cortez wrote:
1.He's been found guilty by a court
2.He was seen at the lab
3.Soon after tested positive for high hgb
4.He is not contesting the ban
I'm glad you are not a detective. What else would you like to be able to form an opinion?
I'm an argumentative SOB at the best of times so......... :-)
1. I accept your point one. I did misunderstand that the ban covered tri also. Although in this case, having his not guilty decision overturned, in the way it has been, does raise suspicions of its own.
2. This is circumstantial evidence IMHO. I've been seen at strip clubs, but that doesn't mean I am guilty of cheating on my wife.
3. High heamocrit isn't proof of doping, it was a "health test" so riders wouldn't risk their lives trying to pump red glue around their bodies.
4. He may be innocent and simply not rich enough to contest the ban, and thinks he can come back in two years.
What would I like to see as evidence to form an opinion?
1. a copy of a receipt from the clinic saying, say, 2 bags of blood or whatever. Or at least confirmation that such a receipt exists.
2. a clear admission of guilt from the athlete.
Stuff like that.
Athletes and triathletes in particular, rely on sponsorship for much of their income. Their marketability relies on A) their performances, and B) their reputation. Given this, I think it's doubly important to get evidence, as in proper court appropriate evidence, collected PRIOR to making an accusation, because even an accusation can ruin an athletes career. Does an athlete deserve a ruined career for cheating, you bet. But do they deserve a tattered career because of an accusation from a bitter convicted cheating competitor? I don't believe so.
Burden of proof is important, and I prefer to err on the side of innocence until proven guilty. (yes, I misunderstood the amount of evidence against him, last weem, but thanks to further evidence from you and others, I now beleive he is guilty and should be punished, but not because he was "seen at a clinic". That would be hearsay, not actual evidence.
TriDork
"Happiness is a myth. All you can hope for is to get laid once in a while, drunk once in a while and to eat chocolate every day"