I wouldn’t get either. After a lot of use the red plastic pieces stretch out and fall off
I lost a couple buds when they fell off the ear speaker when I had them out of my ear … I now superglue the bud onto the earspeaker … very simple/ no further problem. When you lose the bud, you have to replace it with a whole new set … they won’t sell you just the bud as I’m sure you know.
Dave