XC Ski or Snowshoes?

After a nice snow overnight here in Chi-town I went xc skiing for the first time at a local forest preserve. What a blast! I did about 1 hour and my hip flexors and quads are really sore.

What are the pros/cons of xc skiing and snowshoeing? What do people here like to do when the snow falls? Also, what translates into better fitness for triathlon?

I am thinking about buying one setup or the other, given the lack of snow here the last few years, I don’t think I can justify both.

I prefer the snowshoes over the xc skis. It more closely mimics the running motion.

Jeff

I’m a snowshoe guy…but I have never tried XC skiing…I’m sure that I am missing out…but I like the running feel of snow shoes, in fact, my snow shoes are asymetrical and designed for running…they are Tubbs, I only get out on them 4 or so times a year, but they are worth every penny and really give you are hard workout…I had a 90 min run planned for Friday, but had to stop after 60 mins, I was beat…not sure how the two compare for fitness…but I doubt you can go wrong…enjoy!

I think the best of both worlds is what you need. My strongest tri season was two years ago, a year i also got in 25 days of XC skiing (skating). But I also did a ton of snowshoeing.

Yesterday I did 14 miles XC skiing followed by three miles of snowshoeing. Today was 12 miles on the skis and 3 on the shoes. I take my dogs with me in the van and they sleep while I ski, then we go snowshoeing together for about an hour. they have a blast while I get a bit more exercise so it’s a win win situation.

The skiing will be an add-on to your base aerobic fitness, there is little translation into running muscle recruitment with the exception of your quads if you do some non-pole work or big hills. Here in North Tahoe there’s nothing but hills so that’s my focus this weekend.

As for the snowshoes, have you bought some? I recommend the MSR solid plastic models, they are bomb proof and you can clip on “tails” to the back for added float in heavy snow or if you carry a heavy pack one day.

Have a great time.

Karma
:))

I have not yet bought any snowshoes. If you guys have recommendations send them on! (Same for skiis) I have heard of Tubbs Catalyst. I would prefer a running type model.

I would highly recommend skate skiing. Though snowshoeing would be more specific to running, skate skiing will work both your lower body and upper body, thus you could imagine that it can substitute as a winter swim workout too. :slight_smile:

The sense of speed and emphasis on technique is a lot of fun too. I don’t think there is a cardio workout quite as intense as nordic skiing, especially if your nordic trails are at elevation.

Eitherway, you’ll have a lot of fun.

Cheers,

Antonio

If you guys have recommendations send them on! (Same for skiis) I have heard of Tubbs Catalyst. I would prefer a running type model.
I use Atlas Dual Trac for running (now called race/run mode). Love 'em.

The catalyst is a great running snowshoe. I ran in them two years ago in a 20K race and only banged them on each other a few times on the downhill. The asymetrical shape takes a little getting used to (10 minutes or so) but then you will fly from then on. They had a production/distribution problem last year and they were nearly impossible to find, although I hear they are back in stores/internet now.

I use the MSR as my recreational shoe due to durability. You can get them used for about $50 and they will last forever. If anything breaks, MSR will replace it no questions asked immediately, they are a great company.

Karma
:))

I prefer skiing. More fun and very good for improving your knees proprioception. We finally have enough snow this week in MA to get out!!!