YEC to Theistic Evolution

Just making this post in regards to the numerous creation v. evolution debates that I have been involved in, and to those that I have countered in the debates.

I no longer hold the view of Young-Earth Creationist (YEC) as a result of reading the Bible (especially Genesis) as a scientific textbook, due to the influence of creationist sites like Answers in Genesis (AiG) and the Institute fro creation research (ICR). I find the manipulative suggestion of “choose science or God” to be quite effective, but highly dishonest. I find the misquotations of evolutionists to make it appear as though they are saying something else to be highly dishonest. I think the presentation of a slant of a scenario to make it seem like evolution is highly questioned (i.e., PE v. gradualism) to be highly dishonest. I think the suggestion that “REAL Christians read genesis as literal” to be a perfect example of mankind stepping over its bounds into the realm of judge.

Frankly, I am a little embarrassed and a lot frustrated, by my willingness to be “scared straight” and away from something I believed to be true (evolution). I was naive enough to not know that there were many Christians (REAL Christians, too) that accepted both God as creator and evolution as the process. I suggested this idea to a friend (before I even knew there was a theistic evolutionist thingy) and was directed to AiG before “I refused the Resurrection” – as the websites like to say. I made the mistake of reading Genesis as a science text, and not a theology source … or by not reading with the perspective of the intended audience.

After some good talks with other Christians and much reading on the subject regarding the situation, the answer was obvious. I was interpreting the Bible incorrectly, and in a way that is very damaging to Christianity. My views on evolution did a 180, from an Godless, random mechanism, to the method God used to create life.

I post this stuff primarily for other Christians. The issue of evolution is something that many Christians struggle with, and unnecessarily so. I feel many are simply unaware of the magnitude of evidence for evolution. It’s a done deal. The science community has known this for a long, long time. It is both a fact (it happened) and a theory (how it actually happened). Evolution is not atheism and it does not (and doesn’t even claim to) disprove God or God as the creator. It does show, however, that certain interpretations of Genesis are not congruent with any evidence or observations.

It was important to me to post this to counter anything I have said or repeated in the YEC view that may (hopefully not) have persuaded anyone else to consider the ideas. YEC is a scientific theory that has been put to rest (as has Intelligent design) numerous times. It’s invalid, pure and simple.

For those, namely Christians, that have questions about it or about the controversy (or the history of controversy), please seek the book “Finding Darwin’s God” by Kenneth Miller (Christian). It is an excellent description of how science works, how theories are tested, evidence for and refutations of counter-claims. It really spells it out very clearly and in not-to-technical speak.

For the geeks in the room, Futuyma’s Evolutionary Biology is the cat’s pajamas (i.e., awesome). I’m reading through it now (797 pages of intro graduate text … i.e., more words than pictures)

Take care. RyanB.


Just curious as to whether or not there were one or two big things that turned you around on this subject.

Wow. Congratulations, and kudos for having the guts to announce that you’ve changed your mind. You’re not drunk right now, are you? :wink:

(How do you define “Intelligent Design,” btw?)

I’m going to adopt the YEC viewpoint so we can continue to argue :wink:
.

Slowguy … basically it was the realization that one could be a believer in the Biblical God and acknowledge that evolution (common descent) is fact. There are also things that allow Genesis to be true, without proclaiming that they are scientific. The early chapters could very well be the means that God chose to reveal history, in a way that the people could understand it. It also seems to have some importance in relation to the Babylonian Gods (Isreal’s neighbors).

To be perfectly blunt. Someone suggested that the early chapters of Genesis could be left out of the Bible and the overall message would go unchanged {stunned me at first, made a lot of sense the more I contemplated over it]. There are plenty of other verses that proclaim God as the creator, and plenty of other verses that say that “all men have sinned” (i.e., need salvation) and will be judged.

A few things got me started the dishonesty of the creation websites I was reading. I take this personally. I know what I expect from fellow Christians and this is not it. Reading different interpretations of Genesis. As it turns out, the idea that Genesis is not a literal account is nothing new. Many church leaders have thought this for a long time. Again, I feel I was misled, and I’m not so sure it was accidental


Vitus … ID to me, is the idea that things are too complex (irreducibly complex to quote Behe) to have arrived by evolution alone. Each example that has been presented, the eye 100 years ago, or the flagellum and blood clotting system by Behe, has been refuted time and again.

Knock it off, jhc- I’m going to operate on the assumption that if TT can change his mind about evolution, even you might be able to see the light on all those topics you’re wrong about! :wink:

I’m going to adopt the YEC viewpoint so we can continue to argue :wink:

Now, THAT is classic slowtwitch! Perfect.

We can still argue whether Neanderthals are our ancestors or our out-competed cousins. From what I understand that is still up for debate. =)

Funny… I was going to say the same thing to you :wink:

There are also things that allow Genesis to be true, without proclaiming that they are scientific.
I’m part of the theistic evolution/intelligent design crowd, too, but I haven’t given up on Genesis being at least partially scientific. If you look at the order of creation, i.e. “let there be light” (maybe the big bang), then the planet coalescing, then an atmosphere forming, then land and water, then life beginning in the sea, etc., with man last of all, it fits fairly well with what scientists now believe about the process. Not exactly, but way too close for me to believe that some guy just happened to make it up 5,000 years ago.

I have no problem reconciling both the Bible and Evolution, but I’m not willing to classify anything in the Bible as “science.” Science has to do with systematic observation and experimentation to gain knowledge of the physical world. While Genesis may offer an explanation for the beginning of the world that can be reconciled with evolution, it certainly doesn’t offer anything scientific about the issue. At least, not as we currently define science.

Slowguy, would “scientifically accurate” be a better term? You know what I meant.

"Slowguy, would “scientifically accurate” be a better term? You know what I meant. "

No, I didn’t know what you meant. And “Scientifically Accurate” isn’t applicable either. There is no science in Genesis, and since no observation, testing, or experimentation currently available to the scientific community can prove that God did indeed create the heavens and the earth, I don’t think it’s fair to call Genesis “scientifically accurate.”

I read something a while ago about one of the main by-products of early universe formation would have been photons … “light”. I always found that to be interesting. I’m no whiz when it comes to “space stuff” , so can anyone verify/refute that one of the first things to “exist” in our forming universe was “photons” (light)?

"I’m part of the theistic evolution/intelligent design crowd, too, but I haven’t given up on Genesis being at least partially scientific. If you look at the order of creation, i.e. “let there be light” (maybe the big bang), then the planet coalescing, then an atmosphere forming, then land and water, then life beginning in the sea, etc., with man last of all, it fits fairly well with what scientists now believe about the process. Not exactly, but way too close for me to believe that some guy just happened to make it up 5,000 years ago. "

I see that Genesis reports the following events:

Day 1: God created light; Evening then morning happens
Day 2: Evening and morning again
Day 3: God creates plants
Day 4: God creates sun, moon, stars

So, what was causing the light on the first day? What separated evening and morning on the first three days? What did the plants use for survival on day 3 before sunlight existed? Think that fits well with what scientists believe?

The point of this belief system is not that Genesis is to be taken literally, but that Genesis can be reconciled with science. The term “day” is not to be taken so literally as to mean a 24hr day. The point is that God could have done the things described in Genesis by the processes we now refer to as evolution or various other scientific theories.

Oh, by the way, your own post says God created light on the first day so what’s your deal with the plants? "

“What did the plants use for survival on day 3 before sunlight existed?”

The point of this belief system is not that Genesis is to be taken literally, but that Genesis can be reconciled with science.

Pick a side already. Did you know what Bill meant or didn’t you?

“Pick a side already.”

Bite me. :wink:

I don’t know what Bill meant, which is why I wrote “I did not know what you meant.” I will restate my position again. I have no problem reconciling the idea that God created the Earth as described in Genesis with the theories about creation that many scientists believe. In other words, I think it’s quite possible that God created man, but that the process was evolution. I don’t think this diminishes God, but rather shows a subtlety and magnificence that is far more compelling than the idea that , whoosh, there was a guy named Adam. However, all that doesn’t mean that Genesis is scientific or even scientifically accurate, since nothing in Genesis can be scientifically proven with current technology or methodology. It just means that I have no problem accepting both the scientific and faith based explanations for creation as complementary.

"Oh, by the way, your own post says God created light on the first day so what’s your deal with the plants? "

I guess I’m disappointed that Genesis doesn’t say something like “and God created light in that portion of the visible spectrum that plants use in photosynthesis, and caused it to turn on and off on a regular basis”.

"I guess I’m disappointed that Genesis doesn’t say something like “and God created light in that portion of the visible spectrum that plants use in photosynthesis, and caused it to turn on and off on a regular basis”. "

Well, the Bible isn’t a third grade general science text. It’s a collection of religious writings. My point is that it is possible to believe both the faith based teachings of the Bible, and the science of man without being contradictory.

I don’t know what Bill meant

Then I don’t know why you’re trying to explain to Ken what the point of Bill’s belief system is.

Since I think I do know what Bill meant, I’ll go ahead and try to rephrase for him.

The point isn’t that Genesis is a science text, or based in science, or that what it says about Creation was arrived at scientifically. But it’s interesting how well the sequence of events described in Genesis matches up to what we continue to learn- scientifically- about how the Earth came into being. No,