If you don’t understand the meaning of a word try the dictionary. But the argument here is that women are less competitive than men. Not only does that argument utterly fail for lack of supporting facts it does not comprehend the meaning of competition. It is not accidental that men are making this argument.
Can you read a dictionary? Get back to me when you find a definition of competition like yours. This is one reason why people should not compare Messi and Pele for instance. Once you start asking who was more competitive you have stumbled badly.
You could take Starky’s example of top 25 and it proves out correct.
You could look at top 10 and generally looking at % time winner vs 10th and It looks to favour the men 6-7 out of 10 times…
Start looking at top 5 and it becomes a more even story…
Start looking at the winners time vs course record and it favours the women.
Easy to argue that maybe the mens race is more tactical, the women’s race is usually more exciting at the top 3.
Maurice
the talent pool is smaller for women, as they are focused on their own particular race series. take ryf,gwen jorgenson,nicola spirig, alicia kaye, miranda and throw them into a 70.3 to make things fair distance wise and call it the womens world championship
Not really caring either way, yes the talent pool is smaller for women IE less deep, but the argument for “competitive” could be top 25 (starky) top 10 (Jack) or maybe top 5 or maybe % of course record, when a female (last year) wins and breaks the CR and the male winner is 14 min slower than CR then what happened was the Mens race played out in a more tactical fashion….nothing wrong either way.
“competitive” is sort of a silly term and easily manipulated by how you define that term.
Maurice
Can you read a dictionary? Get back to me when you find a definition of competition like yours. This is one reason why people should not compare Messi and Pele for instance. Once you start asking who was more competitive you have stumbled badly.
You’ve never heard someone say “it’s a competitive field out there today, a lot of good runners turn out for a race like this” or something similar?
Yes, I’ve heard that and such atrocities as “I could care less.” Which is why I don’t listen to much on ESPN, though they can be funny.
But the argument here is that women are less competitive than men.
Show me one person in this thread that’s alluded to this statement. I cannot find one.
You’re desperately trying to get riled up over non-existent sexism in this thread.
To no-one in particular, and everyone in general,
Isn’t it great here on ST? I’m reading this thread and before I even get to page 2, the haters are at each others throats already. Generally that doesn’t happen till page 2 or 3.
I’m an old man. I’ve been smashing my fingers on keyboards, chatting about triathlon, since 1991. First on r.s.t and now on ST. Back in the day, someone would make a comment and someone would correct their English. After a while it became evident that people from around the world were using the new fangled internet and not all of them were English speakers as a first language. Most of the time we’d let the bad grammar slide, because most people with poor English skills were from some place else.
I’m a complete pedant and while I’m nowhere near perfect, language (better English and grammar) is important to me. With known English speakers, I hold them to a higher standard. For others, I let it slide a little more. If I can get the gist of what they’re saying, I work with that. If not, I question them, rather than holding their feet to the fire.
In summary, can’t we all just get along? I mean, if a person is from an Ivy league school, Outer Mongolia or even Alabama, do we really need to give them grief for the less than perfect English? Can’t we just get over ourselves and discuss the topic like grown ups?
Rant over…
I’m older and may have registered with ST before you. My first race was 1983. But I am simply objecting to lazy thinking, banal generalities, and male craziness. I have a grandson who is a competitive soccer player. He isn’t Pele but he is competetive. I happen to think the distinction I’ve made is important for all of us. I must be wrong again…
Yes, I’ve heard that and such atrocities as “I could care less.” Which is why I don’t listen to much on ESPN, though they can be funny.
Well what word should be used for the fact that relatively fat women can get a good placing in an endurance sport whereas relatively fat men can’t as easily because there are far more relatively lean men competing pushing the relatively fat men down the finishing order (i.e. the penalty they pay in terms of finishing place is greater for that extra weight they are carrying)? Seems to me whether it’s in a dictionary or not, the term that is typically used to explain this is that the women’s field is less competitive.
Or let’s say in the women’s field of a race the 20th place finishing was within 5% of the winners time whereas in the men’s race the 20 place finisher was only within 10% of the winner’s time. Basically the same idea as above, then the men’s race would typically be described as “less competitive”.
You are refering to definition 1 from your Websters link. Judging from the syntax of everyone arguing with you, they are using the second definition of the word.
See competition defined for English-language learners »
-Robert
My rant was to all, not just you, as I stated.
While I agree with your sentiment, I try to remember that it’s easier to just ignore banality than to fight it head on. Afterall, ST is just a bunch of OCD trigeeks putting forth their opinions on various topics. Some are considered opinions while some are not. Some are informed and other are not. Some are valuable and others are …can’t use the r*tarded word anymore.
Like the saying goes “Never argue with an idiot. They will beat you with greater experience”.
I just let things slide. Once in a while I will try to put forth a considered, informed or valuable opinion, but generally I just try to be funny. Afterall, the world needs more funny (and opinions are like assholes, we all have one)
I’m older and may have registered with ST before you. My first race was 1983. But I am simply objecting to lazy thinking, banal generalities, and male craziness. I have a grandson who is a competitive soccer player. He isn’t Pele but he is competetive. I happen to think the distinction I’ve made is important for all of us. I must be wrong again…
There’s a difference between an individual competing and the way the terms is used to describe the level of competition. Of course everyone playing a sport is competing but for example club soccer is typical described as more competitive than rec soccer, it captures the idea that the level of play is greater in the former (i.e. you need to be a better player to do well).
No. Your cited definition does not support the notion that a smaller number of competitors means there is no competition or that competition is somehow weak. Simply put, competition is two or more people or organizations trying to reach a similar goal, such as finishing a race first. The definition does not subsume, or otherwise imply the “quality” of numbers of competitors. The reason this is so difficult to understand is because it has become so much a part of sports lexicon, predominantly developed by males. Yet, it is utter nonsense.
If you want to say that women have a different race from men, or that a very talented woman triathlete might have an easier time being successful than a very talented man, then, yes, I think you have the makings of a half decent argument. But to say the women are not competing on some same imaginary level as the men is absurd on several levels.
As I said earlier, men are making these arguments.
Anyway, we’ve beaten this horse to death and are now simply wasting time.
I understand and generally agree, but I simply found this issue to tempting to resist.
-Robert
I understand and generally agree, but I simply found this issue to tempting to resist.
-Robert
“TOO” (tempting)
(not to, or even two)
Sorry, the pedant in me came out for a visit ![]()
have a great day and dude, learn to let it slide, your bloob pressure will love you for it.
Thanks for the correction. My blood pressure is so low I have to come to ST to get it up to 100/50.
-Robert
Thanks for the correction. My blood pressure is so low I have to come to ST to get it up to 100/50.
-Robert
Jealous!
mine is like 155/95 just sitting here, and I even remembered my meds this morning ![]()
You seem to be insistent that I am placing some sort of value judgement on the women here, I am not.
The OP has noted that the pro triathlete women are not all as lean as the men. There are many possible reasons for that, from differing physiology to slower run pace which would make body mass less of an issue in hot weather, and also, it could be because there is less depth of talent.
Nick B chose to use the word competitive to describe that situation of there being less depth in pro field. It is a reasonable word to use, but words in English have many meanings, such is life.
If we express the finishers of, say, 2013 Kona in terms of how each competitor from places 2nd through 10 finished as a percentage of the winners time, you can see that there is less depth on the women’s side:

The means there is more leeway for suboptimal physiology, or equipment, or whatever. You would not find as much leeway in women’s tennis, or marathon, as those sports draw from a much larger pool of talent than women’s tri does.
Words matter. Women are not less competitive. They may not be as fast, as strong, or as nuts as testosterone makes men, but they ARE competitive.
I’m very surprised you are taking this position…
-Robert
Or just giving y’all something to thing about. Everyone is always talking about weight, weight, weight without taking other things into effect. I think body fat % would be a better indicator where most are about the same. For example the weight of Carfrae and Ryf is about 32 pounds difference yet they finish about 2 minutes apart. Is that not competitive? Or does one need to compare other things such as height/BMI/body fat to really compare the two?
Honestly to me it is similar to watts/kg, when you really dig down to it you can always conclude something. There is a reason why the 30th ranked girl was not as competitive as the top five.
If you don’t understand the meaning of a word try the dictionary. But the argument here is that women are less competitive than men. Not only does that argument utterly fail for lack of supporting facts it does not comprehend the meaning of competition. It is not accidental that men are making this argument.
I understand the version of “competitive” they are using - acurate or not, I don’t view it as saying women don’t care. Perhaps these definitions of competitive will help.
ETA: for example, I could compete in a running competition against Mirinda Carfrae. I could compete with all my effort, heart and soul, but it would not be competitive.