Last year I stepped on a nail in the barn, went to the ER a day later. Great care, in and out in 10 minutes.
Nurse did the usual BP and questioning, Doc opened the door and said hi, made a joke about horseshit and left, nurse came in and gave me the shot, I left.
Come to find out a month later that the entire bill was $379.00 - what the hell?
You’re not being charged for “just” a tetanus shot. If it were just that, you could mail order it and give it to yourself. You are paying for a tetanus shot in an emergency department.
You’re also paying for access to care - the ability to get a tetanus shot 7 days a week, 24 hours a day, holidays included.
You’re also paying for access to advanced care - not just the ability to get a tetanus shot, but to get lifesaving care from a trained and licensed team of professionals at any time. This means access to a full service pharmacy with pharmacists, radiology department with technologists and radiologists, laboratory services . . . all 24 hours a day, etc, ad nauseum.
You’re also paying for everyone else’s access to care - all those people who don’t pay but use the ER for their emergent and non-emergent problems.
You’re also paying for the malpractice exposure associated with both your injury and every other person’s injury.
It’s not cheap to run an emergency department because they have to build in the capacity for every major life-threatening event, whether or not it happens. You pay for the existence of this capacity.
Example - every ED should have a cyanide antidote kit on hand. These expire every 3 years or so, and are killer expensive. Cyanide poisoning is extremely rare, but when it does happen the victim can be saved with the kit - and you have to have it there. It doesn’t help to order up from Eli Lilly the next day. So, who pays for that? Do we keep a running tally of how many kits have expired before we use one, and then charge the first person who needs that particular medication the cost of all those other kits? Instead, we spread around the cost to everyone else who comes through the door.
Who pays for our decomtamination showers, to be used in the event of a chemical accident or attack?
Who pays for the homeless guy who fell down and cut his hand, and needs a tetanus shot?
that was as fine an answer as one could ever hope to find here in the LR…
It begs, however, for answers to the questions which should arise from it. (edit to add) I am also to blame here, in retrospect, I could have kept costs down (to my insurance) by dashing into the local clinic, or by (given the nature of my life) having kept up on immunization.
I did notify the insurance co. that the Dr. had overcharged. He billed a code xxx-xx, which implys a through exam and questioning (by the doc himself, took me hours of interweb research to learn this)…this did not occur. I consider that to be a blatant rip-off.
Overhead !!! when people sue deep pockets . They charge the little guy to make up the cost . You’re just paying off someones settlement , they will get the next guy .
that was as fine an answer as one could ever hope to find here in the LR…
It begs, however, for answers to the questions which should arise from it. (edit to add) I am also to blame here, in retrospect, I could have kept costs down (to my insurance) by dashing into the local clinic, or by (given the nature of my life) having kept up on immunization.
I did notify the insurance co. that the Dr. had overcharged. He billed a code xxx-xx, which implys a through exam and questioning (by the doc himself, took me hours of interweb research to learn this)…this did not occur. I consider that to be a blatant rip-off.
It probably is a rip-off; however, these codes are generally reached by various levels of documentation of an exam and history taking, which a “savvy” physician could probably do in about 2 minutes.
I think that’s an inevitable consequence of the current billing system - and an argument for moving to integrated health care systems with salaried physicians.
I think that’s an inevitable consequence of the current billing system - and an argument for moving to integrated health care systems with salaried physicians.
why do you hate America?
In my case here, the physician did absolutely nothing than open the door, stick his head in and make a joke. This is unmitigated bullshit - or perhaps truly a “savvy” physician.
Wouldn’t have cost me anything here in Canada. My government health insurance would cover the cost. So somebody tell me once again why US style private health care is so great and wonderful.
My understanding was he didn’t pay, his insurance did.
** I am also to blame here, in retrospect, I could have kept costs down (to my insurance) by dashing into the local clinic**
My question is this: did the doctor or other healthcare official tell you the price before you accepted their procedure?
When you take your car in for repairs, don’t they call you with an estimate before proceding?
When will you people get that the way business is done in the ED is NOTHING NOTHING NOTHING like that in a PC environment. As stated, the over head is HUGE. PC for obvious reasons dont make as much money as ED folks, trauma nurses, full time staff of the best of the best…when a PC and a CNA can easily handle the shot in the back of a Buick if need be.
Although I agree with your assessment there is little doubt there’s a WHOLE bunch of fat in the system.
I think someone would be off base to believe that their cost should be “Cost of doc for “X” time + cost of shot”. Often people walk away with the impression that this is the way it should be and the doc is making 4700$ and hour (See dock for 5 minute, shot cost 395$ =4740$ and the shot itself cost 40$)
In reality, as you point out, you are paying for FAR more. However there is MUCH that the individual is paying for that is indeed WAY overpriced and or unnecessary entirely. In most cases alot of that has to do with malpractice insurance, regulation and CYA.
It happened a year ago and you are still thinking about it? You might want to learn to let some things go.
I agree with everything that DKV said.
You probably would have been charged around $120 at most if you would have done this at your Family Physician office. The difference is you are paying for the convenience of 24 hour care by going to the ER. If the Dr has to write a script or give an injection it is usually at least a level 3 ER charge so you are looking at $350 minimum. Any time you can go to your DR vrs the ER it is highly recommended.
Although I agree with your assessment there is little doubt there’s a WHOLE bunch of fat in the system. . . In most cases alot of that has to do with malpractice insurance, regulation and CYA.
I don’t know if I would characterize that as fat. Fat implies that there are people around not doing any work and getting paid for it.
What you describe sounds like inefficiencies, mostly as a consequence of external forces.