From my own experience and attempting to keep up with the science / coaches, most if not all marathoners would stand to benefit from a multisport type approach. Now you can’t blame “runners” for not embracing the bike and/or the swim, since presumably they run because they enjoy running, and likely don’t have a bike or a nice indoor setup. But for triathletes, that part is already taken care of. The magic of cycling is that it is way, way easier to accumulate long sessions. A two hour run is pretty brutal regardless of how slow you go, but from a cardio perspective, a two hour bike ride near the same HR/lactate is going to be a similar stimulus, and way way easier on the body. And once we’re talking 3 - 4 hour + rides, you simply can’t get that type of stimulus with running (which is why you see a lot of two-a-days).
I ran my first marathon last fall coming off a 70.3 focus, and I ramped from 25-30 mpw to a peak of 50 mpw before the race. My mistake is that, because I was pretty burned out, I dropped the swimming and cycled maybe an hour a week for recovery if I was lucky. So while my run volume increased significantly, my overall training volume went DOWN, and I could definitely notice that. I was effectively slightly detraining. I was able to handle the load of running much better, but my numbers in terms of “pace divided by HR” got slightly worse.
I’ve been doing somewhat of the opposite lately, where my running has been very limited due to injury, but lots of bike and swim miles, and what’s surprising is that when I do run I haven’t lost much, and actually feel better cardio wise and can nail some fast paces. Some strength work has played a part here as well. Where I can notice the lower running volume is at very fast paces (faster than 5K pace), where I’ve lost some efficiency, and also each run damages me a bit more than when I was running higher mileage.
For my next marathon build my plan will be to keep cycling 3 days a week, with one long 3hr+ session, one semi-long Z2, and some occasional intervals. Aim to keep the total training volume the same, but shift from maybe a 55/30/15 split B/R/S to something like 30/60/10 (and keep some strength work in there as well). That’s probably 1 or 2 short/medium swims a week.
Tl;dr I think non-elite marathoners / running community chases miles a bit and would benefit from some long Z2 rides to support the base, and with that better supported, a little more race-specific in the running. Fill in the gaps with swimming if you enjoy it / can handle it.
This is fantastic advice. Can confirm all of this both in my experience coaching athletes and also reading the literature. Appreciate you writing it out.
This makes 2 posts this week on this forum that I’ll be saving to share with clients & friends. 