Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

IM and Weight Gain
Quote | Reply
Hello All - I am looking for a little advice/perspective on training and weight gain. I started training for my first Ironman 9 weeks ago and have gained 3 pounds already. I don't feel like I am eating any more than normal. In fact, I have been better about getting nutrients and cutting out junk. While my workouts have increased, they are not overly extensive yet (I was training consistently before the IM program stared). I have added light weightlifting but it is pretty minimal & only 2 times a week. I am 5'7 and and weighed 137 consistently for the past year but am now up to 140. This is particularly unnerving because I struggled with my weight for much of my adolescence. I lost about 70 pounds between the ages of 20 and 25 and have maintained a healthy weight for the past 8 years. Has anyone experience this? Any thoughts on what I should do? I did not expect to lose weight while training for the IM but I also did not expect to gain.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yep, I'm with you. I gained 6 training for my first, and have yet to lose it. And it's not all muscle, some is fat. My %age went up about a point. Some is muscle, of course, but not all of it.

I think it's the woman-curse. Our bodies saying "Oh shit, what's she going to do to us tomorrow? I better hold on to some more fat for that baby" - you know, the one our brains know we're not having any time soon.

I think it'll stabilize, just be careful to not use the training as an excuse to eat crap (like me and my cadbury eggs) and it will likely put you at whatever a healthy race weight is for you.

Good luck with your first IM!

rachel
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I also gained weight training for IM's and have not lost it. This will be my 9th year so I don't think I'm going to lose it. I tried to lose it once and I got sick. So now I just try to eat healthy and I haven't worried about my weight in years.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I had a comment over the weekend from Paulo--he said it was interesting that training for IM races for 8 years and I lost some weight (but have stabilized in the past couple of years), but once I started bike racing this winter, I've leaned out. The scales aren't different, actually they are up about 5-8 pounds, but I'm leaner. I'm not eating differently, in fact, probably eating more crap in the past month due to stress.

clm

clm
Nashville, TN
https://twitter.com/ironclm | http://ironclm.typepad.com
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I believe that one adaptation to endurance exercise is the body learning to store more glycogen (and then another adaption is glycogen sparing: burning a higher % of fat than sugar). When you store carbohydrate, you store water with it, and that water weighs something... this may account for some of your weight gain.

Perspective: focus on performance, not weight ;-)

maybe she's born with it, maybe it's chlorine
If you're injured and need some sympathy, PM me and I'm very happy to write back.
disclaimer: PhD not MD
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I am almost 5 lbs heavier than when I just did running (was 109, am 113) . I don't really care; I was scrawny then anyway. But yeah, I think tri training, and IM training in particular, demands you to be fastitidous about fueling and recovery. At 50 miles a week of running...I dunno, it just wasn't possible to refuel all that. Oh also, swimming makes you hungry.

I don't worry about weight, but I wouldn't mind approaching my next starting line somewhere in between "need to shop in the kids dept" and "bloop!" bulging out of my swimsuit. I am not going to sacrifice fuel or recovery though. If I could cut down to one helping of chocolate a day that would probably do it.

Hmm..137 to 140 is not a huge jump....maybe it will stay there and you will get tighter?
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i never even bother with the scale, except after surgery this year, when i had a tangible amount of fat to lose. too much variance and emotion built up in a number, that changes daily!

go by how your clothes fit. i find that training will put weight on in the right places, and take it off in the wrong parts.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [sto] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Oif - I alway gain wait whenever I pick up my training volume. I have a hard time balancing the number of calories to take in to account for the extra training without taking in too many. I have to be super careful as I put on weight really easily and can gain 5 lbs in a week and it will take 2 months to get it off. I feel it in my clothes too, not just on the scale. I envy the people who can self monitor their food and not gain weight. I track everything I eat. I've come to realize this after many years of struggling and just accept it.

I've also had my coach, a nutritionist and a personal trainer talk about increased blood volume and water weight from the increase in training. While I agree this happens after a good session I still have perminant gain. Really frustrating because I want to get down to 125 for IM CdA and this morning, after some overeating Friday and Saturday, I went up to 132 from 129.4. I might not be able to shake it either.

I suggest tracking your food to see if you are overeating. So easy to do. I use www.calorieking.com. I've been using it for 3 years and they have pretty much anything you can think of This should help you see if you are adding more calories than you thought you were.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Jen

"In order to keep a true perspective on one's importance, everyone should have a dog that worships him and a cat that will ignore him." - Dereke Bruce
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [ironclm] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I also gained weight when doing just long and slow training for IMs, did 5 and was pretty big. It was only this year that I started working on speed and I saw the same thing, Im the same weight, but everyone asks how much I have lost. My face is thinner and clothes are loser.
Are you doing any harder more intense workouts? this worked for me. And also don't fall into the overeating on long run/bike days.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I gain weight during training as well. Part of it is muscle from swimming because my back tends to get huge and my upper body muscles are much bigger when my swimming volume increases. The rest is just my body holding onto whatever it can. My doctor made me cut back my training volume quite drastically when we were trying to get pregnant and I ate about the same amount and worked out much less and lost weight. I know some of that was muscle loss but my clothes were looser and I looked thinner. The female body does weird things, and especially mine. I'm convinced that the 10 years I spent as a gymnast growing up still has my body confused as to what's going on.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [snotrocket] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks All for your advice & experience. It helps to know that this is somewhat common. I have really loved the training so far & don't want to feel bad about it just because of weight gain. My clothes seem to be fitting the same as always. I would like to stop gaining, however. I have been doing interval training - which is something new for me. The gain may be from building muscle in my upper body, which has always been weak.

It seems all the nutritionists think that women need to eat more just before and after their workouts - so I am going to try that. It is difficult to get much down at 5:30 a.m. - especially protein. What do you all eat before early morning workouts?
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Here's another one who gained weight during IM training. In February I was 117 pounds and weighed in at CdA at 130. In between I saw a nutritionist and got my thyroid hormones checked because I couldn't believe that I could train that much and eat that little and still gain. This year I'm still pretty heavy (for me) but my clothes are loose. I've definitely leaned out and gained a serious amount of muscle mass. I've given up on counting calories, but have been slowly making changes to my diet (no more peanut butter!) in an attempt to lose some body fat.

:-)

Jodi
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Add me to the list too. I gain weight really easily training for IM. Actually, i just look bloated. Very little muscle definition (for me) and an extra 5-7 lbs.

The shorter, faster stuff is what makes me lean. IM training just makes me feel BLAH!
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
My first breakfast is usually 2 hard boiled eggs and a breakfast bar. I'm eating fiber one bars. Or sometimes I will have oatmeal instead. I have a big appetite and wake up hungry. Right after my first workout I eat a big breakfast usually an eggbeater/veggie omelet and fruit. I usually have a small break before my next workout and eat a bowl of cereal right before.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It is really hard to eat before the pre dawn workouts. I can cram in a few kiwis or bananas on a good day. Or I buy fruit already cut up so I can eat a few chunks of it. I do try to be more fastidious with the post workout fueling and making sure there is protein included.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [dyl] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
>>Are you doing any harder more intense workouts?<<

Actually, that's about all I'm doing. The track training is high intensity and I'm lifting a lot heavier than before. I'm concentrating on the sprints at the velodrome and we are talking events that take 15 seconds to less than 5 minutes. I'm still swimming and need to get back to running and will do some longer bike rides, but now longer means 3-4 hours instead of 6-7 hours.

clm

clm
Nashville, TN
https://twitter.com/ironclm | http://ironclm.typepad.com
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [ironclm] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Add me to the weight gain list too
I did an IM in Sept of 2006
gained about 5 lbs, cannot get it off
I have had blood work done as well

UGH!

http://www.trainerbecky.com
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [trichic] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I wonder if boys have this problem too.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Jen

"In order to keep a true perspective on one's importance, everyone should have a dog that worships him and a cat that will ignore him." - Dereke Bruce
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [Jodi] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
No more peanut butter? How do you get yourself out of the bed in the morning?
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Been there, done that, still trying to lose it all. Mine was that I didn't realize how many calories I was getting in... working on using my Infinit (which was PERFECT for racing) during some workouts, more shot blox, etc, etc.

This year I am going to be more vigilant about it and actually keep track of the calories I train with. That was a BIG thing for me. Plus all my friends who knew I was training for an IM and my hubby all thought I should be taking in more food. I was about 122 racing my 1/2 IM in May, ended up being about 128 at my IM in September, and actually got up to about 135 before I got it under control. I'm down to about 125 now. I know I gained muscle, but I don't know how much. So I'm trying to lose a couple pounds, but am trying to be smart and watch myself so as to not lose strength.

I also turned 30 this year. What worked to drop 5 lbs 2 years ago AIN'T WORKIN!



Tiger for Life -- War Eagle!

Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I also gain weight while training for an IM, but I find in the 5 weeks prior to the race, the weight begins to fall off. Of course, the weight loss is short-lived and I am back to something in between within a couple of weeks post-IM.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Interesting thread with interesting answers. I'm finding myself in the same situation as well.

I did my first IM in 2004. I lost about 5 lbs. from my starting weight with that one -- I got pretty lean for me -- I was at about 16% BF. I then completed three more over the next 2.5 years and was training for a fifth when I ended up with a stress fracture. However, over that time I gained about 15 lbs. I'm not sure if it was my age (42 now), my screwed up metabolism with so much distance training in a relatively short time (have been on various doses of synthroid for 15 years), the fact that I was eating more to fuel my training (which of course leads to excuses to eat chocolate), or a combination, but I'm having a hard time dropping the weight. I'm not distance training anymore, so hopefully things will stabilize. I'm still at a healthy BF, but it's just a little higher than I like at about 23%.

I do find that the day or two after a long ride or run, my muscles tend to hold on to excess fluid -- I believe tigerchik already mentioned this. Do you think this might be your case?

I woudn't worry about it, though. 3 lbs. isn't that much, and is likely due to normal fluctations and fluid retention. Just keep eating healthily for your training level and you'll be at a good weight for you.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [jenhs] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
This happens to me as well. I'm not doing any tris this year...hoping to become a better runner. I'm running about 80-90 mpw right now and my weight has slowly creeped upwards (same thing happens when IM training as well). I noticed my quads look a bit thicker so I guess that's good.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [matti58] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
No more peanut butter? How do you get yourself out of the bed in the morning?

Oatmeal! And lots and lots of coffee...

;-)

Jodi

Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Add me to the list.

I was a marathon runner for years before turning to triathlons. I'm 5'7 and my running weight is 135, give or take a few pounds. Since starting swimming and adding in a lot more upper body weights, I added 10 lbs. for IM Louisville last year, and this winter I've added more weight. I'm around 153 currently. I expect to be back around 145 for IM AZ (Nov.)

My shape has changed the most. I used to joke I had the build of a T-rex - tiny upper body and big legs, and now for the first time in my life, I'm the same size on the top as the bottom. Sometimes it freaks me out, but at the same time, having shoulder muscles, triceps and lats is really cool too!

I'm also way faster than I was when I was solely a runner, so despite the weight, the muscle seems to be working for me.

I try not to worry about it too much, but it's hard. My husband is the exact opposite. He drops weight like crazy during IM training and gets really, really thin.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [KT-tri] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Interesting post that I've been following for a few days as I too gained about 5-7 lbs training for my IM last year and can't do a damn thing to get it to come off despite the fact that my training (and eating) have been curtailed - though still am working out 10-14 hrs/week.

Anyway, I had a doc appt today with an endocrinologist to whom I complained about my weight and my inability to get it to come off. She suggested I try Alli and said she's had moderate success with patients who have tried it. She said that for someone like me who was working out a lot and eating pretty well (wicked sugar tooth - but when taken into consideration with the general american public I eat INCREDIBLY well) sometimes Alli worked to "jump start" the system and she's seen people like me lose that 5-7lbs that just won't seem to come off despite doing everything else right.

I'll admit that I've always been very skeptical of weightloss drugs but she's a Harvard MD, Brigham and Women's residency - so a really smart doc and she does understand what being an athlete is all about. So I bought some today and am going to give it a whirl in addition to maintaining a healthy lifestyle. I'm keeping my fingers crossed cause as someone with no thyroid there's not a whole lot I can do to increase my metabolism. As always - "consult your doctor before beginning any new exercise or diet routine."


http://smallfoodbiz.com
</blatent self-marketing>
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [lilpups] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Make sure you read up on the side effects of Alli. You may want to start the drug on a day when you don't have to leave the house.
http://community.myalli.com/forums/t/651.aspx
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [squesen] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Come on, who doesn't like a little anal leakage every once in awhile????

;-)

Jodi
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [squesen] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Oh yeah, I just read through everything and it's a tad frightening! Though my doc said that those side effects apparently only really happen if you exceed 30g of fat per meal and I think it's pretty safe to say I'm not eating 90g of fat per day. But yeah, if there are side effects I'll be thankful I work from home! :) On the plus side, the little "healthy eating" book that came with my starter kit gave me a bunch of new ideas for healthy lunches which is great as I'm currently eating the same thing day in and day out for lunch and it's getting a little boring.

I'm still somewhat skeptical given that I'm a good 40lbs under the weight guidelines for Alli for my height but I'm just going to trust my doctor on this one.


http://smallfoodbiz.com
</blatent self-marketing>
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [lilpups] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Let me know how it goes. I might try it for 5 lbs that I've gained and can't seem to drop. And no, it isn't muscle. My pants are tight :-(

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Jen

"In order to keep a true perspective on one's importance, everyone should have a dog that worships him and a cat that will ignore him." - Dereke Bruce
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [Jodi] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Jodi, I had a bad experience with peanut butter a couple weeks ago and now I can't touch it... I got some of the natural stuff and it was so oily and icky, ugggh.

maybe she's born with it, maybe it's chlorine
If you're injured and need some sympathy, PM me and I'm very happy to write back.
disclaimer: PhD not MD
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
i lost 6-8 pounds promptly after stopping the IM training. it was great!

now if i could get a little motivation and quit eating ice cream i might get somewhere.

sorry to hear you're bumming about the weight gain. it's crazy, ain't it? all that output...
IM training made me hungry like a mad person. just crazy for food, and it never seemed like it was enough. also i think all of the sports drink made me "swollen". very weird.

i have no advice, but i can tell you that it happened to me! you are not alone by any means, but i admit to being a little surprised at how many womens go through this! even petite womens!
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [kittycat] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Thanks again for the feedback – this is my first ST post and it has been really helpful. After learning that this happens to so many women, I have decided not to stress about it. I am just going to keep up with the training & try to eat the best I can.

Isn’t it sad when you eat a healthier diet than most people you know, and still feel bad about a little chocolate or peanut butter here and there?

Someone told me yesterday that you know you are at a good race weight when your friends wonder if you are sick. That is not my goal & I am sure I will never look underweight. I just want to feel good on race day – besides, I could never live without peanut butter – it is just not worth it.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
My one time Ironman experience: I lost weight, was anemic, recovered poorly, and had a hard time eating properly. After workouts I would practically binge eat and ate too much sugary foods (chocolate chip cookies). I should have gained weight with what I was eating but I didn't. I also had terrible GI problems that had cropped up with a vengeance on the run.

If I do it again, I will consult a nutritionist. Losing weight isn't all it's cracked up to be so I wouldn't worry about a few pounds unless you're a female pro or trying to win your division at your IM.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [Jodi] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Right on. We should embrace it.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [lilpups] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
how is it going with the alli?
after reading your post I was tempted to try it, is was the endocrinlogist who recommended it? can I ask how much you weigh? curious. If you dont want to respond I understand but we dont 'know' you here.
I will tell the truth,I am 142 which is great after doing this for so long at 155, but the last year I have really plateaued, and no I dont want to accept that this is the weight my body wants. What about ME dont I have any say in it :) ?
I think 130-132 is realistic but at my age 40 I find its harder to lose, even running more than 60mpw. Upping the running got me from 155 to 142 but I have been around that for a year now and feel I need a little help. Extra help.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [kbee] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
It was an endocrinologist who recommended I tri Alli. The reason she suggested it is that she says it can be harder for people on thyroid replacement (even when at the right dose) to lose a little weight and since I was already doing 95% of what they recommend for weight lose - the other 5% is my sugar addiction which I'm desperately trying to kill - she thought this may be what was needed to "jump start" my body as she has had other patients who have had "moderate" (exact words) success with Alli.

I'm 5.7 and at last check I was 137 in a bathing suit. I'm also 32 years old and had a total thyroidectomy in 2002 and have been on thyroid replacement ever since albeit the doseage seems to forever be changing. The weight I had maintained for years and years before the thyroid issues and with a decent amount of muscle tone since I was a Div I athlete in college was between 132 so that's where I'd like to be. Obviously I'm not trying to drop a significant amount of weight by any stretch of the imagination. My issue was that during IM training I gained 5-7lbs which I attributed to muscle gain but it simply won't come off since I'm no longer training for IM distance regardless of what I do.

As for how Alli is going. So far I'd give it a B. The day I started Alli I had gone to my endocrinologist and weighed in at 141 fully clothed and shoes. I started Alli that night and was pretty freaked about the side effects so I was being very concious of what I ate. I was still eating my normal diet but was definitely making sure I didn't have that one extra cookie after dinner as I was afraid of what may happen. I went along for 4 days without a problem. However, my energy level was pretty low which makes sense as Alli is essentially not allowing part of the food you eat to turn be digested which, while tri training, can run you at what one would assume is a pretty significant calorie deficit.

On Friday I weighed myself for the first time right around the same time of day as the day I started taking Alli and I weighed 139 clothed/137 in a suit (I tried both ways to try and get a good read) so it's possible Alli helped me lose two pounds but it's also equally possible that it was a slight fluctuation in water retention, hormones, or any of the other fun things that can have us women flucuating slightly from day to day, or a combination of both.

Also on Friday though my stomach started to become pretty upset. Not in the "outwardly" upset fashion the side effects talk about but just really grumbly to the point where I didn't really want to eat too much. It continued into Saturday morning so I stopped taking the pills since I didn't want to have grumbly stomach during weekend tri training (and my sister was coming to visit). I've started back up with the pills today but may only take them 2x/day with breakfast and dinner to try and avoid any grumbly stomach issues.

At this point in time I think the beauty of the product is that it really does make you think about every single thing you put in your mouth if, like me, you're terrified of the side effects. Not to say I wasn't doing this before but I was certainly giving myself a pass to eat that ice cream as I justified it based on the training I was doing. Trust me when I say I'm the last person who thinks you should live life without your favorite foods (I'm a pastry chef for goodness sake!) but I do think that tri training subtly changed my eating habits so that I was eating really well but also allowing myself to eat bad stuff b/c of the amount of training I was doing. I'm being more concious now of making sure that everything I eat is for a reason - either b/c it's nutritious or if I want a sugar hit I'm making sure to only take a small amount rather than eat the entire bag of skittles.

At the same time I am going to continue taking the pills b/c I decided I wanted to try it for a month baring any major side effects disaster to see what happens. If it can help me get down to my goal weight and also help me do a minor shift in my eating habits then it'll be great.

Two things I have learned from the little alli program thus far - eat more protein. May seem like a no brainer to us triathletes but I was a vegetarian for years so I definitely tend to skip protein for carbs a lot of the time. And secondly, when you need a little afternoon sugar hit the Viactiv calcium chews (in caramel flavor) are just enough sugar to get me over the craving while also helping me get my needed calcium.


http://smallfoodbiz.com
</blatent self-marketing>
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ok, so I have never trained (yet) for an IM. Tho, I have done several marathons and I do train for tris and am now training for ultras. Anyhow, don't sweat the gain. I know that it is difficult being a chick and all. I really hate feeling fat"ter." I'm also a practicing RN and I do know that the studies for heart related instances for endurance activity is not good. Bear with me here, I think our bodies adjustment as women is in our favor. If our bodies want to hold onto fat or if the wt gain is both muscular (probably most likely) and a little bit of increase in fat % it is a good thing. Think of it this way, our systems are trying to maintain balance aka homeostatsis, so with that in mind maybe it is something we should just deal with and after the race(s) you will probably go back to where you were prior. I'm probably not making much sense to you, but bottom line is not too worry. Go out and train, eat right and have a great race. :-)
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [lilpups] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
ok, sorry did not read all the posts before responding. Alli has been proven, but the side effects, weeeell our just that effects. Expect diarrhea if you eat too much fat, that is how alli works from what I know, also it can be rather spontaneous. If you are having some stomach issues you might want to rethink taking it until after your IM?
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [kitkat] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Oh no, I'm not doing an IM this year. Just one little olympic and one little HIM. I actually want to have some time this summer to do things other than tri training (gasp!) like hiking, rock climbing, and sleeping in the sun on the porch on a lazy summer afternoon. :)

I would agree that I wouldn't have tried this if 1. my doctor hadn't recommended it specifically for me and 2. if I was trianing for an IM. Infact my HIM isn't until July so my hope is to do this for a month and then get off of it so that the tiredness I am feeling will be less of an issue for HIM training.


http://smallfoodbiz.com
</blatent self-marketing>
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I also went up a few pounds training for my first iron distance and it was definitely body fat, not muscle. I didn't worry about it too much, though, because I'd overtrained earlier in the season and didn't want to get into that hole again by not getting enough nutrients and energy for the training volume. I also was planning on getting pregnant after (which worked!), so I really didn't see any point in worrying over getting real lean. Needless to say, that at 19 weeks pregnant, I've definitely not lost the weight and have put on quite a few more pounds since!

Rachel's probably right about the female body responding to the heavy training by saving up. I imagine it can be overcome by really watching your nutrition, but it's got to be tricky getting it just right.

P.S. Like you, I generally carry a lot of muscle and weigh a lot more than people think. I'm barely over 5'6" and weighed in at 143 for Silverman, although better race weight would be about 5 lbs less.

__________________________
http://www.aliciaparr.com/blog
http://www.performentor.com

Yes, I too am on Facebook. And LinkedIn. And Twitter. Which begs the question - do I exist in the physical world? Do I?
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Hello, I'm a 28 yr old guy.
Started training for triathlons a couple years ago, and came from a decent running background (3:02 Boston). My weight was ~155.
First I had to learn that whole "side breathing" thing......essentially I had to learn how to swim. Two years later, I've just finished my first IM this past Sunday, and throughout my training I stayed around 155. I look completely different now, however, than I did as just a runner.
I think one generally gains a little weight in triathlon training, especially coming from a weak swimming background. All that swimming adds muscle, and sure you lose fat, but muscle is more dense. And the swimming gave me more structure and definition to my chest, shoulders, and back. I still laugh at myself in the mirror, because I was used my thin torso, equating it with speed like all the other distance running guys. Now I look like some silly tri-model-guy.

From what I understand, most IM athletes get down to their 'race weight' (whatever) as an incidental byproduct of those long-ride/long-run weekends.

2012 Races: Salem Black Cat 10 miler, Heartbreak Hill 1/2 marathon, Getting Married in August
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I am training for my first IM (LP). As prep I did my first marathon in february (it kinda sucked, but I learned a lot). I had expected that dramatic weight loss would be inevitable with all that training, and allowed what I now realize was way too much alcohol and junk calories. Not crappy food per se (all organic, natural, blah blah blah), but too much and at the wrong times. (an organic, vegan, wheat-free brownie is still a brownie it turns out).

I am trying to be a lot more aware of what I was eating- not being neurotic, just conscious. I also started lifting weights again and that seems to have made a noticeable difference. I tore out a training guide from Triathlon mag and am doing it 2.x week. I had always felt that if I didn't work every muscle 3 or 4x week it didn't count, but twice really feels nice.

So far I am down about 5 pounds, but still not at what my coach calls "fighting weight." Am afraid to ask what that is, because it's almost always 10 below where I am.

My final trick--- I got a puppy! I know this sounds silly, but I think it made a difference. Since getting her I seem to be losing more weight than before, and I couldn't figure it out. I read something today about pet therapy counteracting the effects of cortisol (the evil stress hormone that promoted abdominal fat storage)....maybe it's that, or the fartleks we do in the park...
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [eisenhund] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Add me to the list as well. When I was racing olympic or half IM distance, I found that with training came weight loss, which was pretty nice!

I'm 26 yo, 5'6" and am usually about 132 race weight, but for IMAZ I clocked in at 138 and had been creeping up in weight leading to the race (due to taper?!)!! I agree with all the posts before - I definitely felt a gain in muscle, especially in the back and shoulders from swimming 4 days a week and doing strength training. I also felt like my quads and butt were pretty solid muscularly. BUT, I noticed that my belly started to get a little squishy as my volume increased, and I was going insane because I was doing tons of core work!! Although I did let myself slip and have a few extra desserts here and there, by no means was I eating unhealthy! Quite the opposite, in fact.

I feel relieved to read that I'm not the only one. I was definitely my thinnest when training for a marathon in 2006. Not sure what to expect next!! Except that I'll be nibbling on the veggies until the extra comes off...

Jodi - say it ain't so about cutting the PB!! I swear, PB runs in my veins... ;) Perhaps that is my problem...

sassyshanracing.blogspot.com
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [tigerchik] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
All: Tigerchick is quite the sh*t. I love her advice. I know this may be redundent for you but I wanted to share my findings this morning with my nutrionist:

So I finally went to my dietician this morning. I brought her my training plan for my next IM and daily food journal I’ve been keeping. She was shocked about how much working out I’ve been doing comparing to what I’ve been eating on my food journal. To make a long story short—she created a meal plan for me to follow while IM training. Previously I was eating about (1500-2200 and didn’t really have an appetite) This week, it consists of 2800 calories a day including 73-90 fat grams a day. Keep in mind this was NOTHING close to what I was eating. She confirmed that once I start eating this much—it will help jump start my metabolism and that I will eventually get off this plateau that I’ve been at FOREVER . She said initially that I may gain a few pounds and that would be totally normal; since my body will be in shocked that I am actually getting a lot more calories for my regular activity and sustain IM workouts. So, that’s the scoop here. I feel so much better that I went and saw her.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [NYJan] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I'm glad you had a positive experience with the nutritionist. Good luck with your training, and I'm sure you can find plenty of yummy things to eat to get the energy you need too.

maybe she's born with it, maybe it's chlorine
If you're injured and need some sympathy, PM me and I'm very happy to write back.
disclaimer: PhD not MD
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [NYJan] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What are you eating to increase your good fat intake? I don't eat nearly enough fat and am interested to hear what you are eating. Thanks.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [matti58] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Avocado, olive oil, regular cheese. But to be honest-- I am still working on bumping up my fat intake. I used to be afraid to eat "fats." Update-- Day one of my 2800 Calorie intake-- I had AWESOME workouts yesterday-- ran 9 miles of hills and swam 3700 in pool-- and felt MUCH better then normal and MUCH more energy.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [Jodi] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
What? No peanut butter for you? I can't believe what I'm reading!

--
01001010 01100101 01101110 01001000 01010011 00100000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01010100 01101000 01100101 00100000 01000100 01100101 01110110 01101001 01101100 00100000 00101000 01100001 01100011 01100011 01101111 01110010 01100100 01101001 01101110 01100111 00100000 01110100 01101111 00100000 01110010 01101111 01100001 01100100 01101000 01101111 01110101 01110011 01100101 00101001 00100001
http://trainingoferic.blogspot.com/
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [jenhs] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I am a guy who has experienced similar results. A few years ago I decided to take my fitness seriously and lost 50 lbs. I then re-gained 10 lbs which put me at a more healthy weight but I always felt that 5 down from that was a good race weight for me. Whether it was or not it turned out to me near impossible to loose that 5 lbs. Hard training and sensible diet didn’t do it. Sometimes I gained under those conditions. I finally stopped stressing about it and just tried to be healthy and get faster. Having put in some strong training weeks to prepare for my first wildflower I just recently lost those 5 lbs. and don’t feel tired, run down or ravenous. I feel like I’m just fitter and need to eat less to train just as hard, but really I can’t explain it.

I did read an interesting article in a muscle magazine that talked about fish oil. The article was warning body builders to avoid fish oil if they wanted to gain mass. I guess fish oil is a natural anti inflammatory. That is why it is so good for your heart and circulatory system. Anyway if muscles don’t get inflamed then your body doesn’t see them as damaged and doesn’t try to rebuild them bigger. For a weight lifter this is bad but I read it as a useful trick to possibly keep myself from bulking up with all the tri training. I take a single fish oil cap after every hard workout and/or at least once a day. It certainly won’t hurt and might help.
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [tenspeeed] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Fish Oil is wonderful. In so many ways! As an added bonus, I find that it is an appetite suppressant.

:-)

Jodi
Quote Reply
Re: IM and Weight Gain [RoseC] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
After reading all these replies, I have respond that I lost weight during training. Not a lot, maybe 10-15lbs, but I lost it mostly during my base training phase where I was doing a lot of LSD bricks at very low intensity. I didn't add any weight during my build phase either. I have always had lots of muscle compared to other women my size, and I gain bulk very easily if I'm not careful. Of course I have since gained that lost weight back and more since, but that's cuz I like beer and steak too much. Dang, life ain't fair eh? ;-)

AP

------------------------
"How bad could it be?" - SimpleS
Quote Reply