Another fan of Reilly here! When I started in this sport, it was sort of legendary that you would want to hear Reilly call you across the line in your first (and subsequent) IM. I personally think that speaking on the mic for 18 hours (he starts before the race) is a feat that I could never imagine, and I used to announce surfing/bodyboarding events.
That said, I had the pleasure of racing IMC in '07 for the 25th anniversary year and Steve actually raced so I watched him cross the line late that evening, but really loved his emcee job at the banquets. It was obvious he knew everything about everyone. I had never heard of Steve prior to racing in Canada (only my 3rd year in the sport at the time), but made a point to Google him and read about his storied history in endurance sports and have a great deal of respect for him as well.
As others have said, he's not necessarily better, just different. I hope to do IMC again in the future and would love to have Steve call me across the line there when I do!
------------------
My business-eBodyboarding.com