rmt wrote:
No, I disagree that is what rule 11 is saying (to be clear I wouldn’t use headphones in an IM, but just reading the rules..).
It clearly specifies
communication devices may not be used for…. listening to music. Since the other rule also specifies what TYPE of headphones may be used, it would be difficult for IM to argue that it wasn’t permissible to use a Garmin watch that stores and plays music (but isn’t a communication device) playing into bone conduction headphones.
I’d be checking with the race director though (actually, I wouldn’t, as I wouldn’t be using headphones, but you get my point…
The thing here though is you're talking about technology that wasn't available when that rule was written. The rule has been there for a long time, and way before garmin watches with music. To be fair it was there before garmin watches with GPS were around...
The rule is there for safety - the athletes and others in order that there is no (minimal) risk of an athlete not hearing an ambulance, bike (ie referee, medic, lead athlete escort, media), or even other athlete come up behind, or for the athlete to hear instructions from marshall / refs. In relation to the latter, examples are calling out potential trip hazard that has appeared on course, notifying of a course change (happened to me when there had been a fatality on the course), the need to put on a jacket / illuminated pendant at dusk.
And so the rule is there to just make it nice and easy - no headphones.
But then someone thought they would be a smart arse and so it got adapted to be really clear to the pedantic, that it was headphones and ear buds.
Etc etc.
There is an easy solution if you can't manage to survive for 3.5-4 hours of running past crowds of supporters and around other athletes. Train harder and run faster.....