Just making this post in regards to the numerous creation v. evolution debates that I have been involved in, and to those that I have countered in the debates.
I no longer hold the view of Young-Earth Creationist (YEC) as a result of reading the Bible (especially Genesis) as a scientific textbook, due to the influence of creationist sites like Answers in Genesis (AiG) and the Institute fro creation research (ICR). I find the manipulative suggestion of “choose science or God” to be quite effective, but highly dishonest. I find the misquotations of evolutionists to make it appear as though they are saying something else to be highly dishonest. I think the presentation of a slant of a scenario to make it seem like evolution is highly questioned (i.e., PE v. gradualism) to be highly dishonest. I think the suggestion that “REAL Christians read genesis as literal” to be a perfect example of mankind stepping over its bounds into the realm of judge.
Frankly, I am a little embarrassed and a lot frustrated, by my willingness to be “scared straight” and away from something I believed to be true (evolution). I was naive enough to not know that there were many Christians (REAL Christians, too) that accepted both God as creator and evolution as the process. I suggested this idea to a friend (before I even knew there was a theistic evolutionist thingy) and was directed to AiG before “I refused the Resurrection” – as the websites like to say. I made the mistake of reading Genesis as a science text, and not a theology source … or by not reading with the perspective of the intended audience.
After some good talks with other Christians and much reading on the subject regarding the situation, the answer was obvious. I was interpreting the Bible incorrectly, and in a way that is very damaging to Christianity. My views on evolution did a 180, from an Godless, random mechanism, to the method God used to create life.
I post this stuff primarily for other Christians. The issue of evolution is something that many Christians struggle with, and unnecessarily so. I feel many are simply unaware of the magnitude of evidence for evolution. It’s a done deal. The science community has known this for a long, long time. It is both a fact (it happened) and a theory (how it actually happened). Evolution is not atheism and it does not (and doesn’t even claim to) disprove God or God as the creator. It does show, however, that certain interpretations of Genesis are not congruent with any evidence or observations.
It was important to me to post this to counter anything I have said or repeated in the YEC view that may (hopefully not) have persuaded anyone else to consider the ideas. YEC is a scientific theory that has been put to rest (as has Intelligent design) numerous times. It’s invalid, pure and simple.
For those, namely Christians, that have questions about it or about the controversy (or the history of controversy), please seek the book “Finding Darwin’s God” by Kenneth Miller (Christian). It is an excellent description of how science works, how theories are tested, evidence for and refutations of counter-claims. It really spells it out very clearly and in not-to-technical speak.
For the geeks in the room, Futuyma’s Evolutionary Biology is the cat’s pajamas (i.e., awesome). I’m reading through it now (797 pages of intro graduate text … i.e., more words than pictures)
Take care. RyanB.