Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Re: Alto Cycling Carbon Clincher Brake Track Test [BryanD]
BryanD wrote:
They all have their internal tests they do. Zipp and ENVE do plenty of in house testing. You are not the only company doing this. However, the rims and pads work together as a system. Your test is flawed.


I suppose in a perfect world, maybe one uses proprietary pads for each rim, and designs the system to use constant input watts but modulate brake caliper pressure to achieve a constant wheel speed, and that would be an apples-to-apples comparison, i.e. it would tell me how rim A (paired with brake pads A) would compare to rim B (paired with brake pads B) at getting me safely down mountain X. But that would require a way more sophisticated test setup that could adjust brake caliper pressure to achieve a desired speed.

I suppose a cruder version could involve manually calibrating the brake caliper pressure to achieve a set wheel speed at the beginning of the test, and then letting things run. As the brake pad and rim were progressively affected by wear, wheel speed would start to deviate, but this would at least put the rims in the ballpark of each other, so it would be more of an apples-to-pears comparison, better than apples-to-oranges.
Last edited by: niccolo: Dec 10, 17 11:44

Edit Log:

  • Post edited by niccolo (Dawson Saddle) on Dec 10, 17 11:44