The intersection of trans, youth, and sport

https://www.instagram.com/p/DKqbScqvXdA/?igsh=bjZkMml1dWwwdjRq

Or 6th, if the person who got Thomas’ slot beat her.

And no one would have said anything about it

Fifth is a podium spot for NCAA swimming. There were awards involved. So yes, while Gaines capitalized on the opportunity she still had legitimate grounds.

Also, let’s not pretend like the names Gaines was not already a household name in the swimming community.

Just reading a bit more about this whole Biles-Gaines news. Biles tweeted that Gaines should ā€œbully someone her own size which would ironically be a man.ā€

I think she loses a lot of credibility with that tweet. Biles had a whole ā€œbody positivityā€ thing where she felt self-conscious about her muscles and size and had to overcome that and had a message to all girls about being confident with their body. And that it doesn’t matter what anyone says about you.

Not that it matters one bit what I think, but I wish Simone would hold a higher standard than to use Gaines’ physical body as the target of her tweet and compare it to a man.

No relation to Rowdy.

2 Likes

Biles comes off as trashy in this IMO.

1 Like

I…I got nothing. Massive oversight on my part lol. I could have sworn I had this conversation with a patient of mine (who swam with Lochte) and I remembered leaving the conversation thinking they were related.

My mistake

Yes, A-final is All-American. For others to suggest Riley is mad because she just wasn’t good enough is disingenuous at best.

No one … except for MtF athletes and their supporters, who have a great deal to say about whether (and under what circumstances) they can compete as females.

One of the things I find interesting and weird is the celebration of MtF athletes winning/medaling.

Hernandez is not a Jackie Robinson. Hernandez jumped 5’7". That doesn’t place in a boys’ dual meet (note: the triple jump distance is actually pretty decent).

I’m curious at what point men who identify as men start taking prize money at races by signing up in the female category. One of the arguments from the MtF athlete allies is that we ā€œcan’t even define what a woman is.ā€ Well, by that standard, you sure as hell can’t define what it means to identify as one.

Again, if someone wants to live their life as the opposite sex, go for it. You have my support. But don’t go taking away accomplishments from biological women with your unremarkably male-athletic built bodies.

She has every right to be upset. I’m just pointing out that she has also made a career out of it. A very lucrative career.

Biles loses credibility with that. As does Gainers with her attempt to bring Larry Nassar into the conversation.

Eyeroll emoji

If she’d finish sixth behind five females no one would have cared just like every other NCAA championship in prior years. Period the end.

I’m only guessing that he meant the MtF Athlete supporters would have cared if Thomas was not allowed to compete.

I agree with both of you, and I think you probably agree with each other.

Yes, that is what I meant. The athlete and those who support them care if the athlete is not allowed to compete as a female or is allowed to compete but only under rules they consider unduly strict.