First, this is a cool bike. Everything below should be prefaced by…ride the bike you want, not what Slowtwitch tells you. And, I promise.. no 90s mtb bike jokes!!
What you need to know…
It’s all about axle to crown and head tube angle. You gotta get the bike low enough to perform differently than a gravel bike with clearance – e.g. a Giant Revolt does 53 vs the Trek’s 56m. Do you need to spend 9k for 3mm of tire clearance? Or maybe it’s just a dressed up mountain bike with drop bars. Which I fully support!!
**If it’s just an mtb w/drop bars…**The axel to crown on that fork is 475mm. The A-C on a regular XC mtb is 50 to 51 – usually 51. So, you’re about 3.5cm lower (w/the Trek) than a run-of-the-mill XC bike. The rule of thumb in the mtb-to-gravel-build world (for reference I built a Specialized Chisel with a 27.5+ fork at 460mm A-C) is approx. 30mm of fork length shorten = a degree of head tube steepening.
Do you want a super slack gravel (remember that Giant ref’d above) or a marginally twitchy XC bike with drop bars. Can you control it with stem length and angle??? What about seat height or saddle set back…Dan Emp…. you know what I mean
I’ll give you 5mm in either direction
Only the end user can decide LOL!!
For example, a Giant Revolt is 71-72 degrees of head tube angle depending on the size of bike. Bring that down to an A-C of 475 and, really, you’re on a hard tail with a Whisky short travel fork - with regard to feel and geometry. (and they don’t make the ST fork anymore, you’ll need to source it from China, try S-Pcycles).
Put plainly, it will feel like you just slammed the stem on an mtb. Put drop bars on it with Sram Axs, and call it a new cool crossover bike with suspension – Add in some lifestyle vibes and put a cool paint job on it, some dudes with mustaches, and it’s a new bike!!!
Hint: QBP stopped making the Whisky ST because of this very thing!!! (insider info, oops)!!
The other thing to consider is tire size….once you get out to 56mm tire size, do you really need full suspension? Do you understand the type of riding that full suspension was made for? Not you….swear….I mean, The Royal “you”
That begs the question(s)…do you really need that tire size with drop bars? And do you need it for NINE THOUSAND DOLLARS!!! Are you riding the divide? If so, go for it! If not, be realistic. Get a good bike for 3k and spend the other 6k on a Royal Oak on rubber or a GMT 1675 on Oyster.
The bike industry is in trouble….they need us to drink the cool-aid.
You’re buying a re-packaged full suspension with a short travel suspension fork….and a cool paint job.