I was wondering if I should take off The 12 25 of my p3c for kona . I have been using it climbs a lot better and put that 11 23(from my soloist) or 11 27 on the tri bike since im not climbing anymore and training im just going to a flat area and it would probably be a good cassette for Kona. I could even make that a permanent change because I noticed in this years training im starting to avoid the hills with coach Clark. So likewise without hardly without much climbing I could get away with leaving New 11 23 cassette on the tri bike permanently which means ill stay in the drops more and then I would have a good climbing bike on the soloist I know that the 12 25 cassette that is on the Easton wheels that came on the bike is starting to get a little worn down. Now that I think about it the other 12 25 cassette that I have on my zip wheels.
I used the 11/23 last year. I don’t think I spent any time in the 11. I would go with the 12/25. The hill heading to Hawi with a little headwind could dictate that 25. Frankly, though, there isn’t much difference between the two. I would not go with an 11/27 since you might want some of those in between gears that the 11/27 skips.
David
12x25. If you haven’t ridden the course you might be under the impression that it is flat. It isn’t.
if its not flat
then there are downhills
if there are downhills, and the wind is ever at your back
you might want the 11
but on the uphills you might want the 25
hrmm
.
12-25 will do it. If you spin out downhill, no worries, you’ll be going 60 kph anyway, so it will be a good time to rest and suck back some nutrition. Having a 12-25 will allow you to stay in the big ring for many uphills without having to drop down to the small ring…at least that was my experience and I ran a 48/34 up front, not that I ever used the 34…I just used the 48 all day, but I had a good wind year.
I rode an 11/25 in 2007 which was not a very windy year and never spun out coming down from Hawi as the crosswind was bad. And I split a 5:03, so it can be plenty fast.
Why not take a couple of cassettes, check out the course for yourself and decide which one to use then? That’s the whole idea behind having different cassettes…
You can change it without going to a shop, right?
The one that allows you to run quickest:-)
.
I’m really shocked at how many people recommend a 12-25. I’ve done Kona 3x and Honu 2x and every time on a 11-23. Keep in mind that I’m a high cadence dude too (ie, well into the 90s). I don’t remember spinning out on the downhill from Hawi much if at all. The hill where I’ve actually spun out the most is on the way out right after the turn to Kawaihae but it’s a short one.
I’d be absolutely shocked if you needed a 25 to climb anything on that course.
Thanks, Chris
11-23! how can you qualify for kona and still cry out for a 39x25? the 11-23 cassette has smaller steps between different gears, so you’ll always have the best cadence
Dev, you are riding a 48 up front? What on earth for? You are too powerful to be in such a small “big” gear. How did you come to choose that gearing (just talk about the big gear, I understand the 34)?
I used a 12/27 because I like having the granny gear to bail me out. I’m a high cadence guy (95-105). Also, I think you’re this year’s Marisol. Congrats on qualifying for Kona!
Still haven’t been “blessed” with the opportunity to ride in Kona, but if I comfortably used an 11-23 with a 53/39 at LP, then someone who qualified for Kona should have zero issues using an 11-23 at the race!
I prefer one tooth changes instead of the 2 tooth ones. In fact I usually ride an 11-21 on my race wheels because the 18 is my most used gear and I hate not having it on the 11-23.
if its not flat
then there are downhills
if there are downhills, and the wind is ever at your back
you might want the 11
but on the uphills you might want the 25
hrmm
And you are basing this answer on your experience riding the course, yes?
You know - you ARE allowed to NOT RESPOND to a post if you don’t know anything about the topic.
12-25 if you want a bailout gear for Palani or the climb up to Hawi. 12-23 if you like the closer gear ratios.
I cannot imagine a need on ANY IM course for a non-Pro to use an 11t rear (unless they have compact cranks).
This means nothing, but I ran a 12-23 and was happy w/ that.
I am with you as I use a 53/39t and an 11-23t when the course allows for a disc, and I would think that Kona is flat enough for a disc, but rules don’t allow it so that’s that.
I guess the biggest unanswered bit here, is what is the cadence of the OP, as someone who spins 95+ most of the time will need a different set of gearing than the mashers who never go above 70rpm?
I used a 12-23 (10sp) in 2007 and had no issues, never wished I had an 11, and only thought a couple of times that it’d be nice to have a 25.
If/when I return I’ll ride a 12-25 just for the safety net, and to do it, mostly for the climb to Hawi.
I cannot imagine a need on ANY IM course for a non-Pro to use an 11t rear (unless they have compact cranks).
Hmmm… Funny, I honestly don’t remember if I used my 11t on the downhill from Hawi or not but that is certainly one place where I could see someone wanting it – especially if your cadence is in the 70s or low 80s.
I’m bored right now so I just looked at my '05 and '06 power files. These were two great examples where conditions were ideal coming down from Hawi. There are definitely spots where I probably used my 11t.
Thanks, Chris