Scumbag cheats to get into Boston

This dork tried to cheat his way into Boston. Probably not the first, or the last.

So who is the phantom runner???

Cheating at the Twin Cities Marathon?

  ![http://www.kare11.com/assetpool/images/061130172719_marathon-cheater-hd.jpg](http://www.kare11.com/assetpool/images/061130172719_marathon-cheater-hd.jpg)

http://www.kare11.com/images/video-icon.gif
You have to admire the stats put up by Hassan Ibrahim at this year’s Medtronic Twin Cities Marathon. The University of Minnesota physician shaved more than an hour off his previous four finishes in the Twin Cities Marathon, and in doing so qualified for the prestigious Boston Marathon.

Just one problem. Ibrahim never ran the race. In a phone conversation with KARE, Ibrahim admitted that he gave his race number and electronic monitoring chip to another runner.

Brian Mastel, Race Operations Manager, confirms Twin Cities Marathon Inc. has launched a review of the apparent identity swap, after receiving a tip. “In my three years (with the marathon) this is the first time we’ve had to deal with somebody potentially doing that,” said Mastel.

Race photos from the Twin Cities Marathon website show a man wearing Ibrahim’s number who bears little resemblance to Ibrahim. Ibrahim first referred to the man as “a friend,” then later described him as the brother of a co-worker. Ibrahim said the man was visiting from out of town, and said he doesn’t know his name.

But Ibrahim must have liked the other runner’s finish time of just over three hours, ten minutes. A race official in Boston confirmed that Ibrahim registered himself for the Boston Marathon under the time run by the other runner.

“It’s hard to qualify for Boston,” said Mastel, who himself has been trying to qualify for the Boston Marathon for years. But Mastel says the biggest issue is safety. “If a runner were to go down on the course, if we’re trying to take care of them and they’re running under someone else’s number we don’t who they are.”

So why did Ibrahim give up his number? When asked by KARE, Ibrahim initially said, “It’s none of your business.” He later called back and said he only wanted to run the Boston Marathon to raise money for a medical charity. Ibrahim said he planned to seek $25,000 dollars in pledges. “I wanted to do something good.” He said he now realizes he shouldn’t have given the other runner his number.

If race officials rule that he cheated, Ibrahim’s 2006 Twin Cities Marathon results would likely be disqualified, which would prohibit him from running at Boston. He could also be banned from future Twin Cities Marathons, though Mastel says permanent bans are generally reserved for runners with multiple rules violations.

“Regardless of the outcome I hope that people get that we’re serious about keeping this sport safe and people following the rules,” said Mastel.

As for the runner that ran in Ibrihim’s place, Twin Cities Marathon Inc. isn’t sure who it is. But if race officials find out, Mastel says the other runner could face sanctions, too.

(Copyright 2006 by KARE 11. All Rights Reserved.)

What the?

Idiot …

As a physician, he should know that hard work gets the reward/paycheck. Likely cheated in medical school/undergrad then as well as this “mentality” is usually always present.

I was told some dude did the same thing at IMFL this year, that is have someone else do the swim and bike then he switched and did the run. I especially Brian Mastel’s, Race Operations Manager, Twin Cities Marathon Inc. reply to the cheating “permanent bans are generally reserved for runners with multiple rules violations”. Is he serious? This dude shuold be banned from Boston, banned from the Twin City Marathon and even his local 5k for a year or two. Cheating is cheating and regardless of his “good intentions” the results were not of his own athletic talent.

Hilarious. Maybe Twin Cities Marathon will invite him back for a “celeb” spot to gain some new publicity.

*Disclaimer: I’m not defending this guy or saying he didn’t do something wrong but simply bringing up something interesting I read. *I was reading a book recently (tipping point, malcom gladwell) and it summarized some research on cheating. Turns out some researchers believe cheating is actually very situationally based and can’t really be considered a character trait. That is to say you can’t look at a person’s behavior in one context and conclude with certainty that because in he cheated there that he did will or might in other situations.

Also http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Situationism.

I’m sure there is at least one psychologist on this group who can comment.

Ah, but I’m sure there are other “theories” and studies that refute that and state the opposite (i.e. cheating in one aspect of life, test, etc. makes it “easier” or more likely in another that is). Plus, I don’t think this applies to Situationism as this has to be planned, etc. and this guy has also run multiple other marathons (in the article) and couldn’t qualify on his own. I don’t have the energy to search pub med right now :wink:

You are right though - not my baliwick either. It would be interesting to hear from those with more experience (i.e. psychologist, etc.) regarding this behavior.

I’m sure you’re right and this guy is really quite noble and virtuous … after all … he just did it to be able to raise $25K for charity.
I bet all his patients are proud they have such an ethical guy looking out for them … he must have sworn his hypocritic oath instead of his hypocratic. I’m sure all the noble intentions were expressed AFTER he got caught. The race directors comments are rather remarkable also … I guess you are a cheater only if you are officially caught over 100 times … otherwise just a usual competitor. Must be quite a “race”.

  1. Maybe you missed my disclaimer. I don’t have a dog in this fight.
  2. I don’t recall saying this guy was noble and virtuous. In fact I don’t recall saying anything about this specific case. Just made a general comment and asked for informed feedback.

Just curious … how would you define cheating in terms of sport? I think clearly we could both agree that having someone else run for you rises to the level of cheating. But past that what is it? Is cheating breaking the letter of the rules? The spirit of the rules?

It’s a small consolation that qualifying for Boston is a time standard, and not based on a specific number of slots.

So, this guy wasn’t going to be taking away someone else’s opportunity to run the race.

Can you imagine the uproar is someone managed to cheat their way into Kona in the same way??

mraul … my comments were directed at the “scumbag” not you. We’re cool and our dogs are cool. This guy clearly cheated at sport and got caught. The general issue of what constitutes cheating would be too long for me to even attempt. Maybe its like pornography … but I would guess this action meets almost everyones definition (except the perp and the race director apparently).

Cheating is defined as an act of deception, fraud, trickery, imposture, or imposition. Cheating characteristically is employed to create an unfair advantage, usually in one’s own interest, and often at the expense of others. Cheating implies the breaking of rules. The term “cheating” is less applicable to the breaking of laws, as illegal activities are referred to by specific legal terminology such as fraud or corruption. Cheating is a primordial economic act: getting more for less, often used when referring to marital infidelity.

Sport Further information: Doping (sport)
Another venue where cheating has occurred is in sport. An implicit agreement exists among participants that they will play by the rules and eschew unfair measures to win. Cheaters violate the spirit and/or the letter of the rules of competition. Examples include admissions of steroid use by former professional baseball players after they have retired, such as José Canseco and Ken Caminiti.
Cheating refers to more than using illegal substances. Perhaps the most famous example of cheating in professional sport took place in the 1986 FIFA World Cup when Diego Maradona used his hand to punch the ball into the back of the net past the England goalkeeper Peter Shilton. Using the hand or arm is illegal according to the rules of soccer.
Another example of cheating frequently seen in sport is the use of non-regulation (vis-a-vis the rules) equipment. Attempting to intentionally injure an opponent is an instance of poor sportsmanship that borders on cheating.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheating

Nobel = Doing the right thing when no one is looking. I would not trust this guy to pull weeds in my backyard!

i didnt go and check the rules, but i am pretty sure boston has charity slots and if you raise 25k there would be no need to run a qualifying time. it appears to me this guy cheated to cheat, not for charity.

I do a lot of stuff for the TCM, and know Brian pretty well. They’ll do the right thing.

I’m surprised you all give a rat’s ass. As was stated, he didn’t take anyone else’s slot.

If you are in the business world and you have to bend the rules (not necessarily something illegal) to get a deal done are you considered a “scumbag”? Some call that savvy.

Anyways, I don’t know the dude or care about him. I guess I am posting mostly because I find it funny that some people get so self-righteous and indignant over something so minor as this.

btw, I believe this sort of stuff happens a lot more than you think.

I gave away my bib to the Chicago Marathon a couple years ago and didn’t think anything of it. The person actually ran pretty well, not a qualifying time but faster than my PR. It pisses me off now, beacuse people can see that result under my name and I obviously didn’t earn it (nor would I claim to have run it). I didn’t do it to cheat, I was having health issues at the time and a friend wanted to run but didn’t have a bib. If races had a method of changing registration names I would have.

Anyways, I don’t know the dude or care about him. I guess I am posting mostly because I find it funny that some people get so self-righteous and indignant over something so minor as this.

True dat!

One of the reasons I asked my “what is cheating question” earlier is exactly because I don’t think we can always define (agree) what “doing the right thing” actually is, and that these questions depend on the observer (“society”). However, observers are by definition external, and observers don’t always agree, and that because of the mutability of “honesty” due to the fact that it is defined externally it is probably not a hardwired trait (although we want to believe it is). I would be willing to bet that the vast majority of “observers” would agree that having someone else run your race is cheating. I do. But how do we feel about:

  1. Using relative affluence compared to another athlete to purchase speed in the form of better equipment and training?
  2. Living and training in a high altitude location like Colorado or using an altitude tent to gain an advantage in low altitude races?
  3. Using ibuprofen and/or caffeine (in “legal” quantities) before a race to reduce pain and increase alertness.
  4. Using another (currently) legal but potentially performance enhancing substance (such as resveratrol)
  5. Gaming our bodies with recovery drinks and food designed to allow us to train more often and with more intensity than someone who doesn’t know all the nutrional tricks.
  6. Using some new, effective but legal, piece of equipment very few others are using to gain a speed advantage.

I am certain that you could find one or more STers (perhaps the “purists” among us) who would find one or all of those items to be cheating, in accordance with krgregg’s synopisis of cheating as “characteristically … employed to create an unfair advantage, usually in one’s own interest, and often at the expense of others.”

I understand where you are coming from with the occasionally vague definition of “cheating”, especially society based. But, there is a big difference between taking an “illegal” amount of caffeine that my help in a race that you do and not doing the race at all and claiming you did! Bottom line is that caffeine is NOT an illegal drug/substance, wetsuits are legal, disc wheels are legal. Drafting is NOT legal in SOME races, OK in others. Swapping bibs, not running at all and taking a prize is pretty clear and needs little “interpretation”.

The answer to your question is simple. If what you are doing or going to do will appear in tomorrows paper on the front page, will you be proud or ashamed? I wonder if he actually took his medical exams, or did someone do that for him too? I am sure he has no problem with his students cheating either.

Years ago, two friends were planning on a marathon together. One pulled a hammy 4 weeks out. Go figure, I’m the only guy that they know who could complete a marathon with only 4 weeks notice, so I buy his bib for $20, run one 20 miler, taper for 3 weeks and run under his bib number - planning it as a very well supported training run. I ran sub-3 hours. He didn’t run Boston, but he could’ve. In retrospect, I should’ve planned to pull out before the chute and just clock my own time on my watch.