Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Re: Tri Bikes with Greatest Pad Reach/X ?? and the role of Crank Length in modern Tri bike fits [fredly]
fredly wrote:
Of course riders with short(er) cranks position their saddles farther back than those on long(er) cranks, that's necessary just to equalize the rest of the position relative to the pedal, and the x/y axis of the crankā€¦

Just some quick thoughts, interesting stuff!


Thank you. Note that your statement above partially supports the hypothesis in the original post. The feedback Iā€™m receiving is that a rider moving further back when they go to shorter cranks is to keep their glutes engaged, and that closes off the hips and doesnā€™t allow them to feel theyā€™re putting their mass into the pedal stroke (and they have issues on the run).

As for ā€˜putting numbers to this hypothesisā€™, I wrote that Iā€™m not doing biomechanics research at the moment, so I can only leave you with a hypothesis based on observations, a tiny bit of thematic analysis, and no statistical comparison conducted. Iā€™m not sure what you mean by ā€œnormalizing standardā€ - it sounds like youā€™re asking for a t-test, but I wonā€™t be doing any analyses. Iā€™m just stating a hypothesis. The feedback Iā€™m getting verbally and seeing in results seems to support the hypothesis, but definitely doesnā€™t fully confirm it.

I made some edits in the OP that address your other comments - thank you for the thoughts!

watching the women in Kona right now and see many of them crunched up forward - guarantee thatā€™s not where they were during their bike fit, and now their glute vs quad use is far off from what they were perceiving during their bike fit, and I suggest that will affect their run. When triathletes are fit sitting far back behind the bb like a TT rider bound by UCI rules (Remco being an exception), they often inch forward during long course triathlon races (and have to constantly scoot back all race). Rudy (175mm) and Magness (172.5mm) are examples of triathletes in the position Iā€™m speaking of in my OP.

wovebike.com | Wove on instagram
Last edited by: milesthedog: Oct 14, 23 12:36

Edit Log:

  • Post edited by milesthedog (Dawson Saddle) on Oct 14, 23 10:44
  • Post edited by milesthedog (Dawson Saddle) on Oct 14, 23 10:46
  • Post edited by milesthedog (Dawson Saddle) on Oct 14, 23 10:46
  • Post edited by milesthedog (Dawson Saddle) on Oct 14, 23 11:40
  • Post edited by milesthedog (Dawson Saddle) on Oct 14, 23 11:42
  • Post edited by milesthedog (Dawson Saddle) on Oct 14, 23 12:05
  • Post edited by milesthedog (Dawson Saddle) on Oct 14, 23 12:08
  • Post edited by milesthedog (Dawson Saddle) on Oct 14, 23 12:27
  • Post edited by milesthedog (Dawson Saddle) on Oct 14, 23 12:28
  • Post edited by milesthedog (Dawson Saddle) on Oct 14, 23 12:31
  • Post edited by milesthedog (Dawson Saddle) on Oct 14, 23 12:36