milesthedog wrote:
RowToTri wrote:
This is true. But the trick is how to get people to try it in the first place so that they know it works. Many excellent products have failed for marketing reasons.
I think Nick will get this right. What we are seeing online is not his actual product launch. We're just the lucky community that gets to be a part of the process early.
Thank you both. I do view this as a little bit of a sandbox and I truly value all critical feedback. Dan, I will get something for your taint and in the mail your way! Ha
One thing I can say, is that putting stuff out there definitely puts my hand on the burner and keeps me motivated to work hard and faster
This is a healthy take on it, and the sandbox notion is why I felt it was ok to bring it up here.
I say my comments as a former graphic and industrial designer (I designed outdoor furniture for big box retail in a past life lol), and engineer. No matter how objective people claim to be, there are details that convey quality in a product, and maybe hint about how well it was developed. This is something like commercial prejudice, because given two products of unknown origin, we give the benefit of the doubt to the prettier one, often erroneously.
Again, maybe hint is the key word, since it doesn’t serve as true measure of quality, but things like curvature of surfaces on the saddle, particularly where there contact is not expected, require thought and finesse to make them smooth and appealing. Does a company that spends this effort do it at the expense of true comfort, durability and performance r&d? Probably more often than not.
I think I can spot a genuine aerodynamic design, which has been iterated on (any practically “optimized” design must be the output of many iterations), and one that merely claims to be aerodynamic, but has the design signatures of someone’s first CAD project.
I’m no ergonomist, but I’d grant your ergonomic development from observation. Yet I don’t observe surface qualities (“tension” is probably the most succinct term that comes to mind) that make me think there is a lot of refinement in the manufacturing, mold making, etc. I don’t think it would take much to get there, but I do feel it needs to get there.