Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Re: The Aero Bike Shootout TEST DAY THREAD [kileyay]
kileyay wrote:
Did anyone mention that each bike has a different base bar. That's likely to skew results.

Did anyone mention that the P5 has hydraulic Magura brifters and the others are all Shimano? That's likely to skew results.

Did anyone mention that some bikes have full internal routing...

We could go on. And on. And on. All specs will be listed in a table in the report and you can make of it what you will and shit on it accordingly.
But I thought you guys were installing aftermarket extensions in order to control the testing better? I think you went to a lot of trouble to match extensions from bike to bike, I was just surprised they weren't mounted similar. I'd love some reasoning as to why you did not, despite knowing it would likely significantly impact comparability of your tests.

You guys set the standards you're being evaluated on. You identified all of the questions you were trying to answer. You insisted your testing would be objective, implying that manufacturer testing is subjective.

You were extremely defensive when others expressed doubt you were prepared to test things in an objective, comparable fashion. And now you're extremely defensive when others are pointing out some fairly impactful things that might skew your results. Either you overlooked those things or you considered the cost-benefit and made a choice. Instead of taking the opportunity to explain those decisions, you're throwing rocks.

I'm sure plenty hope you fail at your stated mission, but some of us actually hope you succeed.

Trent Nix
Owned and operated Tri Shop
F.I.S.T. Advanced Certified Fitter | Retul Master Certified Fitter (back when those were things)
Last edited by: trentnix: May 6, 17 11:29

Edit Log:

  • Post edited by trentnix (Dawson Saddle) on May 6, 17 11:29