rruff wrote:
Ai_1 wrote:
You say "I wouldn't be bombing any descents just yet". When would you know it was safe to start bombing descents?It's safe now. The hole isn't any worse than a valve hole. Think of it another way. Manufacturers use the same extrusion for 16 hole rims and 36 hole rims. The only difference is the number of holes drilled in it.
There are a lot bigger things to worry about while bombing down a descent than a rim that has an extra hole.
Valve holes are circular, drilled, central and intentional.
That hole is irregular, punched/torn, eccentric and you don't actually know it's safe.
Aluminium alloys can work harden
Aluminium propagates cracks
Irregular holes are likely to create stress concentrations
The shape of the rim is critical to it's strength and anything that interferes with the corner or sides, even a little is likely to be more critical
There are bigger things to worry about bombing down a descent than a rim that has an extra hole, you say. Well of course, unless it fails, in which case it was the biggest thing to worry about.
I don't know if it's safe or not, neither does the OP and neither do you. That's enough reason not to use it.