Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Re: I got my ass beat by Joaquin riding his Powercranks up La Morcuera with a Powertap [Marco in BC]
In Reply To:



just for the sake of discussion, isn't there a piece of software involved in the transfer between the PT hub and the computer? If so it would be possible (although unlikely) that corrupt data could've sent the program in an error state where it would just keep repeating the same data over and over and over for values it wasn't able to read.

The fact that the data in the PT hub became bogus only after the climb started could happen because possibly the PT decided to pack it in once the power/torque went above a certain level (unlikely to have been reached while riding there). Again, I am not saying this is what happened, but if it did it'd pretty easy to repro, just take the hub, redownload the data with the same version of the software, and either you'll get the same bogus file or maybe this time you won't hit the bug and you'll get the right file out: of course if the hub is sent away for servicing and/or is completely reset this won't be possible anymore.

Nice try--but not quite (and I realize you're just playing devil's advocate here). 2 problems: 1) there are earlier sections of the ride with high power where the hub acts normally, and 2) while the data are identical in some sections, in other sections they're 'almost' identical, i.e. the power pattern repeats itself, but some of the other numbers may or may not repeat themselves. IOW, someone changed a couple of pieces in an attempt to 'not make it look like a clear cut and paste'. For me, THIS is the most obvious reason that the data are faked, and not an artifact of the PT. If you look closely at the raw data, you'll see exactly what I mean.

EDIT: oh yeah, and 3) if this were a software glitch, I think it's pretty likely that someone, somewhere, would have experienced or witnessed this before. I'm sure the folks contributing to this thread/comedy have seen a combined number of 'Tap files numbering in the 10's of thousands--and yet this is the first case--and the glitch just so happens to match up with a desired result?
Last edited by: roady: Nov 22, 07 8:55

Edit Log:

  • Post edited by roady (Dawson Saddle) on Nov 22, 07 8:55