Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Prev Next
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [Bavarian_Frank] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thank you for that, just picked up 2 pair fo the cheapest Hoka's ever!
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [Runguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Runguy wrote:
Mad Jee wrote:
Might want to check with the ultra running crowd. They seem to take them pretty seriously.

As stated previously in this thread, I have friends who run Ultras and none of them are wearing, or talking, about Hokas. Maybe it's a regional thing, I'm in New England. Seems like they are popular out in Colorado.

Either way, we're talking about a small niche here. Not exactly challenging the waffle sole in terms of a turning point in running shoe history.


You talked about Dan having an agenda but I wonder if you don't?! From opening a thread questioning Hoka and then recommending other brands.

Just asking

No he is just being a guy from New England ( I live in NE too) - always suspicious and very traditional. :)!
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [blueraider_mike] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hoka is definitely starting to take off in NE. Mike, your local run door has a fair number of people in them. Seems like the tri crowd adopted them first before the ultra crowd. Lots of the ultra crew still loving Inov-8, Salomon. But now starting to see crossover from the tri crowd into the regular run market. And even a few of the old ultra guard starting to make the switch.

The next gen line-up that launches 7/1/14...I don't want to call it a game-changer. But the brand is going to become a lot more accessible. They'll have a much wider range to fit people with. Exciting stuff.

----------------------------------
Editor-in-Chief, Slowtwitch.com | Twitter
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [rrheisler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Ok, I've been testing a pair of these out for a little while now.

They are not 'fast' in any stretch as it's quite literally like running on memory foam (or something like that) but they are SUPER cushy and I'd bet running crazy distances in them would feel fantastic.

Most of 2013 has had me hiding from running thanks to a heel that hurts like hell. I got a pair of these Hoka's to try out and they let me run pain free. Mind you I take them off and my heel still hurts so they aren't 'fixing' anything, but they are letting me run.

I have been running on different surfaces road to uneven trail, I thought I'd be rolling my ankle all the time just looking at them and feeling how soft they are. No rolled ankles as of yet. They feel pretty stable.

I'm guessing they are going to break down quicker due to the fact they are as soft as they are.

Bonus: I feel like I could jump off a flight of stairs and get selected for the RedBull Stair jumping championships! BOOM!


Tim
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [Bavarian_Frank] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Bavarian_Frank wrote:
kathy_caribe wrote:
charris19 wrote:
do you folks only run the long runs in the Hokas? Or the short ones, too? I just ordered a pair, but at $160 a pop i don't necessarily want to use them up on a 4 1/2 mile jog around the neighborhood.


right now i'm starting to use them for medium and long but look very longingly at them on the short ones. If I could afford them (under $100 on Ebay) I'd wear them for each and every run.


they are under 100$ at running warehouse ...

OMG thank you!!!

http://harvestmoon6.blogspot.com
https://www.caringbridge.org/visit/katasmit


Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [kathy_caribe] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Just purchased some HOKAs several weeks ago. The Bondi Bs I believe. Got them in a store, so not sure if they are an earlier 2013 model or not. After 3 runs, I have to give them up. The number one problem of me was the large toe box. So on faster runs, my toes got pretty beat up. And I wanted them to work as I thought they would help with high mileage, long brick workouts, etc. Does anyone know if HOKA makes a shoe with a smaller toe box?
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [goblin] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
THis very thread talks about the new models coming out that are supposed to have a better fit, smallter toe box etc. read back two or three pages


goblin wrote:
Just purchased some HOKAs several weeks ago. The Bondi Bs I believe. Got them in a store, so not sure if they are an earlier 2013 model or not. After 3 runs, I have to give them up. The number one problem of me was the large toe box. So on faster runs, my toes got pretty beat up. And I wanted them to work as I thought they would help with high mileage, long brick workouts, etc. Does anyone know if HOKA makes a shoe with a smaller toe box?
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [YO mortaaay] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
YO mortaaay wrote:
THis very thread talks about the new models coming out that are supposed to have a better fit, smallter toe box etc. read back two or three pages


goblin wrote:
Just purchased some HOKAs several weeks ago. The Bondi Bs I believe. Got them in a store, so not sure if they are an earlier 2013 model or not. After 3 runs, I have to give them up. The number one problem of me was the large toe box. So on faster runs, my toes got pretty beat up. And I wanted them to work as I thought they would help with high mileage, long brick workouts, etc. Does anyone know if HOKA makes a shoe with a smaller toe box?

Right, that would be the Bondi 3 due out next month
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [goblin] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
goblin wrote:
Just purchased some HOKAs several weeks ago. The Bondi Bs I believe. Got them in a store, so not sure if they are an earlier 2013 model or not. After 3 runs, I have to give them up. The number one problem of me was the large toe box. So on faster runs, my toes got pretty beat up. And I wanted them to work as I thought they would help with high mileage, long brick workouts, etc. Does anyone know if HOKA makes a shoe with a smaller toe box?

what size? I get a larger size to get a larger toe box as the size that fits me is too narrow. :) I hope they widen their toe box, personally. :)

http://harvestmoon6.blogspot.com
https://www.caringbridge.org/visit/katasmit


Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [Runguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Great, I will check on the Bondi 3 next month. Most of my problem seems to be less about the width of the toe box, but the amount of "room" between the top of my toes, and the top of the shoe. There was a rather large gap, so on fast runs, intervals, etc. my toes ended up getting slammed up and down so much that it caused problems, sore toes, etc. I have been running in Asics 2000 series for years. I guess I need a more tight fit around my toes to be comfortable. Though I have put my current HOKAs for sale on Ebay, I do not want to give up on the HOKA because with the right fit around the toe area, I think they could work for me. Especially with long course training this year.
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [dsmallwood] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
dsmallwood wrote:
how about some widths? a 2E would be nice. that cushioning doesn't help when my forefoot goes numb.

just a thought.

I take a 2e or 4e in just about every shoe I wear but found both the Mafate 2 and Bondi to have plenty of width for me.
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [rrheisler] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
rrheisler wrote:
Hoka is definitely starting to take off in NE. Mike, your local run door has a fair number of people in them. Seems like the tri crowd adopted them first before the ultra crowd. Lots of the ultra crew still loving Inov-8, Salomon. But now starting to see crossover from the tri crowd into the regular run market. And even a few of the old ultra guard starting to make the switch.

The next gen line-up that launches 7/1/14...I don't want to call it a game-changer. But the brand is going to become a lot more accessible. They'll have a much wider range to fit people with. Exciting stuff.

I noticed they all had them on when I was in the store last month. I tried to buy a pair from our favorite store in Portland but they didn't have my size, been waiting for 5 weeks, so, I just ordered today a discounted pair from Running Warehouse to try. My wife (who you know) tried them and didn't like them, but she is never patient. I am gonna try them because all the therapy in the world (even from Dr. Raymond) over the last 3 years hasn't kept me running without pain in a race scenario. So am gonna try them from the perspective, can I get more miles in, can I get my long runs in....I am a desperate 49 year old who still wants to compete. Hope you are enjoying your new life down south.
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [blueraider_mike] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yeah, availability was still an issue later half of the year, particularly for the Bondi in any color besides the relatively hideous unisex blue. Looks like Deckers has really pumped the cash in, so with the Bondi 3, Conquest, and then the 7/1/14 updates everything should have much better availability for stores.

That's a big bummer to hear. I know you've been through a lot. But, to give you some hope: JR (owner of MRC) hadn't run a step in three years due to how bad his knees had gotten. His Stinsons let him run. Period. He's not fast these days, but he doesn't care: he can run.

Things are good! Some fun stuff to announce here in the near future. Still settling in. Still riding outside, which is a big plus.

----------------------------------
Editor-in-Chief, Slowtwitch.com | Twitter
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [kathy_caribe] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I run in a size 9 in the Pearl Izumi Streak IIs, which supposedly run small. So I tried an 8 in the Hokas. Barely enough room in the toe and too narrow. I'm trying a 9 in the Hokas and we'll see.


Chris Harris
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [kathy_caribe] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
kathy_caribe wrote:
goblin wrote:
Just purchased some HOKAs several weeks ago. The Bondi Bs I believe. Got them in a store, so not sure if they are an earlier 2013 model or not. After 3 runs, I have to give them up. The number one problem of me was the large toe box. So on faster runs, my toes got pretty beat up. And I wanted them to work as I thought they would help with high mileage, long brick workouts, etc. Does anyone know if HOKA makes a shoe with a smaller toe box?


what size? I get a larger size to get a larger toe box as the size that fits me is too narrow. :) I hope they widen their toe box, personally. :)

Ha, ha! I'm in the same boat. Bondis are the ONLY Hokas that are comfortable for me BECAUSE of the wider toe box. I wear my running shoes loose and I'm a 4E width in most running shoes. Virtually all the other Hokas have narrower toe boxes than the Bondis. Really bummed about the talk that the Bondi 3s might have a narrower toe box!

------------------
My business-eBodyboarding.com
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
As I've posted in other threads on Hoka, my ankles twist when wearing the Stinson on the trails. In a test run, the Bondi wasn't much better for my ankles.

A shoe with as much cushioning as the Hoka cannot be intrinsically fast. It takes too much time to compress and push off, thereby losing much of the ground reaction force.

Slowman wrote:
"It seems like turning an ankle would be incredibly easy."

that's what i thought. that's what i was afraid of. that right there almost kept me out of this shoe. but, for me, i'm less likely to turn an ankle in this shoe than i was in my adrenalines, which were my shoes in all their iterations for upwards of a decade. i can only tell you that this was not, in practice, a problem.
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [Pedalhead] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
"As I've posted in other threads on Hoka, my ankles twist when wearing the Stinson on the trails. In a test run, the Bondi wasn't much better for my ankles."

then i recommend you run in another shoe. and when in the future you follow the yet-to-be-posted hoka threads repeating your dissatisfaction, i'm still going to recommend you run in another shoe.

"
A shoe with as much cushioning as the Hoka cannot be intrinsically fast. It takes too much time to compress and push off, thereby losing much of the ground reaction force."

nevertheless, it is intrinsically fast. for me. it is the fastest shoe - for me - in my closet, that i own. when another shoe enters my closet that is faster, i shall report that here. and i have other shoes coming, for which i have high hopes. i can explain to you why you are - in my case - wrong, but you sound as if you've made a decision, and do not care to be influenced by facts not currently in your possession.


Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
You recommended that I try the Bondi, which I did and thus posted my experience (N =1) herewith.

Slowman wrote:
"As I've posted in other threads on Hoka, my ankles twist when wearing the Stinson on the trails. In a test run, the Bondi wasn't much better for my ankles."

then i recommend you run in another shoe. and when in the future you follow the yet-to-be-posted hoka threads repeating your dissatisfaction, i'm still going to recommend you run in another shoe.

"
A shoe with as much cushioning as the Hoka cannot be intrinsically fast. It takes too much time to compress and push off, thereby losing much of the ground reaction force."

nevertheless, it is intrinsically fast. for me. it is the fastest shoe - for me - in my closet, that i own. when another shoe enters my closet that is faster, i shall report that here. and i have other shoes coming, for which i have high hopes. i can explain to you why you are - in my case - wrong, but you sound as if you've made a decision, and do not care to be influenced by facts not currently in your possession.
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [Pedalhead] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
"You recommended that I try the Bondi, which I did and thus posted my experience (N =1) herewith."

you're right. but you're extrapolating to n=everybody in your post as regards the ability of the shoe to run fast. i just don't stipulate to your stipulation.


Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [Pedalhead] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hmm...My data shows the Stinsons aren't any faster or slower than my Brooks Ghost 6. What I have found wearing the Hoka's is that they are more comfortable, I can run longer, and I can run more frequently during the week due to the extra cushioning. Sorry they didn't work out for you.
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
True, the first determinant of a shoe's ability to run fast is, of course, the wearer. The second might be how much the shoe improves the wearer's tolerance to the miles of pounding. Example: Nike funded a research project and supplied 2 models of shoes for the runners, high-cushion and low-cushion. The two randomized groups ran against each other, averaging 17+ mi per day for 18 days. Overall finishing time was faster and markers of tissue injury were lower in the high-cushion group.

Slowman wrote:
"You recommended that I try the Bondi, which I did and thus posted my experience (N =1) herewith."

you're right. but you're extrapolating to n=everybody in your post as regards the ability of the shoe to run fast. i just don't stipulate to your stipulation.
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [Slowman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I don't doubt for one second the veracity or truth behind Dan's post. I absolutely believe Hokas are the fastest shoe for him. I don't know if I can say they are faster for me, but they aren't any slower.

That said, I wonder where those are who have referred to anecdotal evidence such as this as "garbage"? Is it just that Hokas are more widely "accepted" by ST doctrine compared to other products?

Chicago Cubs - 2016 WORLD SERIES Champions!!!!

"If ever the time should come, when vain and aspiring men shall possess the highest seats in government, our country will stand in need of its experienced patriots to prevent its ruin." - Samuel Adams
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [matt75] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
matt75 wrote:
Hmm...My data shows the Stinsons aren't any faster or slower than my Brooks Ghost 6. What I have found wearing the Hoka's is that they are more comfortable, I can run longer, and I can run more frequently during the week due to the extra cushioning. Sorry they didn't work out for you.

Same here.

My fastest HIM and IM runs were done in the Bondi B2 this year and I would consider my one 70.3 and two IM's in 2013 to have been B+ efforts. I'm certain my Newtons, Kinvaras, and Brooks PureFlow were technically faster shoes as they're lighter and assumably more responsive but that's doesn't mean jack if training and racing in them beats me up.

Favorite Gear: Dimond | Cadex | Desoto Sport | Hoka One One
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [Pedalhead] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i am no expert, but i would think the length and topography of the race, the shape of the shoe, where the cushion is placed in the shoe, the durometer of the structure or substance providing the cushion, the velocity we're talking about when we talk about the inherent speed of a shoe, all would be factors.

i was a confirmed brooks adrenaline guy. the "1" thru the 13 or 15 or wherever it was when i bowed out in favor of hokas. one of these iterations had an outsole that was soft, and it was kind of like jelly when i landed. it wasn't the cushioning that was the problem. it was the lateral movement. this is what slowed down the return or response or whatever you want to call it. brooks stopped using that outsole material in later iterations or at least it so seemed to me.

but this issue of lateral motion of the foot, whether in the upper or in the outsole substance, this became an issue to which i paid attention after this experience wearing 2 iterations of the adrenaline that were otherwise almost identical. i think we tend to look at shoe function and movement as a 2-dimensional process when really there's a Z axis that literally takes us, as runners, sideways and slows down this interval between foot plant and push off.

Dan Empfield
aka Slowman
Quote Reply
Re: Hoka: Let's Get Real [Runguy] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Right. I train in mine, particularly longer runs or if I'm a bit tired. Newtons to race.

-Robert

"How wonderful it is that nobody need wait a single moment before starting to improve the world." ~Anne Frank
Quote Reply

Prev Next