I think when that statement was made, it was at a time in the show where there were significant characters still on the Basestar. Technically not "in the fleet", because as I recall that was before the co-operation pact with the rogue Cylons. Also, Starbuck was still missing. That may trim down the list, unless there is some surprise appearance by someone a la Daneel Olivaw at the end of the Foundation series.


EDIT: God, I am a flippin' geek.

It's the Admiral.

---

"The great pleasure in life is doing what people say you cannot do."

They're all cylons. Every frackin' one of them.

---

__________
there was no one chasing us... distance is its own reward.

 
Yeah, I rewatched that episode and Deanna clearly says that only 4 of the final five are in the fleet. Therefore, my theory is that the final five is one that already "died". So my guess is either Cally or Cat.

Was Boxy the kid or the robot dog?

---

_____________________________________
You're not stuck in traffic. You ARE traffic.

Boxy was the kid. Daggett was the dog. And yes, I am still a geek.

One of the minor characters who died.

I'm guessing Billy.


Tigh's wife would be interesting, but I think the Cylon skin jobs tend to be attracted to humans not other skin jobs...

Billy is a good guess but I can't imagine it having a huge WOW factor, which is what they've promised. I read where Mary M mentioned that it would be beneficial to go back to the very beginning of the series.

Entertainment Weekly's website ew.com has a handful of guesses along with their probabilities.

Also, in case you missed any episodes, scifi is showing the first ten all day tomorrow.

Tigh's wife is more likely I think. She always was somewhat manipulative.

The problem with Tigh's wife is that she is very similar to a Six but older.

Hey, what do you think of Gaeta? He could also be a cylon.

First ten of season four...

Your comment about her being an older six is interesting.... Mom and Pop Cylon? Mean Uncle Cavil....

Oh crap... I guess I'm a geek too.

At least we can all agree......can't freaking wait until 10pm tonight! If I can stay sober that long....

I'm having to DVR it tonight beacuse I still have to watch the last two episodes (on DVD) before I watch tonight's show.

Jeff

  

So now the cat's out of the bag, how cool is this?

---

"The great pleasure in life is doing what people say you cannot do."

Gaeta has been my #1 guess all along.

Another dark horse is Admiral Helena Cain.

---

Live long and surf!

So now the cat's out of the bag, how cool is this?[/quote]
WOW!!! JUST WOW!!!!!!!!

Spoiler of last episode........................





























So, what the frak is Starbuck then?
And I'm still shocked about Dualla.

Wasn't the dog called, Muffit...or something?

---

=====================================
"Yeah you point a finger back far enough and some germ gets blamed for splitting in two."

Colonel Saul Tigh from Battlestar Galactica

more spoiler in my reply...


hah -- that was awesome.

i was *sort of* right (i was actually kidding) -- i thought Dualla might be a cylon....

this should be an interesting half-season.

---

__________
there was no one chasing us... distance is its own reward.

The Dualla scene was the most shocking thing on there yet, except maybe the classic scene where Tigh poisons his wife. Uh-oh on that one.

SPOILER:


















So, the final 5 have been resurrected after being dead 2,000 years? And yes, what the frak is Starbuck?

My guess - Starbuck is a Being of Light. if you remember the original series, the Beings of Light were sort of angels. And she's clearly the Angel of Death.

---

Live long and surf!

Ok. I'm a BSG newbie. I just watched the "cliff notes" yesterday and tuned in for the episodes last night.

So, why can't Starbuck be a Cylon? From what little I know, isn't that what happens to them when they die? Don't they get "reincarnated" or "downloaded" into another body?

Maybe there was more than 5 and she's the 6th?

---

---

"100% of the people who confuse correlation and causation end up dying."

The show has made it pretty clear from early on that there are 12 Cylon models, the 7 that we knew early on that were the "bad guys", and then 5 others that were fundamentally different. If they went back on that and say now whoops, fooled you, there were really 13, then I don't think the fans would be too happy. Even the producers/creators continually have said there are only 12. Starbuck has to be something else.