Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Ankle Slightly Rolled - No Pain So Why Swelling?
Quote | Reply
I rolled my right ankle/foot while hiking on Friday. We were camped at 10,500 ft doing a summit of 13,500 ft at the time I rolled it. It was sore while walking but nothing like the bad basketball ankle sprains or broken 5th met (other foot) I've had before. I hiked back to camp and out to the trailhead the next day (about 12 miles total) and it was sore and annoying but not painful. No limping. Some swelling the next day, but no big deal. Got home, rode my bike no issues yesterday and today. Now, my foot is swollen and stiff and a little discolored by the sprain. If I press around the ankle bone the ligaments and tissue are sore but again, nothing like the swelling and pain when I broke my foot 3 years ago. I can weight bear and walk without feeling anything. I've been lazy as hell and haven't done squat with RICE.

So is this normal for swelling to be present without any real pain or functional issues? I read that the swelling is present to protect the ligaments while they heal. Seems logical. No, I haven't gotten an x-ray...the only reason to do so would be because of the swelling as there's no pain.

Thoughts?
Quote Reply
Re: Ankle Slightly Rolled - No Pain So Why Swelling? [JimMoss] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Following multiple or severe ankle injuries, the ligaments may be elongated to the point that (mild) rolling only causes minimal damage. In other words, the ligaments may be permanently 'stretched out'. The downside is that you're left with a permanently unstable ankle, meaning you can easily invert it by stepping on a pebble or off a curb.
I've sprained mine so many times that when I mildly roll it, there's enough flexibility so that it's almost like a normal range of motion.
I do wear supportive shoes with a solid heel counter and always run with one eye on the ground.

Dr Jay
http://www.Tri-Pod.net
Quote Reply
Re: Ankle Slightly Rolled - No Pain So Why Swelling? [JimMoss] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
I would get an X-ray to rule out an avulsion fracture. Rolled mine 9 weeks ago and continue to train for another 2 weeks and finally went to get an X-ray and sure enough, I had a fracture. Had to cancel two ironman races and have been in a walking boot for 6 weeks. Sucks balls.
Last edited by: russ090909: Jul 21, 14 19:22
Quote Reply
Re: Ankle Slightly Rolled - No Pain So Why Swelling? [russ090909] [ In reply to ]
Quote | Reply
Yes, I've had an avulsion fracture of the left 5th metatarsal. This current incident with my right foot while hiking is very minor compared to that avulsion fracture. Unless there's another type of avulsion fracture from an inversion of the foot that I'm not aware of, I doubt that is what has happened.

I'm sorry that you too have suffered an avulsion fracture. They do suck balls. It was awful.
Quote Reply