Need architectural design input (new post, more info)

I posted a couple design ideas a couple days ago but here is a more detailed post. We need/want to add an extra bedroom upstairs. We have about 4-500 sq feet of space upstairs that is just an attic. We can’t build out in any direction due to setbacks.

Here is our current home (bad streetview pic but you get the idea):

Here is an example I like:

There are several capes in the neighborhood that have done this. It’s not real pretty but it gets allows for 3 bedrooms upstairs instead of 2 and we would end up with 3 bedrooms in an office upstairs. Here is a neighborhood example:

Here are 3 design options the architect sketched up. Each will have the roof rebuilt and raised although this isn’t in the sketches. I’m not really sure why we need the roof raised since other examples in the neighborhood don’t have the roof raised but the architect said we don’t have enough height as is to pull this off. Does anyone have any input on the designs 1, 2, and 3? Total cost is 150-200k and they are all about the same cost. I know they aren’t the most architecturally beautiful but I think our options are pretty limited. We hired an architect who has done some great work around here so I trust them.

Sample new floor plan:

Design 1:

Design 2:

Design 3:

Given the scale, option 1 by a mile

1 Like

Still with option 1. Lose all the fake shutters on the house and line up the windows though.

The offset door on all of them gives me stress!

That’s how all the capes are in my neighborhood. Living room on one side when you enter (larger room) and the dining room and kitchen on the other side (narrower)

#1
Someone said it in the other thread, I think, but how do you channel water run-off from the center roof section of design 2? Do you put a downspout vertically down the window? Even with design 3 and the photo you attached of the white house, the downspout looks like an afterthought

generally not a great idea to have the headboard of the master bed backed up against the wall of the next bedroom, if ya know what I mean

Did I guess right?

#3

philistine

look at the size of the house; those gables will be like a meter wide!

I don’t like the peaks above the roofline

Bump for the morning crew. Any input?

Why not just the shed dormer like the picture of what you like and not have the additional peak added in on 1? That would be my preference

Can you take a picture from the front of your house? What is your current roof pitch? Looks like maybe 8/12, but hard to tell from your picture.

Can you figure it out from this?