Vick allowed to play in the NFL - protest, or let him be?

A while ago I took a poll asking if he “deserved to play again.” I was a little dismayed to find that over 50% of the respondents said yes. I had some debate with a few people, but those on the “yes” side seem to feel that “the man served his time, lets leave him alone.”

Now, mind you, I’m not saying that I think that it should be “illegal for him to play.” I simply don’t think the commisioner should let him back in the league, nor do I think that any team owner should sign him.

But lets say that one does? Should we leave him alone? If he is going to be a public entertainer, is it wrong to protest his behavior at the games or in the blogosphere? Is it wrong for me to send letters to his employer and his employer’s sponsors telling them that I intend to boycott their products?

22 months in prison for torturing and mudering dogs, and I’m just supposed to back off and let the man earn millions, while his employer and sponsors make a ton of cash off of him as well?

Funny, I could never work in my field again if I did the same. Maybe I should work on my passing.

Let me start off by saying, I agree with you on basically all of your points.

My profession requires an extensive background check, so I would not be allowed to return to my job either. However, the NFL does not. It may seem like it should, because it’s such a public entity, but it doesn’t. The guy pouring concrete for your patio could probably find work in his field after such a crime, so you have to think of NFL players as highly-paid tradesmen.

I don’t like it at all, the money and the public image make it especially hard to swallow. So to answer your original question of should he be allowed to play, my answer is, I wish he wasn’t, but I understand why he is. There is nothing about their job that requires them to be trustworthy or reliable people. My job requires that, Mike Vick couldn’t come do my job, but he can do his.

The flip side of that is, because it is such a public institution, created for enteraintment, you can protest, write letters, do all you want. I’ll sign any petition you got.

I responded to a blog that a friend of mine wrote asking us to “leave him be.”

I said that if Michael Vick wants to go and make an honest living in his private life, I won’t persue him.

As far as I am concerned, he has paid his debt…both in time served and untold millions lost.

That was exactly my point, the nature of his chosen profession does not place any sort of priority on trustworthiness or other character issues, so he may resume that profession.

However, that profession, is by its very nature, public. Therefore, protest as you wish, I hope many do.

There are plenty of people in the NFL who have been connected to worse crimes than Vick. The sad fact is, the NFL, unlike most of our employers, doesn’t really have a problem hiring convicted felons. The reason that’s true is, in the NFL, unlike most of our employers, employing convicted felons doesn’t seem to detract from their ability to market their product.

If someone picks him up, which they will, you should feel free to protest or write letters or boycott his games. That’s the perogative of the fans. My guess is there will be plenty of Vick jerseys sold for whatever team grabs him.

x2

Also consider protesting all the wife beaters and drug addicts in the NFL and other sports.

Good point of the wife beaters. I don’t feel so strongly about the drug addicts.

Out of curiosity, what do you consider to be worse crimes and who are these people.

…FWIW, I have been getting more and more disgusted with pro-sports for many of these reasons. Guess I’m just getting old and crotchety…hey Slowguy…git off my lawn (dang kids!).

I do my best to boycott professional sports all together. I think we as a society have our priorities all F’d up. A doctor goes to school for umpteen years and we bitch about the fact they make 200-300K a year. OTOH we have kids, in essence barely making it thru HS going directly to professional sports being paid multi million dollars a year to play a GAME and people will gladly dole out hundreds of dollars per ticket to watch and thousands of dollars a year for asscoiated sports parafenalia.

Should Vic be “Allowed” to play in the NFL? What does it matter? If people want to see him they will pay 10X more to see him than they are willing to pay to see a doctor.

We as a society want our “Celebrities” and don’t give a crap about responsibilty.

Take the above with a grain of salt…because somehow my wife got 8 free tickets to the Bears “Family Day” :slight_smile:

~Matt

Protest. The decision to let him play again was not based on whether or not he served his time or was truly repentant. The NFL decided they had more to gain financially allowing him to play again. They will continue to make such decisions until enough fans make it clear that it is not the profitable choice to make. Unfortunately, I don’t think enough fans exist. I won’t watch him play. I won’t endorse any company that sponsors him. I think we are in the minority though.
It is not about the crime sports stars commit, it is about the difference between how good they are at their sport and how bad they are off the field. Batting 300 gets you a free pass on a drunk driving violation. Bat 400 and you could get away with vehicular homicide. If a baseball player could bat 1000, I don’t know if there is anything he could do that would keep him off the field.

If i had my rathers, he would never play again. just because I consider him a low-life animal killer and he does not deserve the life he will regain once he begins to play in the NFL again. Those dogs will never have another chance, why should he??

but, my main problem with this ( and our society in general) is that most felons have a tough time in society once they are released and have “DONE THEIR TIME” and paid their dues.
in my profession ( attorney) i could not return to my prior profession after a felony conviction.
Most felons have a tough job even getting a job. whether its as a concrete pourer or garbage man. no one wants to hire a felon, and no one will rent an apartment to them either. for most convicted felons, life after conviction is hell. for Michael Vick, he will walk right back into the lifestyle he had and the millions he makes and never look back.

jana

There are a lot of issues upon which you and I don’t agree. This isn’t one of them. At some point character needs to trump “business”…I admit, the line can be pretty indistinct at times, but I don’t think this is one of them.

Regardless of what happens, I think karmic justice will take hold in a big way. NFL executives will realize he has not improved as a quarterback during two years in the custody of the state and avoid him like the plague. Seriously, to say nothing of killing dogs and lying about it, he was ridiculously athletic and exciting to watch but he wasn’t that good to begin with, and two years away from the game did not help him. Add to that the potential backlash from the various communities surrounding NFL teams and he is a HUGE risk, both on the field and off.

So in the grand scheme of things, let him (try to) play. The universe has a way of correcting itself.

"Out of curiosity, what do you consider to be worse crimes and who are these people. "

In the 90s, Christian Peter was arrested 8 times, twice for rape. He was convicted on sexual assault charges and settled out of court in another case. He played for 3 NFL teams.

Jamal Lewis is a convicted drug trafficker. He was only suspended for 2 games.

Ray Lewis pleaded guilty of obstruction charges in connection with a double murder. Now he’s a poster boy for the NFL.

In 98, Leonard Little hit and killed a 47 year old mother while driving drunk. In 04, he beat another drunk driving case. He signed with St Louis last year.

Lawrence Phillips pled guilty to a pretty brutal domestic abuse case (dragged his girlfriend down a flight of stairs and smashed her head into a mailbox), then was arrested several more times, including other domestic abuse incidents, and an time when he tried to run over some teenagers over a dispute in a pickup football game. The 49ers had no problem picking him up.

Michale Irvin. Durg charges. sexual assaults. Regular assaults. Etc.

Terrence Kiel. Multiple drug charges over the span of several years. Remains a free agent, available for a team to pick him up.

I’m sorry I asked. I think I am officially done with the NFL. = ^ (

There are a lot of issues upon which you and I don’t agree. This isn’t one of them. At some point character needs to trump “business”…I admit, the line can be pretty indistinct at times, but I don’t think this is one of them.
x2.

People don’t need to “Protest” simply quit making it the focal point of their lives. Maybe if people looked at the sports as what they are “Games”, rather than their entire lives some of the glamour would be knocked out of it. Maybe at that point some of the heads might shrink on the field and maybe, just maybe some level of decency might return.

I’m not holding my breath though, we love our “Stars”.

~Matt

Don’t forget Dante (Donte?) Stallworth. Convicted for manslaughter/DUI. he’ll serve his 6 months and be free to play again.

A while ago I took a poll asking if he “deserved to play again.” I was a little dismayed to find that over 50% of the respondents said yes. I had some debate with a few people, but those on the “yes” side seem to feel that “the man served his time, lets leave him alone.”

Now, mind you, I’m not saying that I think that it should be “illegal for him to play.” I simply don’t think the commisioner should let him back in the league, nor do I think that any team owner should sign him.

But lets say that one does? Should we leave him alone? If he is going to be a public entertainer, is it wrong to protest his behavior at the games or in the blogosphere? Is it wrong for me to send letters to his employer and his employer’s sponsors telling them that I intend to boycott their products?

22 months in prison for torturing and mudering dogs, and I’m just supposed to back off and let the man earn millions, while his employer and sponsors make a ton of cash off of him as well?

Funny, I could never work in my field again if I did the same. Maybe I should work on my passing.

As far as I know little or none of the 22 months had to do with torturing and murdering dogs. It had to do with obstructing justice and participating in an interstate gambling ring, but feel free to jump on the PETA bandwagon and obscure what this case is about. Torturing and killing dogs alone would probably get you little or no time in jail.

I think all your points are wrong and the NFL has no basis to exclude or ban him from the league.

They let drug dealers, wife beaters, drunk drivers and all manner of criminals back in the league after serving time or paying their fines. Nothing Vick did is any greater crime than what has already been accepted. If anything I feel bad for this guy, he got really bad legal advice. If he did not lie and obstruct justice and just owned up when the charges first surfaced he probably would have gotten a hefty fine and a suspended or very short (3 month sentence). As it is he lost 22 months of his life and it is time to let the guy move on from this.

If you want to protest his behavior I think you have your priorities really screwed up. There are a lot of elected officials and others (like teachers unions) that are doing a lot more harm to America everyday than Vick ever did.