mrtopher1980 wrote:
noofus wrote:
mrtopher1980 wrote:
My only gripe with is it seems to set your calories based on your target weight and then subtracts your deficit. I'm 200lbs and it says I should be eating 1300 calories. Both My plate and the MS app factored your base calories for the day on your current weight entered minus the deficit. It took me a little bit to figure out when it shows I was 500 or so calories over for the day in reality I was still under for my current weight and a realistic deficit.
Pretty sure this isn't true. When I was using MFP to track weight loss it set my calorie goal for current weight less deficit. When I hit 10lbs it asked me if I wanted to recalculate, after I said yes it gave me a new, lower, "base" calorie rate.
On all the other apps I've used the daily calories have changed with every input of a .1lbs up or down.
On my fitness pal it has been 1380 since day one at 200lbs, it has been 1380 when I entered 204 and it has been 1380 when I entered 198.
What you describe is exactly what I"m saying I have a problem with, it shouldn't be asking to reset at 10lbs, that is huge, It should be adjusting as you drop or gain.
I agree. I realized after that first 10lbs that the 10lb increment is too large. I suspect they have that set up for people with A LOT of weight to lose, where 10lbs isn't actually all that much. After that point I manually kept resetting it after every ~2lbs.
On a different note - 1380 seems WAY too low.
I am 5'7" and right now at 145lbs. When I was trying to lose weight it had me at 1500ish, and now I have it set to 1980 even though I am not actually logging.