I'm looking into buying an indoor trainer. From what I've read I probably want a magnet or fluid trainer. Which trainers would you guys recommend. I don't know much about them.
Triathlon Forum
Login required to started new threads
Login required to post replies
Re: Indoor Trainers [wasatchrunner]
[ In reply to ]
Kurt Kinetic fluid road; $300 (or cheaper if you find clearance online), lifetime warranty, good feel, and relatively quiet.
Re: Indoor Trainers [wasatchrunner]
[ In reply to ]
I'll second Kinetic...mine gets 6 hours per week at average of 350 watts per hour.
Re: Indoor Trainers [JPatterson]
[ In reply to ]
This forum is full of two types of people - Kurt Kinetic fans, and those who haven't yet tried Kurt Kinetic. :)
Re: Indoor Trainers [Boogie711]
[ In reply to ]
Thoughts on Cycleops Fluid 2 ???? Thinking about getting one...
_____________________________________________
"It's a line you have to cross to understand."
_____________________________________________
"It's a line you have to cross to understand."
Re: Indoor Trainers [Quantum]
[ In reply to ]
Do you need a "trainer" tire? I think I tried a Kinetic when I got fitted, and I noticed my back wheel seemed to be fine. I have a Cycleops now that I have to use the trainer tire or else it gets shredded to pieces.
------------------
@brooksdoughtie
USAT-L2,Y&J; USAC-L2
http://www.aomultisport.com
------------------
@brooksdoughtie
USAT-L2,Y&J; USAC-L2
http://www.aomultisport.com
Re: Indoor Trainers [bad929]
[ In reply to ]
Craigslist your area and find a fluid one. Im on a blackburn and it's great.
Re: Indoor Trainers [wasatchrunner]
[ In reply to ]
Kurt Kinetic. I ride the hell out of mine. Lifetime warranty! Excellent customer service.
Re: Indoor Trainers [jar70]
[ In reply to ]
With the exception of the new LeMond (which I have never ridden) I have melted all of the major manufactures fluid trainers that I have tried....and yes including a Kinetic.
The Kinetic is the last to burn up under sustained wattage. You don't need to worry about this happening unless you are hitting it with 400+ watts for more than an hour at a time. The Kinetic people are great and they will send you a new unit if yours breaks.
The Kinetic is the last to burn up under sustained wattage. You don't need to worry about this happening unless you are hitting it with 400+ watts for more than an hour at a time. The Kinetic people are great and they will send you a new unit if yours breaks.
Re: Indoor Trainers [JPatterson]
[ In reply to ]
The Kinetic is the last to burn up under sustained wattage. You don't need to worry about this happening unless you are hitting it with 400+ watts for more than an hour at a time.
OK, I figured it out. JPatterson must be Fabian Cancellara's Slowtwitch username! ;-)
Steve Fleck @stevefleck | Blog
OK, I figured it out. JPatterson must be Fabian Cancellara's Slowtwitch username! ;-)
Steve Fleck @stevefleck | Blog
Re: Indoor Trainers [Boogie711]
[ In reply to ]
So True, I ride my KK quite a bit, its smooth , quiet and I can get power reading w/ my KK power computer.
I am affiliated w/ Bicycleoutfittersindy.com I can have any trainer I want , but I use the kinetic w/ the extra 12lb flywheel , best on the market period
we offer these for less than anybody out there coupon code 20% OFF A95436
I am affiliated w/ Bicycleoutfittersindy.com I can have any trainer I want , but I use the kinetic w/ the extra 12lb flywheel , best on the market period
we offer these for less than anybody out there coupon code 20% OFF A95436
Re: Indoor Trainers [Fleck]
[ In reply to ]
Re: Indoor Trainers [solidasarock7]
[ In reply to ]
sorry just found out this code was rendered inactive at the request of KK , b/c it was below manufacturer pricing guide lines
but I will get it turned on for cycber Monday it will be turned on soon or at the latest by 9 am EST Mon and it will work till Tues morning
but I will get it turned on for cycber Monday it will be turned on soon or at the latest by 9 am EST Mon and it will work till Tues morning
Re: Indoor Trainers [solidasarock7]
[ In reply to ]
I have a few days of training on my new Lemond Revolution. If you are working out where neighbors aren't to close to you I would really recommend this!
Thing is: It is loud! The fan creates a humming sound (comparable to a vacuum-cleaner) and the noice will go up or down depending on the speed of the fan.
BUT no more tire-roller interference and it is dead stable. Plus there will be a power-computer available in December for an extra $350. So I would say that the noise is the only downside! They also offer lifetime warranty on the trainer.
Kurt Kinetic is also being recommended by everyone that has tried one, so that really would be my second choice (haven't tried one myself).
Thing is: It is loud! The fan creates a humming sound (comparable to a vacuum-cleaner) and the noice will go up or down depending on the speed of the fan.
BUT no more tire-roller interference and it is dead stable. Plus there will be a power-computer available in December for an extra $350. So I would say that the noise is the only downside! They also offer lifetime warranty on the trainer.
Kurt Kinetic is also being recommended by everyone that has tried one, so that really would be my second choice (haven't tried one myself).
Re: Indoor Trainers [Fleck]
[ In reply to ]
How loud are the KK's?
_____________________________________________
"It's a line you have to cross to understand."
_____________________________________________
"It's a line you have to cross to understand."
Re: Indoor Trainers [jar70]
[ In reply to ]
I keep the TV at the same volume when I'm on the trainer as I do when I'm just sitting on the couch.
Of course, the fan I have blowing at me while I'm on the trainer is loud because it's on high.
Of course, the fan I have blowing at me while I'm on the trainer is loud because it's on high.
Re: Indoor Trainers [wasatchrunner]
[ In reply to ]
I've had my Tacx for ten years with no problems. Mag with resistance. Lots of resistance.
__________________________________________________________________________
Bike Centric Art
__________________________________________________________________________
Bike Centric Art
Re: Indoor Trainers [wasatchrunner]
[ In reply to ]
Screw fluid trainers. Get a CycleOps Super Magneto Pro. I have both a KK and the Super Mag and the Super is much better. It's just as smooth if not smoother than my KK and it has 4 levels of adjustable resistence that is smooth and works well. Oh and if that doesnt convince you, Rappstar uses one too.
http://cycleops.com/...63&category_id=3
http://cycleops.com/...63&category_id=3
Re: Indoor Trainers [wasatchrunner]
[ In reply to ]
Take a look at the Tacx Satori, it's magnetic but it's the only trainer I've used that allows you to put out huge power at low cadence (other than a Computrainer). I also have a Cycle-Ops Fluid 2 and a Computrainer but I find myself riding the Tacx more and more, especially now that I have a Quarq so the Computrainer is essentially collecting dust. The Tacx is incredible and looks like a work of art, I love it.
Re: Indoor Trainers [wasatchrunner]
[ In reply to ]
www.1upusa.com. American made, and the best in the market.
Re: Indoor Trainers [AlexG]
[ In reply to ]
Why do you think the Super Magneto Pro is much better than the KK? I'm trying to decide between the two, your insight would be particularly useful.
I read from one buyer that the Magneto was pretty loud, but he didn't own any other trainers as a comparison. Which is louder, Magneto or KK?
Thanks for the help in deciding.
I read from one buyer that the Magneto was pretty loud, but he didn't own any other trainers as a comparison. Which is louder, Magneto or KK?
Thanks for the help in deciding.
Re: Indoor Trainers [YaHey]
[ In reply to ]
That 1up looks pretty nice. What are the cons?
Re: Indoor Trainers [solidasarock7]
[ In reply to ]
http://www.bicycleoutfittersindy.com
the code A95436 in prior post is now active for 20% of KK road machine from the minimum advertised price of 319 takes it down to about 255 + free shipping ....crazy
another code for BOI is " cycbermonday " activates 25% off most items , excluding sale , closeouts and trainer combos...expires Tues AM
Profile design Bionik 2 wet suit $99 + free ship
regularly $419
the code A95436 in prior post is now active for 20% of KK road machine from the minimum advertised price of 319 takes it down to about 255 + free shipping ....crazy
another code for BOI is " cycbermonday " activates 25% off most items , excluding sale , closeouts and trainer combos...expires Tues AM
Profile design Bionik 2 wet suit $99 + free ship
regularly $419
Re: Indoor Trainers [anitan1]
[ In reply to ]
anitan1, I had a 1up trainer 3 years ago and loved it...with that said, mine for some reason had friction plate problems and I had to have 3 replaced. Excellent customer service, everything warrantied. I believe they have that issue fixed as they were addressing it then because some models were having that problem, lemons I guess. It was quiet and well made and very smooth. I tried a kk fluid once at the shop I was fitted at and it wasn't as smooth or quiet as the 1up.
The Rat Snake:
A Tribute Race at Gilbert Lake State Park, Laurens, NY May 16 2015
Follow the Rat Snake on Twitter
The Rat Snake:
A Tribute Race at Gilbert Lake State Park, Laurens, NY May 16 2015
Follow the Rat Snake on Twitter
I have tried just about every trainer out there. The KK has been my winter best friend for the last 2 years. nothing else even comes close to an 18lb flywheel on the Pro model w/ a 60 second coast down.
I can get power w/ my KK power computer, which is calibrated to the unit perfectly b/c they use medical grade silicone as the fluid for resistance. the viscosity does not change w/ raising temperatures created in the resistance unit while riding, so it produces consistent measurable and repeatable resistance every time. giving me accurate power reading for much less than other power options.
fluid trainers dont need to be adjustable b/c the resistance is progressive , just like outdoor riding.
I can get power w/ my KK power computer, which is calibrated to the unit perfectly b/c they use medical grade silicone as the fluid for resistance. the viscosity does not change w/ raising temperatures created in the resistance unit while riding, so it produces consistent measurable and repeatable resistance every time. giving me accurate power reading for much less than other power options.
fluid trainers dont need to be adjustable b/c the resistance is progressive , just like outdoor riding.
Last edited by:
solidasarock7: Nov 28, 10 17:36