use it for? If you can look at your power duration curve, you don’t need FTP to figure out power targets for intervals. FTP and “zones” might have been the most useful thing at one point, but nowadays it’s just a datum. Pretty much every training platform nowadays shows you your PDC, or a version of it.

And if you’re curious because you want to see whether you got faster, we’ll, you already know that you did :)
Quote Reply
Re: New FTP via Zwift race, how valid? [devolikewhoa83] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I guess it's the last one. I don't exactly have a scientific training plan I'm just jumping in the races a couple of times a week and going somewhat hard. So I guess good news I'm getting in better shape.
Quote Reply