Triple v. Double

I have recently been involved in long discussion of whether one should use a triple or not. The discussion ranged from detailed technical analysis as to why a T would make no difference to gear inches, etc., etc. There is also the coolness factor as well: “only wusses use Ts.” (Although Roberto used on on the Angliru in the '02 or '03 Vuelta.) I ride a Campy Racing T. I ride a lot of hills here in the Bay Area and find the granny gear a god send when my legs are shot. Three chainrings in front also allows for finding just the gear you want. A T also makes it easier to keep a higher cadence. But what do you think?

I’m sure someone with more technical gearing experience will chime in here, but it sounds to me like a compact crank set-up might be what you’re looking for…the pros and cons, if any, of a compact set-up have been discussed quite a bit around here if you do a search.

b-

I have a triple on my road bike and use it to keep my HR down on easy days when I’m faced with hills, recovery rides, etc. It doesn’t get a lot of use, but I’m glad I have it. For racing or any hammer days, the bigger rings get all the work, but some days you need to kick back.

I love my compacts. Living in Vancouver, there are a lot of really big freakin’ mountains as well as STEEP hills - many of which are just a little too long for me to “stomp over”. The compacts give me a 34/25 to sit and whimper my way to the top after I’ve blown up trying to Hercules it. I also tried the Pantani method to no avail. :wink:

Triples: Wider Q Factor More Weight Crappy front chainring shifting/trimming

I see no advantage of a triple over compact cranks.

Now the real reason: triples aren’t cool. :wink:

I used to have a triple on my road bike and got rid of it long ago. I have never regretted it.

how do you like the 34x25 up cypress and seymour? Do you find the 50x1whatever long enough for the descent? I might spring for a compact myself soon (the 39 was getting old last year, I wouldn’t have minded putting a triple but I’ve been told that on my p2k it wouldn’t work very well by my lbs).

BTW, nothing around here is ‘steep-STEEP’, every time I go back to Italy to visit my cousin (who routinely rides the Stelvio, Mortirolo and Gavia passes for fun) I am reminded of what steep-STEEP really is (everybody there rides a triple, no way you could survive on a double).

If I get a compact, how much am I going to miss my 53/11 combo? I love being able to pedal approaching 40 MPH on a downhill. I tend to pass many who either cannot or care not to go that fast. OTOH, I made the mistake of not having enough ratio for climbing those grades on the Ralph’s Calif. HIM course - my 39/21 made my quads quiver. I suppose it’s better to spin up the hills and not worry about spinning out on the downhills, right?

Now the real reason: triples aren’t cool. :wink:

EXCEPT when you torch some guy on a double w/ your triple up a hill! :slight_smile:

“I suppose it’s better to spin up the hills and not worry about spinning out on the downhills, right?”

Exactly. Races aren’t won and PBs aren’t made on downhills.

I have a triple on the roadie and a compact on the tri bike. If I was starting from new, I’d put compact on the roadie. The 34x25 that I can get on the compact is low enough to keep a nice easy spin on the steeps. I’ve been a huge fan of triples for years, but the advent of high quality compacts has made the triple moot in my case.

If I was 25+ watts less powerful, I might need the triple again. I think somebody with steady-state power (say, average power on a good solid ride of 3-4 hours) of less than 175 should think seriously about a triple. In the 175-225 range, a compact is good. Over 225 and a normal 53/39 combo makes sense. Over 300 and you’re in Bjorn territory and those big pizza platters are good.

What gets lost in these debates is that choice of gearing is really about the athlete’s power output. What’s right for one person might be entirely wrong for somebody else.

Another recommendation for a 50/34 compact, assuming you’re on 700c wheels. I’ve tried the regular 53/xx, T’s and definately prefer the compact. Good article here:

http://www.slowtwitch.com/mainheadings/techctr/gearing.html

You’re right, of course - even compared to San Francisco we don’t have STEEP hills. But I suck at climbing, so everything is long and steep. :wink:

I haven’t actually gone up any of the locals with the compacts, partially due to the fact that I just got them in Nov but mostly because I’m trying to dial in my cleat position due to some weird knee issues - so I’ve been avoiding long/grindy rides.

The biggest hill I’ve done on them is the one from Spanish banks up to UBC, and the compacts make a big difference over the 39x27 I used to ride. So does a bike that fits me properly. I’m willig to bet it’s more the geometry/fit than the gearing, but the compacts sure are nice.

There are some few technical reasons why a double is better than a triple, but the real reason is that doubles are 'core and triples are for pussies. Me? I’m a pussy.

Sure, the front derailleur performance is not quite as smooth with a triple as for a double, and you have to pay a little more attention to chain crossover with a triple, however:

a. If you are such a strong rider that you are concerned about the extra few ounces that a triple weighs, the bike you ride doesn’t come in triples.

b. If you’re worried about the infinitesimally small additional friction of a crossed over triple affecting your performance, you need to find something else to worry about.

c. For the average bicycle rider, (as opposed to Cat 2 cyclists and 5 hour IM split folks here) a triple gives them the additional range of gears on the low end to keep them on the bike if the road gets steep.

Seriously, most people go with doubles because doubles are the big boy pants of cycling.

FFO,

For me, a triple is the only way to go. Is it heavier? Come on now. Does anyone really notice 100 additional grams? Do all the weight weenies ride with seat bags?

As far as the addditional weight is concerned, its a training opportunity isn’t it? Doesn’t one train hard to get faster and/or stronger? If you carry a little more weight up those hills aren’t you working just a little harder? If you dropped those three or four ounces, the extra weight of the triple, would you be able to give up those 4 gear inches? 30 x 29 = 28 GI approx vs 34 x 29 = 32 GI. If you are at your limit or straining, you will definitely notice the loss of the four measely gear inches.

As for replacing my triple with a compact crank, no one will convince me that a 34 x 29 compact/cog combination is as adequate as a 30 x 29 granny/cog combination. I’ve been there and done that.

Mt Mitchell, NC was a bitch with a 30 x 26 granny/cog combination. With a 30/29 granny/cog combination it was still a bitch, but at least I wasn’t in agony. There is no way I can stand the entire length of the Asheville watershed on SR 80. I’m much happier spinning rather than mashing.

I’m with you. Keep the T and keep smiling and enjoying the climbs instead of grimacing and hating the climbs. Cycling is supposed to be fun. If it works for you and is not broken, why try to fix it?

Now if its too easy with your triple, then ditch the bail out gear and go for the double, but I bet your legs will ask you why you wish to inflict such hurt upon them.

From a physiological standpoint, you can only go real hard and real deep a limited number of times on a ride. If you have to strain the entire ride or most of it, you will soon deplete your capacity and be lost off the back or in no man’s land struggling to carry on at a fraction of your “normal” effort. Your tank will be empty or the reserve capacity will be spent. The triple permits some to reduce the effort to a more manageable level so they are not “cooked” before the ride is over. They ride faster, overall, and longer while finishing in much better shape than if they tackled the same ride with a double.

Now on a level route, its a mute point.

If you need a triple to go up your hills, then by all means get one. But first figure out your gears that you use going up the big hills and see if it matches the lowest one from a compact crankset. Coupled with a 25 tooth rear cog the 34 or 36 front gives you a pretty low gear.

jaretj

Ben -

I haven’t considered a compact set up. A triple offers many more gears in the intermediate range. I could get some of the lower gearing with a compact but what about middle range gearing? And I love to bomb down hills! With a 53/12, I can push it to 36-38 mph. Anything above that and I am free-wheeling! I ride Mt. Diablo several times a year. That is an 80 mile R/T for me. I have to climb several hills just to get to the base of Diablo. Which means I have to climb them on the way home. That’s when that granny gear is really appreciated! Last summer I did a tour of the TDF. On our way to Col de Colombiere, I dropped all the hotshots on the climb to the summit. Did I mention that I was 20-30 years older than most of them? Of course, I could not hold the wheel of our group leader Patrick Junker who was riding a double. He had riden several TDFs with Robobank, Once, Banesto, and Postal!!