What's up with the "I can't do a 1/2 IM before IM" Mindset?

People always ask this question: “Should I do a 1/2 IM four weeks/two weeks/six weeks before IM?”

I don’t know, is it just me? Come on… UMMMM YES!!

Maybe I am missing something, so fill me in- but it is as though they have this mental image that doing the race this close to Ironman will somehow compromise their Ironman perfromance- that they will not *get *fitness from the workout but somehow lose fitness or become so fatigued they won’t have a good IM performance.

Now, obviously everybody is different, but I like to bang out a fast 1/2 IM 2-3 weeks before IM, recover, do one more long workout a week out and then rest for the race/trip. That’s just me.

But am I the only one who notices the frequency of this questions? I don’t understand the mindset behind it. Specifically- what do people think will happen?

I don’t know what’s up with that either. I like to schedule a HIM 3-4 weeks before an IM.

I’m not saying whether its right or wrong - but here’s my thinking:

The last 4-6 weeks before your taper is the key period when you should be doing IM specific training - lots of it - day in and day out. Resting for and recovering from a hard half IM will only detract from the training you should be doing…

Do you freshen up for the 1/2 IM with a 1-2 week taper? If so you lose 1-2 weeks of key training that should be going on in the last 6-8 weeks.

How long is the recovery from a half IM - if I race hard - I like to take a week off/super easy - esp. the run.

Do you race the half at half pace or full IM pace? Do you take it easy on the run? Few lack the discipline to not race 100%.

So I’d say - do not freshen much at all - maybe 2-3 days easy before the half IM race - have a scheduled easy week after the half IM. If the half is 3 weeks out - then just do easy week and 2 taper weeks. If its 6 weeks out - you have easy week - 2-3 good weeks and 2-3 taper weeks. I don’t think 4 or 5 weeks out works well. You also need to realize that you’ll be racing the half IM tired so do not let a slightly slower result depress you…then you’ll compensate by overtraining right before your full IM and you’ll have a horrible full IM…

Dave

You make an interesting set of points. I was especially interested in your comment about resting up before the 1/2 IM.

I would suggest, in my view, that the 1/2 IM is raced, and raced well- but as a training day. That is, you aren’t doing things for the race (1/2 IM) to optimize your performance in that race- like tapering. You just go to the race, get the workout in as a tempo workout, race rehearsal and then allow for recovery. Job done. Also, the recovery should be proactive: Massage, sleep, nutrition very focused and dialed.

Also, I am a little out of the loop here because I have never been a big one for long tapers. A friend of mine who has done the Tour de France 9 times said “In 48 hours you are loosing fitness”. I agree with him to a degree. I think a long, long taper is detrimental.

I don’t think you should do a 120 mile/18 mile brick the Sunday before Ironman (for most of us) but maybe two weeks before (sorry Francois).

Anyway- interesting thoughts during the preparation of our course curriculum for Ironman training.

In Kona 2003 I saw Stadler and Zack out on the Queen K the sat before the race. A couple of days later Zack was in a bike shop where I was and I over-heard that he and Stadler had ridden the course at an average of 40kph (not a breath of wind that day) and then got off and run 5 miles at 6 min miles! From there on to race day it was pretty solid rest.

Personally my only experience of a half leading in to a full was Tauranga (Jan 2) pre Taupo (March 3). Personally I found this excellent. A couple of days rest pre the half and then a very hard race. This gave a good indicator of where the fitness was at and areas to work on. Don’t know that I would want to do one much closer than that or if I did it would be very much a training day rather than a race, in which case I would probably rather do a Half Ironman simulation either solo or with a couple of friends. This would esp be the case if there wasn’t a race within a couple of hours of where I was. Certainly wouldn’t want to deal with the hassle of a days travel either way to a race that was only a training day.

“I would suggest, in my view, that the 1/2 IM is raced, and raced well- but as a training day. That is, you aren’t doing things for the race (1/2 IM) to optimize your performance in that race- like tapering. You just go to the race, get the workout in as a tempo workout, race rehearsal and then allow for recovery. Job done.”

I think the problem most people run into, myself included, is that it is hard once you are in an actual race to “get the workout in as a tempo.” Rather once those competitve juices start flowing and the clock is running, all that tempo stuff goes out the window and it is a race. For this reason, I think its good to do a 1/2 IM distance workout 3-4 weeks before the IM, but not in an actual race. Rather, set up a workout with some friends in an environment where you won’t be as competitive and won’t beat yourself up as much.

I think it boils down to Race a HIM or do a HIM.

IF you’re really racing any distance that means you put everything you had into it adn even if that’s a 5K it takes something out of you, more than just a regular workout.

I think it’s a good idea to DO a HIM 5-6 weeks out, but not RACE one.

~Matt

People always ask this question: “Should I do a 1/2 IM four weeks/two weeks/six weeks before IM?”

I don’t know, is it just me? Come on… UMMMM YES!!

I thinks it boils down to ‘how fit for an Ironman’ a person is. If you are really fit for an Ironman I think racing a half-Ironman up to 3 weeks (and even 2) prior the IM is a good thing. Allows you to test IM gear in a fast semi-long brick.

If a person’s goal is only to finish, and still afraid of the distance, than obviously a half ironman might require more thinking, may be no more than 4 weeks ahead, and may be just doing the distance and not racing it.

I used to need 2 weeks to recover from a half ironman. Now that I am fitter, 2-3 easy days is all I need.

Francois in Montreal

Tom - I agree with your thinking. That is why we place the Steelhead race in early August - to give athletes racing in Wisconsin a chance to race a 1/2 six weeks out from the Ironman. We have lots of athletes that do just that! Z

Tom … i’ll have athletes disucss doing a Half IM anywhere from 2-6+ weeks out. I don’t have any problem with them doing the event … we just set goals based on fitness, what the IM goals are, what the Half IM course is, etc. … i agree, at worst it’s a good race rehearsal and training day. (provided recovery vs. how tired you were entering the race / fatigue from the race is taken seriously)

Good thread!

That’s another reason I think Steelhead is in a perfect place on the calender.

If the schedules lined up such that this was possible, my thought would be…I’m already dropping $400+ on Ironman entry fees, plus any travel that’s necessary. I really don’t see the purpose in dropping $150 for race entry fees (plus any travel) to do a “workout”. I like to select a few races per year and show up ready to do my best, I don’t do any “B” races.

I had the same consideration with a marathon that finished about 1/2mile from my house last month…yeah it would be neat to go do it as a workout, but why pay $90 to run the same workout (on the same roads in this case) as I could do anytime for free.

But that’s just me, and I’m a cheap bastard.

I’ve done 1/2s anywhere from 4 to 6 weeks out, and the farther out I do them, the faster I’ll go when I do them. If it’s only 4 weeks out, I use it as strictly a training day-type of race, with some little amount of speedwork. Moreso on the run, off the bike, than for anything else.

In a perfect world, I wouldn’t do any racing at least 8 weeks prior to an IM. But, I’m not perfect and it’s too much fun to soak in the race atmosphere :wink:

T.

I think it boils down to Race a HIM or do a HIM.

That’s where I’m at. I don’t get to race too often, and I like every race (other than the tri-club ones) to be an “A” race. I don’t want to drive across the state, stay overnight, pay hundreds of dollars in fees, gas, motel, etc. and then have a “catered workout.” I can stay home and do that (except the catering part).

I will do several big days in the 5-6 weeks before my IM, each substantially longer than a half IM. I’ll also do individual workouts where I go at half IM pace for half IM distances. Nothing wrong with putting in the volume or intensity – I just don’t see a need to pay big bucks to do it.

Many coaches I’ve talked to discourage this based on the fact that its hard to do a race and NOT race it…I think they’re worried that the more novice types will shoot their wad at the 1/2 and not be able to recover in time for the IM…

I’m with you, though, Tom…I think, done right, it can be a huge boost to training. There are too many coaches right now who seem to think that you have to sequester yourself away from racing for six months prior to an IM…Boring…not to mention probably dulling your racing feel…

Other sports, even extreme endurance events like the TdF, see the athletes building up steam leading into that race with some well timed races…

tribriguy … i agree with you and Tom (per my post above), w/ the “if done right” disclaimer …

Have Fun …