Login required to started new threads

Login required to post replies

Re: Strength Training, Science vs N=1 [Frank Day]
In Reply To:
Could you direct me to the literature showing that Monod is "unaffected" by hyperoxia or hypoxia.


There have been multiple such studies, but Moritani et al. (Ergonomics 1981; 24(5):339-50) appear to have been the first. (There are multiple review articles out there on the critical power concept, so I suggest that you start your reading with one of those.)

In Reply To:
I find it interesting that you try to use a term (anaerobic work capacity) that, it seems, only you understand and have defined in your own mind. When someone asked you for a literature reference you said it didn't exist, as I understood it.


That is correct: most people use anaerobic capacity and anaerobic work capacity interchangeably, whereas I prefer to keep them separate (just as I once was careful to draw a distinction in a review paper between splanchnic glucose production measured using the a-v balance approach and whole-body glucose Ra measured using an isotopic tracer, even though many sloppily (IMO) refer to both as "hepatic glucose production"). You will note, though, that while I feel that this distinction is useful, I also recognize that it is my invention (as is the use of "metabolic fitness" as a synonym for LT, comparable to how "cardiovascular fitness" is used as a synonym for VO2max), and thus don't thrust it upon others (this thread only went in this direction when someone asked what I meant).

In Reply To:
Of course, the breakdown of any model to predict outcome is a result of the model not being adequate for the conditions ("both the model being too simple and the assumptions of the model being violated") How can anyone say the model means anything under conditions where it is known to break down and keep a straight face?


Because the conclusion that the y-intercept is an indicator of anaerobic capacity is based upon application of the model under conditions/experiments in which it does NOT break down.
Last edited by: Andrew Coggan: Jan 22, 10 12:36

Edit Log:

  • Post edited by Andrew Coggan (Dawson Saddle) on Jan 22, 10 12:36