nealhe wrote:
Hello trifil and All, “I’m saying this because it’s true. Inside of us, we both know that Speedplay pedals are the way of the future. You’re part of the event, the thing that’s happening. When the Speedplay pedals are available and you don’t get them, you’ll regret it. Maybe not today. Maybe not tomorrow, but soon and for the rest of your life.”
(apologies to the authors) I have always wanted to like sp pedals. I like the concept - the two sided entry, the large measure of adjustability and the ability to fine tune the float without moving the location of the cleat. The large fore and aft range for siting the cleat is also great as is the multitude of available axle lengths. However, in use they fail to live up to their promise. The cleats get fouled easily, they are very sensitive to cleat bolt torque and to the curvature of the shoe sole. They wear very quickly and develop the dreaded rocking. I once had a pair that seemingly had the rocking built in - they rocked right out of the box with the brand new cleats! And the bearings are not great compared to others on the market. This combined with their cost and the high price of replacement cleats mean they are off my list.
I have tried them a few times and used them for almost a year about a decade ago but, invariably, I end up back on spd-sl pedals which are the benchmark for a solid and dependable pedal design, imo.
Anyone who loves the function and feel of Speedplays should give Keywin pedals a try. They max out at only six degrees of float, but they have a huge platform, a tunable float (in terms of resistance), rock solid cleat retention and they are lightweight and last forever.