Triathlon and religion?

Triathlon is for people that are confident enough in themselves to be able to find their own way.

Religion is for people who need to be led.

Based on my assorted relationships and interactions with many people of many different religions and spiritual beliefs, I have found that almost without exception, religious people are unwilling or unable to take total responsibility for themselves and their actions, but feel the need to give that responsibility up to their particular god. They follow what they think is the way that they have been told god has determined for them.

I prefer to think ahead of time what is right and wrong in particular situations (ie how do I feel about abortion) during my long rides. I figure out how I should treat people (basically the same as how I would like to be treated) I think about what is fair and not necessarily what is nice, or easy to do, and I follow those self imposed guidelines/rules that I develop for me in my life. By and large, I have found that religious people do not go through similar soul searching, but rather, they simply follow the guidelines/rules of their church or religion.

I think there is no god and that generally, the scariness of the finality of death conspires to cause many people to invent a god, without any evidence of the existence of one. Humans have difficulty grasping the concept of infinity and along with that, the infinite time they will be dead. Man has concocted the notion of everlasting life (bestowed by some benevolent god) since it is more comforting to him in life, that life is short and that death is infinite.

Weak people have created religion as a crutch to get them through their own lives. Sad for them really.

Flame away, thy religious zealots… :slight_smile:

Hey man, I used to think the same stuff…I even majored in philosophy at the University of Michigan!

Since I decided to become a christian (long story) I feel like I enjoy everything in my life more, including exercise. I agree with an earlier post in which it was stated that the two aren’t mutually exclusive. I couldn’t agree more.

I also use long rides, or short ones for that matter, to think about issues in my life. The only difference is I am asking God for clarity and to help those about whom I’m thinking, etc.

Hey, I appreciate that everyone has been able to talk about this without being rude.

Respectfully,
Dan
www.aiatriathlon.com

Continuing a theme…Almost everyone does indeed have a good sense of personal morality, gained by looking inwards towards their soul, rather than relying on religious teachings. The guidelines that you describe: treating others as you would like to be treated, reviewing each situation as it arises and acting as the feelings dictated by your own moral compass; are shared by almost every human being, and, surprisingly seem to work quite well. Most advances in the way that humans treat each other and the world have come from secular influences: religion has always tended to be conservative. The rules laid down by religion are either ignored or twisted to suit mankinds baser purposes. For example, check this link to the ten commandments: http://www.religioustolerance.org/chr_10ci.htm . In this article, obedience to them causes a few issues with the Constitution, even without asking how the organised activities of our governments can be reconciled with “Thou shalt not kill”

The deeper you look into your soul, the more wholesome and loving a place it is: Anger, jealousy, materialism, apartness are manifestations of your ego, and not your deeper purpose. I urge you to look deep inside: you may discover that you are not alone and share more with humanity that you are telling us now.

Gotta go for a run, now.

I agree with much of what you say except the part about “reviewing each situation as it arises…”

What I actually do is think about the biggie type questions AHEAD of time.

My example of the abortion issue is a prime example. I have never had to decide whether anyone close to me should have an abortion, but I have spent considerable time thinking about if abortion is acceptable and if so, under what circumstances. My choice on this issue is not particularlyimportant in this discussion. It is good enough to know that I have made a calm reasoned decision rather than waiting to be forced into a hasty, possibly wrong decision at the time.

Similarly I think ahead of time that in general “thou shall not kill”, but have determined in what circumstances it is acceptable for me to kill someone. So, if and when I do get presented with such a choice, I know that I have already made a rational decision and not a quickie decision on the spur of the moment. Many situations require a quick AND correct decision. For example, if a burglar enters my house. I have already decided what that person will have to do to deserve to be killed in my opinion. IF I have to make that decision at the time, It would likely take up0 very valuable time and I could end up dead rather than the death deserving criminal burglar.

My thoughts, choices and decisions are based on what I have been told during my life anlong with my own life experiences, as is the case for everyone on this planet. Since we have all been told different things and had different experiences, we all come up with different beliefs and make different choices.

I’m not quite sure how we decide who’s right or whether we just accept that different decisions and choices can be right for different people.

Religion is not right for me and based on my fairly regular discussion with religious people of different religions, I don’t think any of them are right. (I haven’t seen any evidence or been convinced by anyone that any god actually exists). However, many people who are religious behave quite well, but some of them behave qutie badly…just like non religious people

well… first, good response. That was a poorly written sentence (by me) and your sarcastic response is truly worthy of slowtwitchia. I should have known better by now :wink:

All I have to say in reply is that you are certainly entitled to your view. No question about that. But the fact is only one of us will be right - either the Bible is true or it’s not. I hope you’ll investigate that question seriously on your own. No matter what, each person will find out eventually which one of us called it right.

So true… totally agreed… didn’t want to go there - my post was long as it was. But good job succintly explaining the faith/religion difference!

You’ll be pleased to know I don’t have a religion to sell to you, just a few thoughts to share. In one way I equate religions with rigid rules: which in the end are the work of man, not god. If you fjust followed the rules you won’t get the result, because we are dealing with deeper things here. All humans have a responsibility to examine their spirituality and respond in their thoughts and actions in a way that serves a higher purpose than their own short term comfort. They should not abdicate the responsibility for this examination to others, otherwise, whats’ the point of being given free will?. Christianity has many things to recommend it, not least of which in the way that it declares that everyone can have a personal relationship with God and encourages them to do so.

John Spong says “religions are like swimming pools, most of the noise is from the shallow end”. But religion does provide a framework, and underneath all of them is a very deep current of spirituality, which in its ultimate form expresses itself as pure love, the basis of everything, both form and formless. This is accessible to all of us. If you experienced it you would indeed believe it was a divine gift and would begin to investigate from whence it came. But you have to open yourself up to it, consider the possibility that there is more going on than what is apparent to you at the moment. To find a purpose, a sense of belonging, a deepening sense of understanding of the universe and where we fit in, is not a cop-out at all, but part of our fundamental purpose. You may be driven there by the need to avoid some psychological pain, you may be driven there by the need to understand who you really are. You may come across some very off-putting people and rituals: being told what to think rather than be allowed to investigate for yourself. No doubt you have a deep sense at the moment that there is nothing there; I can remember that feeling, but that doesn’t mean that there will always be nothing there for you.

"finality of death conspires to cause many people to invent a god, without any evidence of the existence of one. "

Was it not Rousseau who said that if there was no such thing as God it would be necessary for mankind to invent one. From a logical way of thinking I’m with you 100%. Unfortunately the emotional side of me is like that old song " I’ll swear there ain’t no heaven but I’ll pray there ain’t no hell".

I’m a reformed druid I pray for bush (not the president the … well you know).

Your “logic” and posts sound so much like me (a few years ago) it is scary.

It is OK and right to ask these questions. Hell, I think if you don’t your not thinking. I especially had your view of the the “religious” being weak and needing guidance - boy was I wrong.

If you are looking for proof of (a) God - you are on your way. That is why it is called the mystery of faith. If/when you come full circle (like I almost have), you will see that it takes a great deal more understanding (and often one’s entire life) to truly answer your spiritual questioning.

The simple “earthly” logic you are using makes perfect sense (especially with western thinking/logic) and that is comfortable - yet why the questioning?

I wish you a great 2005 season!

Religion is for people who need to be led.
almost without exception, religious people are unwilling or unable to take total responsibility for themselves and their actions
I prefer to think ahead of time what is right and wrong in particular situations<>I have found that religious people do not go through similar soul searching
Weak people have created religion as a crutch to get them through their own lives. Sad for them really.

Reading your post, full of wisdom as it is, makes me realize how thoughtless, irresponsible, weak, and sheep-like I really am. Thank you for opening my eyes.

Flame away, thy religious zealots

Not at all. I’m helpless to refute your calm, rational, open-minded argument.

Caught myself. Not commenting on a triathlon & religion thread. Swim on by little fishy. Good fishy.

Sure, you can be religious about being a triathlete. And yeah, it can be a religion. But it falls far short of relationship with God (which has nothing to do with religion).

I got religion about mile 50 on the bike at Lake Placid this year when the three women dropped their shorts. I definitely believed in god at that point.

Uh… I think that was my point.

Anyway, I’ve decided to worship my new P3. At least I know it exists.

Religion is for people who need to be led.

Isn’t atheist the Latin word for “wishful thinking” or “big ostrich”. I can see the point of view of many types of different groups (while I may not agree with them) but, I don’t understand the rationale that leads one to be an atheist. From my view, it seems that all evidence and rationale has been cast aside for the wishful belief of “nothing is out there”. Getting an atheist to comment of where the first speck of matter and energy came from is like getting a woman to apologize … it just won’t happen. =) It seems that “something” has to be out, no matter what label you put on that “something”.

Religion is for people who need to be led.

Here we go … the whole “sheeple” bit. That comment is about as accurate as saying “non-religion is choice irresponsible and childlike folks make so that they can do whatever they want guilt-free”. It’s just not accurate for the vast majority of the group.

Faith is led by reason. Without reason, you have hope … not faith.

Folks seem to believe what they want to believe and say whatever take the least amount of effort to support (accuracy be damned). Accuracy is there for those that are willing to look for it.

Most advances in the way that humans treat each other and the world have come from secular influences:

Really? Name some. IMO, if people really emulated the behavior their religious texts describe, the world would be very “peaceful and loving”.

Where in evolutionary history did all of this “morality” and “fair treatment of others” evolve? I don’t think I’ve seen that studied very often.

You got sucked in. You couldn’t just swim on by. :slight_smile:

Come on, jump in, the water’s fine. What is more miraculous, that we just sort of happened at random from some chance events (the atheistic view) or that we are come from some form of higher intelligence and are part of a plan? Atheists rely on more of a miracle than any religious people I know.

hee hee… maybe BallPrkRat should have waited for his P3 to evolve instead of having someone “create” it for him… (sorry couldn’t resist!)

I keep waiting for my Specialized Allez Comp to evolve into a more aero frame, but it doesn’t seem to be happening. It has parted the Red Sea and cured some lepers though.