If your old helmet is over 3 years old (or you’ve ever crashed on it - realistic if it’s a MTB helmet) you should get a new one anyway. i have a Sonic that i use once in a while - it’s comfortable and easy to adjust. $50 seems like a good price for it.
The EPS foam (the stuff that absorbs shock) breaks down over time, lessening its ability to protect your skull. Also, exposure to heat and sunlight breaks down the shell/liner. So does exposure to chemical vapours that might linger in your garage, etc. While helmets don’t have “expiry dates” per se, it’s generally considered best practice to replace your lid every 2-3 years. Sure you might probably be ok with a 6yr old lid, depending on your usage and storage patterns - but for $50, is it worth the risk?
I think of it as an insurance policy, and will happily spend a hundred bucks or so every couple of years to know that me head is well protected. Not to mention that after a year or two the lid gets pretty funky, and my nose demands a new one anyway!