Which bike should I choose? What should I base my decision on?
FIT is first…
Assuming you’re looking at 2004 models - the DUAL is better components-wise!
Check out this review: http://bikesportmichigan.com/reviews/dual.shtml
A better match-up to the DUAL would be the Felt S25! These two are comparable…
Of the two I’d lean towards the 'velo. Now the S22, that’s another story.
Does anyone ride a P2K or S32?
Ok, First off, I work for Felt. They are great bikes at a great price. Incredible value, blah, blah, blah.
I’d buy the DUAL if the choice was between a S32 and a DUAL. If the fit can be replicated on both bikes, the components on the DUAL have greater performance than those on the S32.
As previously mentioned, the S25 is a much tougher decision. The spec on that bike is a homerun, and again if the fit is there…
If you can find $400 in your couch, buy the S22, It shares more than half of the components as its $3500 B2 brother (frame, fork, headset, seatpost, integrated carbon X bar/stem, deraileurs, brakes, brake levers, tires, tubes, and cables.)
Another tough call between the S22 and the P2K arises at that price point however.
Good Luck and let me know if you need any info on the Felts, or anything else for that matter.
-SD