Movie Review: Black Panther - Wakanda Forever

Wakanda Forever is simultaneously one of the most cheesy phrases and also the name of the latest movie in the MCU. The follow-up to the 2018 Black Panther film, this movie left the cast and director (Ryan Coogler) with the unenviable task of carrying on after the death of Panther’s star Chadwick Boseman. On watching, you might get the feeling that this wasn’t the story Coogler wanted to originally tell, but the movie does its best to tell a MCU fan-friendly superhero story while dealing with the subject of grief, to varying degrees of success in both areas.

Wakanda Forever opens on the death of T’challa from a lingering disease that he kept secret from his family. His genius sister Shuri is trying to replicate the magic flower that allowed previous generations to invoke the healing powers of the Black Panther, after Killmonger burned the sacred garden. Unfortunately, she fails to develop a cure in time, and the kingdom of Wakanda loses its king and protector. One year later, we find Wakanda struggling to fend off the rest of the world. Major countries have sensed an opening to seize the power of vibranium, which has heretofore been the sole property and source of power of the hidden African nation. When a young scientist named Riri Williams invents a device to detect vibranium, the precious metal is discovered in the bottom of the sea. The discovery places Williams in danger, places Wakanda’s role as the world’s strongest country on unsure footing, and awakens a sleeping giant from the depths. Shuri must figure out how to save Williams, protect Wakanda, and deal with her grief as her world crumbles around her. Will she take on the noble mantle of her brother, or will she succumb to her grief and seek the path of vengenace like her cousin Killmonger?

Wakanda Forever is a decent addition to the MCU, although it will likely fall short of the hype and positive response to the first Black Panther movie. Wakanda revolves heavily around the idea of grief and loss, which is a difficult thing to pair with big action superhero stuff. Shuri is not a great character to base anything around, and she definitely doesn’t provide the same presence that T’challa brought to the first film. In part this is due to the limitations of the actress, but also because the character is basically a brat. She was a bit bratty in the first film, a bit bratty in this film, and her grief doesn’t do anything to help with that. One of the biggest weaknesses of this film is the lack of character arc for its “hero.” Without spoilers, I’ll just say that there’s no discernible evolution in how she thinks, so much as it seems the director got to 2hrs and 30mins and decided he just had to wrap things up. There were a couple of other weaknesses in editing, audio, effects, and a lack of character development, but those generally fell within the margin of error for a Marvel film. The Riri Williams character doesn’t add much to this movie, and is clearly there mostly because she’s getting a MCU TV show. The side plots with Agent Ross just seem tacked on. Namor, the primary antagonist, is a complete overhaul from the corresponding character in the comics; and it’s not clear if they just didn’t want him to be seen as an Aquaman clone or if they really wanted to get some Hispanic representation. His limited storyline revolves heavily on a “white colonizer evil” trope. And, in what’s becoming a hallmark of the Disney-owned MCU, this movie is all about representation. Black representation, Hispanic representation, female representation, even tacked on LGBT representation that doesn’t advance the story in any way. I’ve said it before; there’s nothing wrong with diversity in movies, in fact it can be a hugely positive thing. However, the first consideration should be good storytelling, and sometimes Disney places representation first and story second or possibly third.

Interestingly, Wakanda Forever is reportedly the last movie of “Phase 4” of the MCU. You might think that it would tie something up, or maybe point directly to something in Phase 5, but it does neither. There aren’t really any cameos or roles for other Marvel heroes, and even the single mid-credit scene only really pertains to this film, whereas previous post credit MCU scenes all pointed you to some other big plot or movie. It will be interesting to see if the MCU flounders a bit as it tries to set up this next phase of films.

Overall, Wakanda Forever is a decent MCU-style superhero movie. If big action, that remains generally family friendly, is what you’re looking for; this might be your thing. If you’re particularly invested in the Black Panther franchise or really value the MCU’s efforts toward diversity; it also might be your thing. There’s no sex, although there’s a lot of violence (mostly non-bloody), and a handful of “bad language words.”

Impressive detailed review.

Totally off topic: you ever see Shazam? I am not much for superhero movies, but this one surprised me.

Thanks for the review. I loved the first one…maybe in my personal top 5 MCU? But part of what made it great was Boseman and Jordan. I liked Shuri in the role she had, but carrying a move is a completely different task.

Had your review/description been glowing I may have seen it in theater, but I think I’ll wait for this one to hit Disney+.

It would have been interesting to know what it would have been like if Boseman had not passed. I imagine it wouldn’t quite be able to match the first movie but it would have been closer

Anyone else totally over Marvel movies etc? Like this article says, Marvel is ‘content’ not ‘art’:

https://www.vice.com/en/article/dypabj/the-mcu-is-not-art

Anyone else totally over Marvel movies etc? Like this article says, Marvel is ‘content’ not ‘art’:

There’s definitely some MCU fatigue setting in, but it doesn’t look like it’s reflecting in this movie’s audience. It sounds like it’s had the biggest November opening in history.

Anyone else totally over Marvel movies etc? Like this article says, Marvel is ‘content’ not ‘art’:

https://www.vice.com/en/article/dypabj/the-mcu-is-not-art

I don’t think I understand that criticism. It would be helpful if they had bothered to define “art” and mere “content”— but they didn’t because they’re just whining.

I thought the movie was fine. The costumes were awesome. It included beautiful tributes to T’challa. It explored the aftermath of losing the most powerful leader of the most powerful nation. My son said there were no annoying characters and he thinks Marvel is doing a good job of introducing the next generation of characters. He particularly like the cute little boy at the end. We can’t wait to see a movie about him.

The movie was sad at the beginning, sad in the middle, sad at the end. I actually had tears at the end, but I felt beaten down— all the sadness and the people fighting with each other who should not be fighting each other. I have battle fatigue.

Thanks for the review. I loved the first one…maybe in my personal top 5 MCU? But part of what made it great was Boseman and Jordan. I liked Shuri in the role she had, but carrying a move is a completely different task.

Had your review/description been glowing I may have seen it in theater, but I think I’ll wait for this one to hit Disney+.

It would have been interesting to know what it would have been like if Boseman had not passed. I imagine it wouldn’t quite be able to match the first movie but it would have been closer

I like the character the Black Panther, but I thought the first movie was massively over-hyped. I enjoyed it, but I don’t know that it was among my “best of” in the Marvel Pantheon.

Iron Man
Captain America First Avenger
Captain America Winter Solider
Captain America Civil War
Thor: Ragnarok
Doctor Strange
Guardians of the Galaxy

Deadpool
Logan

The last two aren’t MCU, but those fall within my “favs” category.

I’ll watch Wakanda Forever but will also likely wait until it streams.

Fair enough. I liked the whole father-uncle and long lost cousin story line. And Michael Jordan’s character was and easy villain to get behind since he wanted Wakanda to use their technology and riches to help people outside of Wakanda instead of just keeping it for themselves

I also definitely get swayed by the music used in the movie which is probably what drives my top 5 (in no particular order)

Avengers: Infinity War
Thor Ragnarock
Guardians of the Galaxy
Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 2
Black Panther

Though now that I write it out it’s hard to leave off Winter Soldier and Civil War. I did like the first Dr Strange a lot as well. Would probably be easier to pick the 5 worst movies. Though it’s getting harder with some of the recent releases…

I somehow forgot about Infinity War. That plus Endgame would probably be in the “list” for me as well.

And yes, this might be the best trailer of any superhero movie ever and it’s the music that does it for me:

https://youtu.be/dxWvtMOGAhw

Finally got around to seeing it. Definitely a bottom 10, if not bottom 5 MCU movie for me. It was a super hero movie without a super hero, the leads were weak and couldn’t carry the movie, and though I’m sure many may have enjoyed the content, to me it was just a bunch of talking in one location, followed by more talking in another location, etc. I definitely yawned more often than I laughed or jumped out of my seat at the action.

Interestingly the original BP was a top 5 MCU film for me.

I watched it yesterday on Disney+. I thought it was just ok at best. Cinematics were good and I thought the music and score was good as well. I couldn’t get behind the plot and story arc - I just felt like there were too many holes in it. You could really see how big of a hole Chadwick Boseman (and Michael Jordan) left - and none of the characters were good/interesting enough to fill it. I walked away thinking I have any interest in following any of the stories or characters in future movies.

Sadly, despite being underwhelming and a big drop off from the first film, it’s still one of the better phase 4 marvel films. Post Endgame has been really rough so far. Black Widow, Eternals, and Thor L&T were almost unwatchable. Spiderman No Way Home felt like bad fan-fiction. Dr Strange MoM had decent parts but also some pretty bad parts as well. I thought Shang Chi was kind of fun, but not great

Hopefully phase 5 turns things around and we start getting movies good enough I’ll want to watch them more than once. I am planning on seeing Quantumania in the theaters as the trailers look good so far. And I trust James Gunn will nail the third Guardians film (the trailer looks fantastic)