Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Does this look like the bike of a cheater?
Quote | Reply
Take a look at the image below...


Looks pretty innocent right? Well thatā€™s an ā€œaero e-bikeā€ believe it or not with a 250w motor and a battery thatā€™s good for two hours at full power. The electric assist is only good for 20mph but I guarantee you thereā€™s a workaround. How long until we see these in a transition area? How long until someone uses one to KQ?
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thatā€™s pretty nice looking actually.

I donā€™t think you need full power, just a little assist. 20-30 extra watts in your next Ironman bike leg would mean either a much faster bike leg, much faster run leg or both.


--Chris
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
They already have officials checking bikes with phone apps for ebikes at larger races
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [chriselam] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I thought the same thing. If you look at more images of that bike, it truly is ā€œstealthā€. Top tube bag, couple of bottles, and some clip on aero bars and it would blend in in any transition area. No idea what sort of noise it makes but Iā€™d bet minimal.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [MrTri123] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
MrTri123 wrote:
They already have officials checking bikes with phone apps for ebikes at larger races

Great justification for overnight bike dropoff.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Fin Man might be considering a comeback.

Find out what it is in life that you don't do well, then don't
do that thing.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [MrTri123] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
MrTri123 wrote:
They already have officials checking bikes with phone apps for ebikes at larger races

If the system was powered down I have no idea how theyā€™d find it.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
The Orbea Gain is another bike that looks no different than a traditional road bike. It does worry me that these types of things might be showing up in transition and in Gran Fondos, etc at some point. While 20mph might be a ā€˜limiterā€™ on the flats, it would make climbing easier.

Matt
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GreenPlease wrote:
MrTri123 wrote:
They already have officials checking bikes with phone apps for ebikes at larger races


If the system was powered down I have no idea how theyā€™d find it.

You can use magnetometers to detect magnets and inductive proximity sensors to detect ferrous metal.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Very simple answer: WEIGHT and FRAME. The E-bikes are at least 5-10 lbs heavier than a regular tri-bike (15-19 lbs) so just weighting the bike would be enough but looking at the frame, the top and bottom tubes are way wider since that's where the parts are built in. At least on the couple I've already seen on the road from fellow cyclist so not sure if ALL of them are the same but 3 different brands confirm my hypothesis partially.

P.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
From the side, it looks pretty slick. The rear hub is a dead giveaway however.

I like ebikes because it keeps my spouse in the game to ride together, given her time/commitment is less than mine.
Last edited by: Rocket_racing: Jun 30, 19 15:34
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Sapix] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I wonder How long does it take to weigh 2700 bikes
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
GreenPlease wrote:
MrTri123 wrote:
They already have officials checking bikes with phone apps for ebikes at larger races


If the system was powered down I have no idea how theyā€™d find it.

You can use magnetometers to detect magnets and inductive proximity sensors to detect ferrous metal.

Fair enough but if youā€™re just magnet hunting a transition area will set off a ton of false positives (hell, my bike in race trim has... counting... nine magnets on it).

TBH, while Iā€™d love to see rules officials checking bikes at large races, Iā€™m doubtful they would be effective.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Pun_Times] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Pun_Times wrote:
The Orbea Gain is another bike that looks no different than a traditional road bike. It does worry me that these types of things might be showing up in transition and in Gran Fondos, etc at some point. While 20mph might be a ā€˜limiterā€™ on the flats, it would make climbing easier.

I already figured out how to get it up to ~22mph by changing a single setting in the app :)
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Sapix] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sapix wrote:
Very simple answer: WEIGHT and FRAME. The E-bikes are at least 5-10 lbs heavier than a regular tri-bike (15-19 lbs) so just weighting the bike would be enough but looking at the frame, the top and bottom tubes are way wider since that's where the parts are built in. At least on the couple I've already seen on the road from fellow cyclist so not sure if ALL of them are the same but 3 different brands confirm my hypothesis partially.

P.

I think that was true on the first generation of bikes but look at some of the other pictures of that Bianchi. Fairly svelte. Maybe not a true aero road bike but I guarantee you the downtube of a Synapse is wider and blunter and nobody would bat an eye at one of those.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [MrTri123] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
MrTri123 wrote:
I wonder How long does it take to weigh 2700 bikes

Plus the bike I posted weighs 26lbs. Is that really that far out of the norm? I think not.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Probably not THAT discernable once there's a hydration system, 2 normal full bottles (or even fake-full to put inspectors off the scent) , a tool pack etc etc all strapped to the bike.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Pun_Times] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I donā€™t care what people show up on in a Gran Fondo
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [mickison] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Simple: lifetime ban from all sanctioned triathlons if you use a motor. USAT should just state that now.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Poon] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Agree.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Rocket_racing] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Rocket_racing wrote:
From the side, it looks pretty slick. The rear hub is a dead giveaway however.

I like ebikes because it keeps my spouse in the game to ride together, given her time/commitment is less than mine.

I was going to say that the hub on this one is the give away but does someone make a hub drive disc wheel? Or just use a wheel cover to hide the hub.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
just check the podium finishers or top 10 in each age group or something after the race.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [mickison] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mickison wrote:
I donā€™t care what people show up on in a Gran Fondo

Ok well then, I guess it we shouldn't worry about it since you don't care

Gran Fondo's are not all just big group rides...some races around the US pretty competitive (some also offering prize purses) to the point the people are getting caught doping: https://cyclingtips.com/...new-york-gran-fondo/

Matt
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Pun_Times] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thatā€™s fine. Do it for some that are competitive or allow people to opt out for prizes. I donā€™t want to pay more for the fun gran fondos that I do.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GreenPlease wrote:
I thought the same thing. If you look at more images of that bike, it truly is ā€œstealthā€. Top tube bag, couple of bottles, and some clip on aero bars and it would blend in in any transition area. No idea what sort of noise it makes but Iā€™d bet minimal.

I had this exact bike pass me on a greenway a few weeks ago. I heard the electric whining of the motor before I saw it. It wasn't very loud but it was distinctive and I instantly noticed the large rear hub.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [MrTri123] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
At my last IM in Boulder every bike was photographed which takes at least 90-120 seconds per.bike. Don't see why can't use a pretty basic ML algo to detect these things. If they weigh the bike + run the digital images through ML, they'll know right away which bikes would need to be singled out for closer inspection in T1.

Next races on the schedule: none at the moment
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Rage KG] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Rage KG wrote:
GreenPlease wrote:
I thought the same thing. If you look at more images of that bike, it truly is ā€œstealthā€. Top tube bag, couple of bottles, and some clip on aero bars and it would blend in in any transition area. No idea what sort of noise it makes but Iā€™d bet minimal.

I had this exact bike pass me on a greenway a few weeks ago. I heard the electric whining of the motor before I saw it. It wasn't very loud but it was distinctive and I instantly noticed the large rear hub.

Thatā€™s good to know.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Also. Size of rear hub. and additional spokes on wheel. Charging port on top of BB, plastic cover on bottom of BB for battery service. Two wires on on non-drive side (including an electric wire to hub). There are plenty of tells for those who know bikes.


Last edited by: bloodyshogun: Jun 30, 19 20:24
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [bloodyshogun] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That is so obvious... Not sure why anyone is actually concerned with this.

If someone wants to cheat, they could easily build and hide their own motor on a bike that's actually made for triathlon.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [indianacyclist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Or... they can dope... or cut courses...

Electric bikes are not that concerning, imo.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [bloodyshogun] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Totally agree. Someone having an extra $15k to spend on a P5X or some other decked out super bike probably shaves off more time than a pedal assist motor on an ebike anyway
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [indianacyclist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yep. Totally agree. I'm too busy worrying about me to be concerned about anyone else. Granted I'm so firmly ensconced in the middle of the pack most of the time that I really don't care what those at the pointy end get up to.

Trust me Iā€™m a doctor!
Well, I have a PhD :-)
Last edited by: PhilipShambrook: Jun 30, 19 20:35
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Rocket_racing] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Rocket_racing wrote:
From the side, it looks pretty slick. The rear hub is a dead giveaway however.

I like ebikes because it keeps my spouse in the game to ride together, given her time/commitment is less than mine.

You could just put a normal rear wheel on it and roll out of T1 and stop up the road pretending to have a flat and your mate has the wheel. Swap it on and then do the same near the end of the race.

Or just get wheel covers made for it and make it a disc.

So many ways to cheat. It's only a matter of time until we start seeing cheats at events.

Rhymenocerus wrote:
I think everyone should consult ST before they do anything.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [kiwi.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
kiwi. wrote:
Rocket_racing wrote:
From the side, it looks pretty slick. The rear hub is a dead giveaway however.

I like ebikes because it keeps my spouse in the game to ride together, given her time/commitment is less than mine.

I was going to say that the hub on this one is the give away but does someone make a hub drive disc wheel? Or just use a wheel cover to hide the hub.

The e-road gave it away for me.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [PJC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Mate with a wheel is a DQ for outside assistance right? And if you stop twice plus have a funny looking wheel you're going to be noticed by enough other competitors that there's a high chance you get reported and looked into a bit more closely.

Agree with the comment above that they should simply announce a straight lifetime van for anybody caught with an ebike. If possible, across all bike-related sports and events. Course cutting, drafting and doping are all forms of cheating where you can muddy the waters enough to cast at least some doubt on your guilt and so punishments can't be too extreme (I took a wrong turn without realising, I lost my chip, I momentarily entered the draft zone just as an official showed up, I took some cough medicine without checking the ingredients, etc, etc). It's going to be pretty hard to wriggle out of getting caught with a motor in your bike though.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I brought the wrong bike to the race?
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Schnellinger] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I know plenty of people who have managed to turn up with the wrong bike shoes, or forgotten their helmet, or various other kit mistakes. I don't know anybody dumb enough to actually get as far as checking in the wrong bike at registration! Particularly with the weight difference.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [cartsman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
People show up with the wrong bike all the time and some times it happens to have a motor in it.

https://au.eurosport.com/...o5499239/story.shtml
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [kiwi.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
That case kind of proves my point, they dismissed her excuse and gave her a long enough ban to effectively cause her to immediately retire, based on the evidence from one race. No way that a similar sanction would have been given to a relatively unknown 19 year old who course cut or failed a drug test. The few cases where people have had lifetime or at least very long bans for doping or course cutting are the extreme ones where the athlete is very high profile (Lance) and/or is a habitual repeat offender (Moats). Even Julie Miller only got a 2 year ban (I think?) despite a lot of evidence that she cut the course at a whole heap of races.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [kiwi.] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
kiwi. wrote:
People show up with the wrong bike all the time and some times it happens to have a motor in it.

https://au.eurosport.com/...o5499239/story.shtml

Oh the classic ā€œofficer those arenā€™t my drugs. I donā€™t know where they came fromā€ /pink
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [mickison] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mickison wrote:
kiwi. wrote:
People show up with the wrong bike all the time and some times it happens to have a motor in it.

https://au.eurosport.com/...o5499239/story.shtml


Oh the classic ā€œofficer those arenā€™t my drugs. I donā€™t know where they came fromā€ /pink

When that story first broke, I thought that she might spill the beans on the how, where and who else was involved. Instead, she just accepted her ban and quietly disappeared. I was hoping for a whistleblower.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Durhamskier] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Looks like the bike of a rich person either trying to relive glory days or pretend they can do something they'll never be able to.

Let's be clear, e-bikes have their place...........and even for European touring for a less than fit or capable person.........this ain't it.


Now.........that being said..........check this out.........

I'm doing some Google research on all the people selling road bars and stems that hide the Di2 or mech cables the cleanest. Guess what the first auto-correct result is when I started typing "who sells hidden bike.....".

It isn't cables or stems or nutrition bento results. It's hidden motors.

So, to me, if the algorithm is working for Google........lots more people are searching for who sells bikes with hidden motors than they are searching for stems and handlebars that hide the shift cables. FWIW, wound up getting a great deal on a PD aeria ultimate.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [burnthesheep] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
They help older people too. Was following a 70 year old lady up the col du Glandon and couldnā€™t catch her

She told me at the top ā€˜this keeps her riding
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [mickison] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mickison wrote:
just check the podium finishers or top 10 in each age group or something after the race.

Could be very tricky to do right after the race with all the rolling wave starts. And what do you do if 5 of them turn out to have motors and nr 11-15 are already gone?
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [TriStart] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
TriStart wrote:
mickison wrote:
just check the podium finishers or top 10 in each age group or something after the race.


Could be very tricky to do right after the race with all the rolling wave starts. And what do you do if 5 of them turn out to have motors and nr 11-15 are already gone?

I think you would need people to stick around after they finish. If you don't then no chance at podium. how many people stick around for roll downs? Or they would need to dedicate more resources to inspecting bikes after people drop off their bikes in transition. but 2000-3000 bikes is a lot. Or maybe any body who is wants to be considered for a podium spot has to opt-in. And then that's a much shorter list of people to inspect their bikes while in transition. how many people in each age group would even believe they had a shot at a podium finish in an IM? 30? I have no idea
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [indianacyclist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
indianacyclist wrote:
That is so obvious... Not sure why anyone is actually concerned with this.

If someone wants to cheat, they could easily build and hide their own motor on a bike that's actually made for triathlon.

BUT WHAT ABOUT MY STRAVA SEGMENTS?!

808 > NYC > PDX > YVR
2024 Races: Taupo
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [mickison] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
mickison wrote:
TriStart wrote:
mickison wrote:
just check the podium finishers or top 10 in each age group or something after the race.


Could be very tricky to do right after the race with all the rolling wave starts. And what do you do if 5 of them turn out to have motors and nr 11-15 are already gone?


I think you would need people to stick around after they finish. If you don't then no chance at podium. how many people stick around for roll downs? Or they would need to dedicate more resources to inspecting bikes after people drop off their bikes in transition. but 2000-3000 bikes is a lot. Or maybe any body who is wants to be considered for a podium spot has to opt-in. And then that's a much shorter list of people to inspect their bikes while in transition. how many people in each age group would even believe they had a shot at a podium finish in an IM? 30? I have no idea

I like your idea, Mickison.

In response to TriStart - Normally at WTC races you can't pick up your bike until many of the top finishers are well past done with the whole damn race. That seems like plenty of time to check about 50 bikes and more if necessary.

808 > NYC > PDX > YVR
2024 Races: Taupo
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [indianacyclist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
indianacyclist wrote:
Totally agree. Someone having an extra $15k to spend on a P5X or some other decked out super bike probably shaves off more time than a pedal assist motor on an ebike anyway

top flight tri bike is what, 20-40W better than a old school roadie with clipons?

ebike gives 250W for 2 hours...so >100W over the course of an IM, 200W for HIM, 350W for an olympic...spitballing numbers, but no, a superbike is no where close even when you consider the additional 5-10 pounds for the ebike.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GreenPlease wrote:
I thought the same thing. If you look at more images of that bike, it truly is ā€œstealthā€. Top tube bag, couple of bottles, and some clip on aero bars and it would blend in in any transition area. No idea what sort of noise it makes but Iā€™d bet minimal.

It's a great engineering problem. Design a motor that's (1) small enough to fit in a normal bike, (2) doesn't produce enough heat to be detectable by thermal, (3) doesn't produce enough sound to be detectable aurally, (4) adds a meaningful amount of power, and (5) can be switched on/off inconspicuously.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Not to stir the pot, but I would argue that those kind have already been in transitions, have already been used to KQ or podium grand fondos and such. The amount of disposable income, plus win at all cost mentality, plus the lack of a good and systematic process of checking bikes in events makes me think that, like doping, these are in far more use that one would think.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [rosshm] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I saw an ad for a stealth e-bike that recommend using it to go on group rides and show up all the roadies...
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [PJC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It's only a matter of time before people are caught at events using this type of system.

___________________________________________
http://en.wikipedia.org/...eoesophageal_fistula
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cerebral_palsy
2020 National Masters Champion - M40-44 - 400m IM
Canadian Record Holder 35-39M & 40-44M - 200 m Butterfly (LCM)
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Chemist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Chemist wrote:
The Orbea Gain is another bike that looks no different than a traditional road bike.

Ya, it's pretty stealth (below).

For the group ride dynamic, I think I'd rather have an ebike that looks like an ebike and say "I can't normally stay with you guys, is it okay if I ride my ebike with you?" rather than have someone say "hey, isn't that the Obea Gain?" (it says "Gain" on it).

Or I guess I could just get the Gain but be upfront about it.

Doesn't matter, I have no desire to do either of those.


Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Durhamskier] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Durhamskier wrote:
mickison wrote:
kiwi. wrote:
People show up with the wrong bike all the time and some times it happens to have a motor in it.

https://au.eurosport.com/...o5499239/story.shtml


Oh the classic ā€œofficer those arenā€™t my drugs. I donā€™t know where they came fromā€ /pink


When that story first broke, I thought that she might spill the beans on the how, where and who else was involved. Instead, she just accepted her ban and quietly disappeared. I was hoping for a whistleblower.

Nope, because it's basically a family of sociopaths... the excuse was that it was her old bike she sold to a friend, who then added the motor, and that they grabbed the wrong bike to bring to the pit area for the race... Herself, her father, and brother, along with this friend have been previously arrested for exotic bird theft, among other things, it's really just a bizarre story...

We are seeing more motor checking at races. I got checked at Multisport worlds in Penticton, and they were doing checks in Fyn as well... At pretty much every ITU event that I've been at in the last few years, there's a bike check official checking some of the bikes out for motors... similarly there, they photograph all of the bikes and spots in the Tzone which helps control for the funny stuff... In terms of checking for large AG races, if you do random motor checks, and quick visual checks on every bike (which can include a lift test to check for abnormal weight), you can always refer anything suspcious for the detailed scan... You may not get them all, but you'll get the vast majority of them.

In terms of the Bianchi, I have a friend who has one and loves it (he got it because he's recovering from a cardiac issue, and it allows him to get back out riding with the guys), but you can notice the weight and the sound when it's running...
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Trauma] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Trauma wrote:
), but you can notice the weight and the sound when it's running...


Also, in my experience, something always seems a little "off." Every time I've noticed one in a fast group ride, my first clue was something not looking quite right - then I look for the sign of the motor/battery. In these cases no attempt was being made to hide anything. They do annoy me a little because the guys who rode them are perfectly capable of sitting in with a regular bike, and were just "having fun." One guy ticked me off when he started going for the town sprint. At first I thought, "Oh he's going to moto-pace the leadout...a little sketchy, but OK." Then it was, "No, he's actually going for the line." Sigh.
Last edited by: trail: Jul 16, 19 6:13
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Speaking of stealthy looking road Ebikes, I just spotted this over at CTips.

https://cyclingtips.com/...-price-tag-to-match/

It actually looks half decent for an Ebike, along the lines of the Bianchi, Orbea etc, but this thing apparently can assist you upto 45km/h. All yours for the eye-watering sum of 17,000K for the top tier S-Works. Mind boggling.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [realAB] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
realAB wrote:
It's only a matter of time before people are caught at events using this type of system.

It would be easy to do.

Use the old Bion-X hub motor system - build the rear hub into a race rim and use a wheel cover.

Disguise the battery pack on the down tube with a SpeedFill bottle or similar.

I wouldnā€™t be surprised if it has already been done.

-------------------------------
“Get the most aero and light bike you can get. With the aero advantage you can be saving minutes and with the weight advantage you can be saving seconds. In a race against the clock both matter.“

BMANX
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [Barchettaman] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Alaphilippe did his rest day ride today on an e-bike.

http://www.cyclingnews.com/...ce-rest-day-gallery/
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [HardlyTrying] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
As a massive PR stunt for specialized...
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [trail] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trail wrote:
Trauma wrote:
), but you can notice the weight and the sound when it's running...


Also, in my experience, something always seems a little "off." Every time I've noticed one in a fast group ride, my first clue was something not looking quite right - then I look for the sign of the motor/battery. In these cases no attempt was being made to hide anything. They do annoy me a little because the guys who rode them are perfectly capable of sitting in with a regular bike, and were just "having fun." One guy ticked me off when he started going for the town sprint. At first I thought, "Oh he's going to moto-pace the leadout...a little sketchy, but OK." Then it was, "No, he's actually going for the line." Sigh.

I'm not exactly a connoisseur of group rides, but I'd tell that dude to feck off and never come back.

I'm sorry, but if you're on an e-bike it better be in the C-group.

Even motorsports has classes based on engine/chassis/modifications. It's still cheating, plain and simple.

Is there a concept of "cheating the group ride", well yeah. You didn't do any work.

It's great for people to tour, commute, recover injury or permanent disability. It shouldn't be a means of keeping up with a group you can't.

And yes, that includes trying to invite a spouse or S.O. to the group ride that can't hang with it otherwise.

Would you let a cheater play golf with you? How about they can just throw the ball out of the woods every time it goes in? Can toss it out of the sand too? Free second try on every shot?
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [burnthesheep] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I should clarify, this isn't the super organized hammerfest group rides that he's bringing out the electronic assist bike on, it's more the cafe rides... Just like a race, he wouldn't show up to the dick swinging rides on the e-bike, because I agree, I'd be pissed if someone is effectively motorpacing a break clear of the peloton (now if they want to tow me back into the peloton when my fat ass gets dropped, I'd be less mad...)... In terms of the cafe rides, it doesn't bother me at all, trying to start to reintroduce riding back into his routine, and getting a chance to hang out with the regular crew again, given that it's a relatively easy ride, I have no issue if he wants to use the assistance...

As for the golf point, I've played with plenty of cheaters, not flagrant like throwing the balls out of the woods, but I've noticed scorecards where a few strokes tend to vanish, with some degree of regularity (I only get pissed, if there are bets on the line...)...
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [indianacyclist] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
indianacyclist wrote:
As a massive PR stunt for specialized...

And a good one. Having a TdF team give it a stamp of legitimacy is good publicity.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [burnthesheep] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Got it. You are a very fun guy to hang around.

Do motorcycle Sunday rides ban bikes based on CC ("don't you dare bring a a bike with 700cc to our 500cc bike group cruising over the country side. This road is for 500cc bikes only. Cheater!"). Man, there are as many jerks riding motorbikes as there are dopers in cycling.

Yes, I actually play golf with my family, even though they are not good. I don't care if they want to take additional swings. We laugh over a drink, poke fun at each other. I call it Sunday afternoon, and it's a pretty fun time.

E-bikes are great for people to come together and enjoy the hobby together even at various fitness levels. I won't tell someone to "f off" over a Sunday ride, unless they are compromising the safety of the group. I don't even mind it if people bring a TT bike to the group (as long as they stay on bullhorns when they are in the back). Such cheaters for bringing TT bikes to B rides. When they are up front, they aren't even working that hard, or providing much of a draft zone. Should really tell them to ride by themselves. Cheater!

I propose a separate type of weekend activity (let's call it cruise on wheels), and have a different cruises system based on speed, so groups can stay together, won't drop anyone, and focus as much on camaraderie as fitness, but not competition. SOs are welcome, SOs riding e-bikes are welcome. SOs riding e-bikes with delicious snacks and drinks in tow are even more welcome.

burnthesheep wrote:


I'm sorry, but if you're on an e-bike it better be in the C-group.

Even motorsports has classes based on engine/chassis/modifications. It's still cheating, plain and simple.

And yes, that includes trying to invite a spouse or S.O. to the group ride that can't hang with it otherwise.

Would you let a cheater play golf with you? How about they can just throw the ball out of the woods every time it goes in? Can toss it out of the sand too? Free second try on every shot?


Last edited by: bloodyshogun: Jul 16, 19 15:03
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [HardlyTrying] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Kind of like putting pro triathletes on new TT bikes with disc brakes.

Absolutely 0 reason for them to be riding them when half the courses are pancake flat...but they gotta sell all these AG folks on something new
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [burnthesheep] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
So me buying my girlfriend an ebike so she can ride with me is now the same as cheating at golf? You realize most people do this for fun, right? Group rides aren't races...
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [bloodyshogun] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Sounds like a way more fun, and honestly probably more productive, group ride than the ones most people on here do. I'd be very down for that, and I could probably convince my girlfriend to make cookies too :P
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Relax- electric motors have a very specific electro magnetic signature, even when off. The gauges for this are readily available and already in use. I am pretty sure here is also a life time ban for this in place- even for just checking it into transition.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [imswimmer328] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It would be awesome way to convince your girlfriend to come on a European cycling holliday... I see Deceuninck-Quickstep were marketing the Specialized version on the TDF rest day yesterday... http://www.cyclingnews.com/news/deceuninck-quickstep-ride-electric-road-bikes-on-tour-de-france-rest-day-gallery/
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [imswimmer328] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
imswimmer328 wrote:
So me buying my girlfriend an ebike so she can ride with me is now the same as cheating at golf? You realize most people do this for fun, right? Group rides aren't races...
That's not at all what he said, but.. cherry pick. It's a common theme in the good ol' USA these days.

Group rides do generally have a goal, level, or purpose. Your Sunday brunch latte ride? Sure.. e-bike for the girlfriends who can't keep up. 1-2-3 group training ride.. gtfo.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [bloodyshogun] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
bloodyshogun wrote:
Got it. You are a very fun guy to hang around.

Do motorcycle Sunday rides ban bikes based on CC ("don't you dare bring a a bike with 700cc to our 500cc bike group cruising over the country side. This road is for 500cc bikes only. Cheater!"). Man, there are as many jerks riding motorbikes as there are dopers in cycling.

Yes, I actually play golf with my family, even though they are not good. I don't care if they want to take additional swings. We laugh over a drink, poke fun at each other. I call it Sunday afternoon, and it's a pretty fun time.

E-bikes are great for people to come together and enjoy the hobby together even at various fitness levels. I won't tell someone to "f off" over a Sunday ride, unless they are compromising the safety of the group. I don't even mind it if people bring a TT bike to the group (as long as they stay on bullhorns when they are in the back). Such cheaters for bringing TT bikes to B rides. When they are up front, they aren't even working that hard, or providing much of a draft zone. Should really tell them to ride by themselves. Cheater!

I propose a separate type of weekend activity (let's call it cruise on wheels), and have a different cruises system based on speed, so groups can stay together, won't drop anyone, and focus as much on camaraderie as fitness, but not competition. SOs are welcome, SOs riding e-bikes are welcome. SOs riding e-bikes with delicious snacks and drinks in tow are even more welcome.

imswimmer328 wrote:
So me buying my girlfriend an ebike so she can ride with me is now the same as cheating at golf? You realize most people do this for fun, right? Group rides aren't races...

Don't take what I said and twist it with hyperbole. I said in the group rides. "it better be in the C-group". There's nothing wrong with riding with another person or people who do want to ride as friends.

I'm not talking about a couple out for a weekend ride together, nor even a group of 3 to 4 folks on a ride. I'm talking about your bigger A/B/C organized local group rides.

There's an A/B/C not just due to riding experience, but physical ability. If you want to ride with Billy Bob and Sussie on your e-bike, invite them out for a Sunday morning ride together. But if Billy Bob and Sussie are in the A-group ride that day, don't invite yourself along on your e-bike.

There's no A/B/C on a social friend's ride. It's whoever is invited with whatever they've got.

When there is an A/B/C, that should be respected within reason.

Also, my point about motorsports was about motorsports. You took the hyperbole up a notch again by talking about Sunday moto rides. What about a Sunday moto ride is "motorsports".

There's also the concept of having a cohesive group of similar physical ability in golf. You can have a Sunday family or friends hack fest and do whatever you want for fun. Or, you can choose to have a foursome among players of a similar ability for a round. If I chose to play a round in a foursome with some single-digit handicappers, we'll still have a drink and have fun.......but you better not be cheating in the foursome of single digit handicappers. If I chose to play with the single digit golfers and a duffer shows up and cheats the whole time to be able to hang, people are going to be annoyed.

You can have both groups. But trying to call someone a boring crappy person because within certain groups they DO want the rules enforced is a bit much. That's YOU trying to inject your idea of your leisure ride or leisure golf round into what other people do.

I'm not telling you to ban e-bikes or freebie shots from golf within your fun groups. I'm telling you that the "A group" and the "single digit handicap" outting demand at least a modicum of respect for norms and rules.

That does NOT make someone "not fun".
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [burnthesheep] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Apologies. I have never done group rides, I only cruise (large cruises where a few dozen people show up, where strangers become friends because of common interest). Some times, we end up having a few beers after the cruises at the local parking lot.

I am talking about large group cruises. In my world, only A+ cruises are competitive. A/B/C cruises are social cruises. Most A and B cruisers are still no-drop social one. We wait for everyone and anyone who shows up. For B groups, we have leaders, sweepers, and welcome SOs if that means more people can participate. If you show up to an A group but can only ride at B pace. We'll stay with you for the ride (might split in two groups) and ask you to join another ride next time. If said rider has an e-bike and can actually maintain A speed with an electric motor when gassed, that would actually help with the group maintaining its pace. A rider is far more likely to stay if his/her SO can participate. A cyclist is a friend.

In my opinion, the presence of an e-bike does not impact my riding experience or training effect. I welcome the conversation. If they cheese for a sprint, we either laugh at them or ignore them. If they want to drop the group with a motor, then they are on their own. There's a time to be competitive and that's at the local crit.

And you are the one comparing A/B/C rides to motorsport, and stating motorsport has strict rules on classes as a parallel to group rides. I was responding to your analogy. I understand your point. Sorry, I do not know the meaning of group rides.

FYI, the cruises I participate in go by the definition of: A+ is 23/24+, A is 20-23/24, B is 18-22, C is < 18 but usually end up going ~14. Of course assuming no hills. Your definition might vary. B rides are not fast... and most definitely not competitive.

burnthesheep wrote:

There's no A/B/C on a social friend's ride. It's whoever is invited with whatever they've got.

When there is an A/B/C, that should be respected within reason.
Last edited by: bloodyshogun: Jul 17, 19 9:34
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [burnthesheep] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
and that's YOU (ALL CAPS, am I shouting?) trying to inject your idea of competitiveness in to what other people do. Sorry, I have never done group rides. I'll show myself out (rather not get told to F off and never come back). Let each tribe decide their own rules. We belong in different tribes.

burnthesheep wrote:
That's YOU trying to inject your idea of your leisure ride or leisure golf round into what other people do.


Comparing a e-bike rider (and confirming this includes bring a SO) to cheaters who don't follow motorsports regulations, to cheaters in golf (I originally assumed you meant golf tournaments, but I think everygame is a tournament for you).

Do you get paired up with strangers a lot in golf? Do you get paired up with strangers and actually care about their score (vs. just ignore them if they are not your type of people)? What if you got paired up with a total beginner (busy day at club)? What if you get paired up with a sandbagger?


burnthesheep wrote:

I'm telling you that the "A group" and the "single digit handicap" outting demand at least a modicum of respect for norms and rules. That does NOT make someone "not fun"./quote]
Last edited by: bloodyshogun: Jul 17, 19 9:32
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [bloodyshogun] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'll state for the record that I think e-bikes are awesome for many reason. I am very pro e-bike.


Regarding mixing e-bikes and regular bikes on a group ride is a matter of the group and the riders involved. For my personal groups, I probably wouldn't want someone on an e-bike joining. I used to race, but no longer do. To me, the point of the fast, drop-eligible group rides I typically do is challenging yourself and your friends to see how much pain each of you can tolerate. Red-zoning yourself to come around for a town line sprint at 38 MPH, trying to drop everyone on a punchy climb, attacking when everyone is suffering. To me, this race-like physical challenge is actually what I enjoy most about group rides. I love it when someone keeps attacking the rest of us in the group and putting us in the hurt locker, it gets everyone fitter, breaks plateaus and resets what you think you're capable of. I get it that this type of group riding could be seen as overly "competitive" and off--putting to some. To me, it's not about putting other riders down, quite the opposite. It's about building group camaraderie and making each other stronger. I find this strengthens the respect I have with the people I ride with.

Obviously, introducing a mechanism that adds 250+ watts to a rider's output changes a lot of this. Maybe less fit riders would be able to ride with more fit riders. Maybe it could become almost like a motor-pacing ride and be fun in that way. It changes things. Inevitably, you lose some of the camaraderie of working as a group to make it hard. Anyone seeking to join a group ride on an e-bike should ensure they understand the etiquette of the group in question prior to joining. I'm sure it would be just fine for the majority of groups.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [hiro11] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I agree. In my area at least, there are far fewer drop eligible rides, when compared to non-drop rides.

In my area, attacks that will split the group are also generally reserved for A+ rides. A+ rides are also usually separate into sprints vs. paceline rides. A+ rides follow a complete different set of rules than others.

Some A rides are paceline rides, but almost no B rides are paceline rides.

I won't welcome e-bikes in A+ rides, but A/B/C rides are very different animals.
Last edited by: bloodyshogun: Jul 17, 19 10:00
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [bloodyshogun] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
How much weight does this add vs. a similarly equipped standard bike? And I assume obviously there is an on/off switch. I'm just thinking like in cases when riding in traffic, maybe uphill, against wind,undernourished and you just want to get out of an uncomfortable situation sooner than later, this would be great peace of mind and safety.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [HardlyTrying] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
HardlyTrying wrote:
Alaphilippe did his rest day ride today on an e-bike.


http://www.cyclingnews.com/...ce-rest-day-gallery/


This ad popped up on my Facebook today:

https://www.facebook.com/...h/?v=720612835035097







Last edited by: HardlyTrying: Jul 17, 19 13:40
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [dmagic17] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
These bikes are around 25 pounds and up. Also, rear hub is heavy (rotational mass, not at the rims, but still rotational mass).
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [HardlyTrying] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Right! Nothing like some ancient old fart roaring down the road on an electric motorcycle with only one hand on the handlebars and no helmet. Makes me want to run right out and buy one.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
GreenPlease wrote:
Take a look at the image below...

Looks pretty innocent right? Well thatā€™s an ā€œaero e-bikeā€ believe it or not with a 250w motor and a battery thatā€™s good for two hours at full power. The electric assist is only good for 20mph but I guarantee you thereā€™s a workaround. How long until we see these in a transition area? How long until someone uses one to KQ?

That's how I got my KQ. Didn't need to ride aero or shave my legs.

---------------------------------------------------------------

https://connect.garmin.com/modern/profile/domingjm
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [trimule] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
trimule wrote:
Right! Nothing like some ancient old fart roaring down the road on an electric motorcycle with only one hand on the handlebars and no helmet. Makes me want to run right out and buy one.

You may not be the target demographic for a $9,000 electric motorcycle.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [GreenPlease] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I want to know what their bikes looked like:
https://www.cyclingweekly.com/...hecked-motors-431070

They were stealth enough to get through two rounds of the race series before suspicion was escalated to a point of trying to enforce checks. At the same time they weren't stealth enough to avoid serious attention.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [HardlyTrying] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Glad we cleared some of that up. I should also clarify, the A groups around here are 50/50 on whether it is a regimented controlled paceline or a hammer and regroup ride. We don't call rides "A+" or "hammer" or "world's". It's just the nature of the A group for a few of the rides. It's still the "A". And on those, an extra 250w and someone with even a normal level of ego it just won't work out so well.
Quote Reply
Re: Does this look like the bike of a cheater? [HardlyTrying] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
HardlyTrying wrote:
Chemist wrote:
The Orbea Gain is another bike that looks no different than a traditional road bike.


Ya, it's pretty stealth (below).

For the group ride dynamic, I think I'd rather have an ebike that looks like an ebike and say "I can't normally stay with you guys, is it okay if I ride my ebike with you?" rather than have someone say "hey, isn't that the Obea Gain?" (it says "Gain" on it).

Or I guess I could just get the Gain but be upfront about it.

Doesn't matter, I have no desire to do either of those.



Went into a new bike shop today and noticed they were selling Orbeas. Trying to find an Orbea dealer around here has been painful. And...what did the mechanic have on the stand? Two Orbea Gains that he was building up...apparently these things sell like hot cakes.

Washed up footy player turned Triathlete.
Quote Reply