Santa Clara County deputy sheriff pleads guilty in bicyclists' deaths; deputy Sheriff now demoted

From Merc News:

The Santa Clara County sheriff’s deputy who struck and killed two bicyclists last year while on patrol has pleaded guilty to two counts of misdemeanor vehicular manslaughter as part of a deal, according to a district attorney’s spokeswoman.
James Council, who originally pleaded not guilty and was scheduled to go on trial Monday, reached a deal this morning, according to Amy Cornell, a spokeswoman with the Santa Clara County District Attorney’s Office.
Council will be sentenced to four months in county jail and 800 hours of community service, according to Cornell. He will also be placed on three years’ formal probation, ordered to pay restitution to the victims’ families and standard fines and fees.

It strikes me as utterly ridiculous that our penal code includes something called “misdemeanor vehicular manslaughter.”

Gotta love it when your actions kill someone else and it’s not even a felony.

did he kill them by hitting them on purpose or by being negligent?

if the latter, 4 months in jail does not seem unreasonably lenient.

people make mistakes, you don’t put someone away and throw away the key for a mistake.

The deputy fell asleep at the wheel.

Guess it comes down then to the circumstances and a judgement call. If he fell asleep because he was overworked and made an honest mistake, 4 months seems reasonable to me

if it was because he was out partying and staying up late the day/night before, then maybe not enough.

remember though that people make mistakes and destroying another life because of a mistake doesn’t always make sense. 4 months in jail is no joke. I’ve been there for 1 DAY and it was enough to make me speed far far less often than I used to =)

The deputy fell asleep at the wheel.

I think I remember this story…is this the one where he fell asleep at the wheel? If so, I would think it comes down to why he fell asleep at the wheel (was he out all night partying the night before and just didn’t sleep or does he have a three month old child and was up all night taking care of him/her?).

I think I remember this story…is this the one where he fell asleep at the wheel? If so, I would think it comes down to why he fell asleep at the wheel (was he out all night partying the night before and just didn’t sleep or does he have a three month old child and was up all night taking care of him/her?).

whoa, great minds think alike zfan =)

I do find it interesting that the deputy was quickly taken away from the crash and not given a test for alcohol.

I think I remember this story…is this the one where he fell asleep at the wheel? If so, I would think it comes down to why he fell asleep at the wheel (was he out all night partying the night before and just didn’t sleep or does he have a three month old child and was up all night taking care of him/her?).

whoa, great minds think alike zfan =)
And so do yours.

4 months in jail is no joke<<

I bet he won’t spend one day in jail. WTF is a “sherriff’s furlough program”?

I look at a picture of Kristy and Matt’s smiling faces every time I get on my road bike. Little pictures of their last win (same race–MERCO) on taped on my stem.
clm

Friday, May 8, 2009 (SF Chronicle)
Deputy pleads guilty in bike-crash deaths
Henry K. Lee, Chronicle Staff Writer

(05-08) 13:27 PDT SAN JOSE – A Santa Clara County sheriff’s deputy
pleaded guilty today to two misdemeanor counts of vehicular manslaughter
for hitting and killing two bicyclists last year when his patrol cruiser
crossed the center line.

Deputy James Council, 28, entered his pleas before Judge David Cena of
Santa Clara County Superior Court. Council is expected to be sentenced
June 25 to four months in county jail in the deaths of Matt Peterson, 29,
of San Francisco and Kristy Gough, 30, of San Leandro.


Council will be eligible to serve that time in a sheriff’s furlough
program or in home detention, authorities said. He will also be required
to perform 800 hours of community service, said Deputy District Attorney
Ray Mendoza.

The prosecutor said the expected sentence is appropriate “in light of all
the circumstances. This is a tragic case for everybody involved.”
Gough’s father had sought more jail time for Council, but he and other
relatives recognized that no amount of time would “bring back their
children,” Mendoza said.

The accident happened March 9, 2008, when Council’s cruiser crossed the
center line on Stevens Canyon Road in Cupertino and struck three cyclists.
Peterson died at the scene, and Gough died a short time later at a
hospital. The third bicyclist, Christopher Knapp of Germany, was badly
injured but survived.

Witnesses later said there were no skid marks and that the deputy said he
had fallen asleep at the wheel. One said he had heard the distraught
Council say, “My life is over,” and “My career is over,” and, “I need to
help.”

Council’s attorney, Michael Rains, confirmed that the deputy had nodded
off. Council, who had been with the department for 18 months, was 4 1/2
hours into a 12-hour shift at the time of the Sunday morning crash after
working a 12 1/2-hour shift the day before.

Prosecutors have concluded that Council was not engaged in serious
reckless driving, such as running a stoplight, and had no drugs or alcohol
in his system at the time of the crash.

“It was just a terrible tragedy and accident in every sense of the word,”
Rains said.

Council was prepared to go to trial Monday on the misdemeanor charges, but
he did not want to subject his family or relatives of the victims to
“gruesome” photos and difficult testimony, Rains said.
Council remains on administrative leave from the Santa Clara County
sheriff’s office. “We’re discussing what impact this could have on his job
with the sheriff,” Rains said.

The three victims were among about a dozen people riding with Third
Pillar, a San Mateo-based bicycle racing team, and Team Roaring Mouse from
San Francisco. The group had started a ride at Highway 92 and Cañada Road
west of San Mateo and had been heading toward Stevens Creek Reservoir,
about five minutes by bike from where the accident happened on the
winding, two-lane road.

Gough was a professional triathlete who had recently taken up road racing
and who friends said had won every race she entered in 2008. She and
Peterson, an amateur road racing cyclist who like Gough had done
triathlons, both won their divisions in a road racing event in downtown
Merced eight days before they died.

E-mail Henry K. Lee at hlee@sfchronicle.com. ----------------------------------------------------------------------
Copyright 2009 SF Chronicle

Sorry slowman for cutting and pasting the Chron article. I know you don’t like that.

clm

Sherrif’s furlough program = saving his ass from getting killed in jail.

So sorry about your friends

Guess it comes down then to the circumstances and a judgement call. If he fell asleep because he was overworked and made an honest mistake, 4 months seems reasonable to me

if it was because he was out partying and staying up late the day/night before, then maybe not enough

I don’t quite see the validity of this argument. Why does it matter why he was tired enough to fall asleep at the wheel? Either way, if he was that tired, he shouldn’t have been behind the wheel regardless of why. The negligence comes from a decision to drive the car while excessively tired, not the reason for being tired.

From the sound of the article he may not even lose his job? That is crazy! What does a cop have to do on duty to get fired? What a sad story all the way around…

well we can choose to have it not matter, if you like.

why does it matter that he killed someone?
should we punish every mistake with 10 years in jail if discovered?

are you, sir, mistake free? are you infallible?

have you never driven too tired? I have, most people have. should we all be locked up > 4 months?

all of that said

the furlough program is utter horseshit, and is the kind of behavior that leads to people not respecting the police.

I approve any and all punisher style retribution on this guy now!

I don’t quite see the validity of this argument. Why does it matter why he was tired enough to fall asleep at the wheel? Either way, if he was that tired, he shouldn’t have been behind the wheel regardless of why. The negligence comes from a decision to drive the car while excessively tired, not the reason for being tired.

From the sound of the article he may not even lose his job? That is crazy! What does a cop have to do on duty to get fired? What a sad story all the way around…

Well, that’s his atty saying they are discussing it. I doubt you’ll see him in a uniform again…

well we can choose to have it not matter, if you like.

why does it matter that he killed someone?
should we punish every mistake with 10 years in jail if discovered?

I think someone who was negligent and makes a tragic mistake that kills someone needs to be seriously punished. Maybe then, next time they and others will think twice about making that same careless mistake.

***are you, sir, mistake free? are you infallible? ***

I don’t think I ever said that I was… not that it matters.

have you never driven too tired? I have, most people have. should we all be locked up > 4 months?

You’re not really addressing the issue. Sure, I’ve driven when too tired before. But I never killed anyone because of it. I was lucky. It doesn’t excuse my negligent behavior, but you really can’t punish me when no one got hurt, can you?

I think you’re seriously mistaken here. Giving a harsh punishment to someone who made a mistake does not much influence on others who are in a position to do the same mistake…

There have been numerous drunk-driving violations leading to death followed with long sentences. Has it had any impact on drunk driving? Not really.
Doping comes to mind also.

800hrs of community service in say, a hospital with people injured in car wrecks should have enough impact on him to never do that.

It’s extremely sad to lose fellow riders, but in the end, no punishment brings them back.

***I think you’re seriously mistaken here. Giving a harsh punishment to someone who made a mistake does not much influence on others who are in a position to do the same mistake… ***

I guess I’ll just have to disagree with you.

There have been numerous drunk-driving violations leading to death followed with long sentences. Has it had any impact on drunk driving? Not really.
Doping comes to mind also.

No argument. There will always be people who believ that either the rules don’t apply to them, or that it’s worth the risk to get caught. I wonder how many of us would drive even a little bit drunk if the first offense was a 1 year mandatory loss of driving privileges and 60 days in jail? I wonder how many cyclists/pro athletes would dope if a first offense was a mandatory lifetime ban?

***800hrs of community service in say, a hospital with people injured in car wrecks should have enough impact on him to never do that. ***

I don’t think I ever said this punishment was not harsh enough (whatever that means), although I’ll concede you could probably infer that line of thinking from the post from which you’re quoting. Perhaps it is. From a 10,000 foot level, IMO, it’ just seems to me that 4 months home confinement and 800 hrs of community service is a small price to pay for 2 lives lsot because of your mistake.

That aside, the point I was making in my original post is that whether this guy was tired because he’d just spent the last 96 hours in row delivering food to starving orphans, or whether he’d been out partying and binge drinking, doesn’t really matter. He was excessively fatigued, but despite that, decided to get behind the wheel of a car, where he fell asleep, crossed the center line and hit and killed two people.

Calling Bravo or Bum whichever name you go by now. Where is your defense for this? This is a complete and total bullshit outcome. The police are no better then the thugs they are supposedly protecting us from.